Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Analysis: Tax-cut talk in UK leadership race adds to inflation angst

Economists say cuts to taxes will more likely to be inflationary in the long run with benefits skewed towards wealthier households

Analysis: Tax-cut talk in UK leadership race adds to inflation angst

Promises of tax cuts from candidates to succeed British Prime Minister Boris Johnson pose another inflationary risk which could pressure the Bank of England to raise interest rates more aggressively, cancelling out any potential boost to the economy.

Most of the 11 contenders, trying to portray themselves as defenders of the Conservatives' traditional low-tax ethos, have promised to ease a tax burden which is set to hit its highest since the 1940s.


With little mention of any off-setting spending cuts, the pledges mark a further departure from the era of fiscal restraint - or austerity - that was the hallmark of Conservative Party policy for much of the decade before the coronavirus pandemic spurred a historic surge in spending, and debt.

Even big-spending Johnson, who last week announced he will step down after a scandal-strewn three years in power, has balked recently at the prospect of immediate tax cuts with inflation barrelling towards double-digits.

For some, the calls to cut taxes sit uneasily with the economic realities facing Britain. The International Monetary Fund and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development have warned that the country runs a bigger risk of persistently high inflation than other similar economies.

"(It) feels like this leadership election is dodging the key issue facing the Conservative Party: you can't have (Margaret) Thatcher levels of taxation and Johnson levels of public spending," said Gavin Barwell, who was chief of staff to Johnson's predecessor Theresa May.

The government's fiscal forecasters have warned that Britain faces an unsustainable debt burden, more than three times its already historically high level in 50 years' time unless future governments take action.

The horse-trading over taxes represents a potential headache for BoE policymakers concerned about the persistence of inflation.

While tax cuts could inject some stimulus into an economy that looks set to flat line in 2023, a wider budget deficit might further weaken the pound and stoke inflation.

"If you're looking at big tax cuts funded by borrowing in the short run then that might have some small effect, in the wrong direction, on inflation," Paul Johnson, director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies think tank, told the BBC.

"It may result in the Bank of England increasing interest rates a little bit further and a little bit faster than they otherwise would have done."

Philip Shaw, chief economist of Investec bank, agreed.

"The response to looser fiscal policy by the Bank of England may be to hike rates more aggressively, to counter the resulting upward pressure to inflation that this would bring about," he said.

While there is little detail about the candidates' promises, differences are emerging on the scale of the support being offered by Johnson's successors.

Some have pledged sweeping tax cuts aimed at both businesses and households, on the grounds this would boost corporate investment and help hard-pressed households grappling with inflation.

While economists say cuts to taxes on consumers would offer short-term relief in the cost-of-living crisis, they are more likely to be inflationary in the long run with benefits skewed towards wealthier households.

TAXING QUESTIONS

Sajid Javid, who resigned as health secretary last week and previously held the finance and business ministerial briefs, has promised to lower the duty paid on motor fuels, income tax, and corporation tax. He has also pledged to reverse an increase in National Insurance (NI) - or social security - contributions.

Current foreign Secretary Liz Truss has said she would reduce the NI increase and cut corporation tax.

Jeremy Hunt, one of Truss's predecessors and a former health minister, said he would cut "all taxes" but would focus on cutting corporation tax first, saying it would be the least inflationary.

By contrast, Rishi Sunak - who was finance minister until his resignation last Tuesday - has stressed the need for fiscal restraint and dismissed the "comforting fairy tales" of rival contenders that would leave the next generation poorer.

Keir Starmer, leader of the opposition Labour Party, homed in on the lack of clarity.

"Every single Tory candidate making wild spending commitments should tell us precisely where they're getting that money from. Is it cuts? If so, what are they cutting?" Starmer said on Monday.

Tax cut pledges during a Conservative leadership election are nothing new, but some economists warn the lack of debate about trade-offs - during a time of economic upheaval - has echoes of past policy mistakes.

In the early 1970s, Conservative prime minister Edward Heath's "dash for growth" policy contributed to inflation spiralling out of control by the mid-1970s.

