A recent Instagram post from Deepika Padukone criticising the Oscars got global attention, but few seem to have noticed it also revealed just how clueless many big-name Bollywood celebrities like her are.
In the short video clip, Padukone called out the Academy Awards for repeatedly snubbing Indian films and talent, using a montage of titles such as All We Imagine As Light, Laapataa Ladies, Tumbbad, and The Lunchbox to illustrate her point. While her suggestion that the popular awards ceremony has consistently overlooked Indian cinema may appear valid, a closer look shows that she is blaming the wrong people.
Kani Kusruti in 'All We Imagine As Light'Youtube/ LUXBOX
Each country is allowed to submit one film into the Best International Feature category at the Oscars – and India consistently gets it wrong. Whether it is backing a sub-standard effort fronted by a star, submitting a copied production, or overlooking far more deserving films, the fault lies squarely with the Indian selection jury.
The films in her montage offer the perfect snapshot of how absurd the country’s official choices have been.
Globally acclaimed drama The Lunchbox would have been an outstanding submission and may well have secured an Oscar nomination, if not a win. The 2013 romance, headlined by Irrfan Khan and Nimrat Kaur, connected with non-Asian audiences in a way few other Hindi films have managed. It received a standing ovation at Cannes and rave reviews across the board. Yet, instead of submitting The Lunchbox, the jury chose a microbudget Gujarati film, The Good Road – a selection that, unsurprisingly, attracted little attention and failed to make the shortlist.
Irrfan Khan in 'The Lunchbox'Youtube/ Sony Pictures Classics
In 2012, the jury submitted Barfi – despite the fact that it had shamelessly lifted scenes from several well-known films, including The Notebook. The following years saw similarly baffling choices. Newton (2017) was marred by plagiarism allegations, and Gully Boy (2019) was criticised for resembling a weaker version of the 2002 Hollywood film 8 Mile.
Period folk horror Tumbbad (2018) would have made for a bold and original submission – but it too was ignored and never became eligible in the international category.
Padukone also highlighted All We Imagine As Light, which swept major awards at international festivals including Cannes, and was nominated at both the BAFTAs and Golden Globes. Yet India chose not to submit it for the 2025 Oscars, opting instead for Laapataa Ladies, which has faced accusations of lifting its central premise from the 1999 Indian television film Ghunghat Ke Pat Khol.
In the same video, Padukone reflected on being in the audience when RRR won best original song in 2023 and described it as an emotional and historic moment. What she failed to mention is that RRR – despite being India’s most hyped film of 2022 and making a global impact – was snubbed by its own country. It was not submitted as the official Oscar entry.
Stories like these span decades. India has submitted 57 films and received only three nominations – with no wins – despite being the most prolific filmmaking nation in the world.
If more high-profile figures like Deepika Padukone start to understand the problem lies within the Indian system itself, real change may finally happen. Pointing the finger elsewhere will not fix a deeply flawed selection process that continues to deny Indian cinema the recognition it deserves.
