Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Looking east after Brexit

By Professor Rana Mitter

AS BRITAIN definitively left the European Union, the government’s eyes have turned east.


Asia has a pull for Britain that comes in part from the statistics – the two most populous countries on earth, the second- and third-biggest economies in the world, and a wealth of dynamic, growing popu­lations eager to earn and spend.

Boris Johnson plans to visit India soon, with both trade and security on his mind. His hopes for a UK-India trade deal may need to be managed – India does few trade deals and its economy is famously difficult to enter from outside. On defence, howev­er, Johnson may have new cards to play.

One such card is an interest in joining ‘the Quad’, a grouping that brings together India, Australia, Ja­pan, and the United States for shared defence exer­cises. It’s sometimes nicknamed an “Asian Nato,” but this gives too much substance to a grouping that has been marked by ambivalence among its members, and by India in particular.

Although no specific target for the alliance is ev­er named, there’s little doubt among observers that the Quad is aimed at curbing China’s influence. Each member has a somewhat different aim. For Australia, its recent experience of being bruised by an undeclared trade war has been the latest realisa­tion that its heavy dependence on China’s economy brings not just prosperity, but also vulnerability. Japan is increasingly concerned by Chinese mili­tary assertiveness in the East China Sea. The US is starting to see China as an existential opponent. And India is increasingly concerned by the Chinese presence in the Indian Ocean, as well its extensive investment in neighbouring countries such as Paki­stan and Bangladesh.

Yet India and Japan have contented themselves with fairly minimal military outreach in the post­war era – India by Nehruvian inclination, and Japan as a consequence of its militaristic past which led to a “peace constitution” being imposed on it. The shift to a more confrontational posture brings its own set of hard-to-calculate scenarios.

British foreign secretary Dominic Raab has con­firmed the UK is considering joining the Quad, en­couraged by US president Joe Biden and secretary of state Tony Blinken. The UK will have only two aircraft carriers (the second coming into operation in 2023) and doesn’t have the capacity to maintain a permanent Pacific presence. Therefore, its gesture is more of a clarification that it shares the agenda rapidly building around China among its neigh­bours and in Washington – that Beijing’s ambitions are increasingly worrying for the rest of the world.

Yet, this policy will have consequences. Notably, Britain (like India, but unlike the US, Australia and Japan) currently has no formal trade agreement with China. Heightened security cooperation in the Quad might mean that the chances of such a deal lessen further as Beijing reacts angrily. Of course, it could be a perfectly valid decision that security in­terests outweigh potential market gains. Although China has the second-biggest economy in the world, Australia’s example shows that access to it can come with a hefty price. Yet it is also a big ges­ture for a major economy which has detached itself from an integrated single market on its doorstep to take a bet, in effect, that placing security over trade with China is the right call for the next 20 years.

The interest in the Quad echoes the recent an­nouncement that the UK has also applied to join the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), the Asian trade agreement which includes neither China nor the US, but does bring together a range of dynamic Pacific economies. Most analysts suggest that the overall effect of any such deal will be small, but a formal commitment does give a sense that the UK is seri­ous about committing to the Asia-Pacific region.

But Britain is in danger of making a fundamental error if it thinks that it can deepen its relationship with Asia as an alternative to creating a new and deep relationship with Europe. After all, one of the primary attractions of Britain before 2016 for many Asian countries – China and India included – was as an easy route into the single market.

On defence issues too, it will simply not be pos­sible for the UK to ignore its European neighbours. Some ministers might imply that there is little con­nection between NATO and the EU, but they have more connections than just their co-location in Brussels. While the E3 grouping (UK, France and Germany) has significance, it cannot simply be separated from the European security context, not least because so much of European thinking in the near future will be about how to balance trade and security opportunities and concerns with China.

When it comes to defence, climate change, trade, and values, Britain will have long and sometimes very difficult conversations to come with India, China, the EU, and the US. It will need to coordi­nate those conversations, and urgently.