"There's a strong smell of 1972 about Tory leadership candidates promising fiscal largesse while inflation is rising," said independent economist Frances Coppola.

(Reuters)

More For You

Unaccustomed Earth Netflix

Siddharth and Freida Pinto team up for Netflix’s Unaccustomed Earth adaptation of Jhumpa Lahiri’s short stories

Getty Images

Siddharth and Freida Pinto lead Netflix’s adaptation of Jhumpa Lahiri’s ‘Unaccustomed Earth’ centred on scandalous affair shaking an immigrant community

Highlights:

  • Siddharth to co-star with Freida Pinto in Netflix’s Unaccustomed Earth
  • Series based on Jhumpa Lahiri’s award-winning short story collection
  • John Wells and Madhuri Shekar leading the adaptation with Ritesh Batra directing two episodes
  • Cast includes Indraneil Sengupta, Adi Roy, Sarayu Blue, and Iyla Sundarsingh Mckaig

Actor Siddharth has joined Freida Pinto in Unaccustomed Earth, Netflix’s highly anticipated adaptation of Jhumpa Lahiri’s celebrated short story collection. The new drama, combining elements of family conflict with romance, marks Siddharth’s latest international outing. With Pinto leading the cast, the series promises to bring Lahiri’s themes of migration, love, and identity to a global audience.

Unaccustomed Earth Netflix Siddharth and Freida Pinto team up for Netflix’s Unaccustomed Earth adaptation of Jhumpa Lahiri’s short stories Getty Images

Keep ReadingShow less
Piyush Goyal

Piyush Goyal recalled that in February, Narendra Modi and Donald Trump had instructed their trade ministers to conclude the first phase of the bilateral trade agreement (BTA) by November 2025. (Photo: Getty Images)

Getty Images

Trade talks with US moving forward positively, says Indian minister Goyal

INDIA’s commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal on Thursday said that negotiations on the proposed trade agreement between India and the United States, which began in March, are progressing in a positive atmosphere and both sides are satisfied with the discussions.

He recalled that in February, Indian prime minister Narendra Modi and US president Donald Trump had instructed their trade ministers to conclude the first phase of the bilateral trade agreement (BTA) by November 2025.

Keep ReadingShow less
West Midlands Police

West Midlands Police said they were called just before 08:30 BST on Tuesday, September 9, after the woman reported being attacked by two men near Tame Road. (Representational image: iStock)

Woman raped in racially aggravated attack in Oldbury

A WOMAN in her 20s was raped in Oldbury in what police are treating as a racially aggravated attack.

West Midlands Police said they were called just before 08:30 BST on Tuesday, September 9, after the woman reported being attacked by two men near Tame Road. Officers said the men made a racist remark during the incident.

Keep ReadingShow less
Aamir Khan

Coolie hits £47m worldwide as fake ‘big mistake’ quote on Aamir Khan cameo goes viral

Instagram/sunpictures

Aamir Khan did not call his ‘Coolie’ cameo a mistake, fact-check confirms amid record-breaking run

Highlights:

  • Viral clipping claimed Aamir Khan called his cameo in Coolie “a big mistake”
  • The image showed fabricated quotes criticising the role and script
  • Fact checks confirm no credible record of Aamir making such remarks
  • Despite mixed reactions, Coolie has crossed £41.75 million (₹500 crore) globally

Aamir Khan, one of Bollywood’s most acclaimed stars, has become the subject of a viral claim alleging he regretted his cameo in Coolie. The Rajinikanth starrer, directed by Lokesh Kanagaraj, featured Aamir in a brief special appearance. Social media posts claimed Aamir called the cameo “a big mistake”, but fact checks have found no evidence he ever said this. The controversy surfaced as the film continues its strong box office run.

Aamir Khan Coolie hits £47m worldwide as fake ‘big mistake’ quote on Aamir Khan cameo goes viral Instagram/sunpictures

Keep ReadingShow less