Rana Mitter is a professor of the history and poli­tics of modern China, University of Oxford; and vice-president-elect (communications) at the Brit­ish Academy. His new book, China’s Good War: How World War II is Shaping a New Nationalism (Harvard University Press), is out now. He won an Eastern Eye ACTA for Best Presenter in 2019 for his BBC Radio 4 series, Chinese Characters.

More For You

Does likeability count more than brilliance?

Higher education participation is 50 per cent for British south Asian students

Does likeability count more than brilliance?

THE headline in the Daily Telegraph read: An 18-year-old with a higher IQ than Stephen Hawking has passed 23 A-levels.

The gushing piece went on to report that Mahnoor Cheema, whose family originate from Pakistan, had also received an unconditional offer from Oxford University to read medicine.

Keep ReadingShow less
Comment: Why it’s vital to tell stories
of Asian troops’ war effort

Jay Singh Sohal on Mandalay Hill in Burma at the position once held by Sikh machine gunners who fought to liberate the area

Comment: Why it’s vital to tell stories of Asian troops’ war effort

Jay Singh Sohal OBE VR

ACROSS the Asian subcontinent 80 years ago, the guns finally fell silent on August 15, the Second World War had truly ended.

Yet, in Britain, what became known as VJ Day often remains a distant afterthought, overshadowed by Victory in Europe against the Nazis, which is marked three months earlier.

Keep ReadingShow less
Judicial well-being: From taboo to recognition by the UN

The causes of judicial stress are multifaceted, and their effects go far beyond individual well-being

iStock

Judicial well-being: From taboo to recognition by the UN

Justice Rangajeeva Wimalasena

Judicial well-being has long been a taboo subject, despite the untold toll it has taken on judges who must grapple daily with the problems and traumas of others. Research shows that judicial stress is more pronounced among magistrates and trial judges, who routinely face intense caseloads and are exposed to distressing material. The causes of judicial stress are multifaceted, and their effects go far beyond individual well-being. They ultimately affect the integrity of the institution and the quality of justice delivered. This is why judicial well-being requires serious recognition and priority.

As early as 1981, American clinical psychologist Isaiah M. Zimmerman presented one of the first and most comprehensive analyses of the impact of stress on judges. He identified a collection of stressors, including overwhelming caseloads, isolation, the pressure to maintain a strong public image, and the loneliness of the judicial role. He also highlighted deeply personal challenges such as midlife transitions, marital strain, and diminishing career satisfaction, all of which quietly but persistently erode judicial well-being.

Keep ReadingShow less
Fauja Singh

Fauja Singh

Getty Images

What Fauja Singh taught me

I met Fauja Singh twice, once when we hiked Snowdon and I was in awe he was wearing shoes, not trainers and walking like a pro, no fear, just smiling away. I was struggling to do the hike with trainers. I remember my mum saying “what an inspiration”. He was a very humble and kind human being. The second time I met him was when I was at an event, and again, he just had such a radiant energy about him. He’s one of a kind and I’m blessed to have met him.

He wasn’t just a runner. He was a symbol. A living contradiction to everything we’re taught about age, limits, and when to stop dreaming. And now that he’s gone, it feels like a light has gone out—not just in Punjab or east London, but in the hearts of everyone who saw a bit of themselves in his journey.

Keep ReadingShow less
“Why can’t I just run?”: A south Asian woman’s harrowing harassment story

Minreet with her mother

“Why can’t I just run?”: A south Asian woman’s harrowing harassment story

I was five years old when my parents first signed me up for a mini marathon. They were both keen runners and wanted me to follow in their footsteps. At the time, I hated it. Running felt like punishment — exhausting, uncomfortable, and something I never imagined I’d do by choice.

But one moment changed everything. I was 12, attending a gymnastics competition, and had gone to the car alone to grab my hula hoop. As I walked back, a group of men started shouting at me. They moved closer. I didn’t wait to hear what they had to say — I ran. Fast. My heart was pounding. It was the first time I felt afraid simply for existing in public as a young girl. I never told anyone. But I remember feeling thankful, strangely, that my parents had taught me how to run.

Keep ReadingShow less