Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

High Court’s use of fatwa sparks debate on sharia courts

The controversy stems from a 2019 case involving Tafida Raqeeb, a five-year-old girl suffering severe brain damage with no prospect of recovery.

High Court’s use of fatwa sparks debate on sharia courts

The use of a fatwa in a High Court decision has left many questioning the boundaries between religious and secular law in the UK.

(Photo for representation: iStock)

A High Court judge’s decision to rely on a religious ruling from a British sharia council in a life-or-death case has sparked heated debate about the role of sharia courts in the UK. Critics argue that incorporating fatwas into civil court rulings risks undermining the principles of secular democracy, reported the Times.

The controversy stems from a 2019 case involving Tafida Raqeeb, a five-year-old girl suffering severe brain damage with no prospect of recovery. Facing the withdrawal of life support by Barts Health NHS Trust in London, her Bangladeshi parents sought advice from the Islamic Council, founded by preacher Haitham al-Haddad.


The council issued a fatwa declaring it “absolutely impermissible” to consent to ending Tafida’s life support, calling such an act a grave sin.

In his ruling, Justice Macdonald cited the fatwa, acknowledging that continuing life support aligned with the family's Islamic beliefs. Tafida was subsequently moved to a Vatican hospital in Italy, where she remains under care.

The National Secular Society expressed alarm over the use of fatwas in English courts. Its chief executive, Stephen Evans, warned that granting legitimacy to such religious rulings could jeopardise the UK’s legal framework and secular values.

Haitham al-Haddad defended the Islamic Council’s involvement, describing the case as a “landmark” for its guidance on ethical and religious matters. He stressed that the fatwa upheld the sanctity of life while respecting the family’s wishes, consistent with Islamic principles.

The case has reignited broader concerns about the influence of sharia councils in Britain. These councils, often referred to as sharia courts, typically handle cases such as Islamic divorces but have been criticised for their handling of women’s rights and controversial practices.

Fiyaz Mughal, founder of the anti-hate group Tell Mama, called for the abolition of sharia councils, describing them as outdated and dismissive of modern safeguarding standards. “These councils belong in medieval times,” Mughal said, arguing that their interpretations of Islamic law often disadvantage women.

The Times investigation highlighted other contentious practices linked to sharia councils, including polygamy and the “triple talaq” divorce, where men can end marriages instantly. Dr Paul Stott of the Policy Exchange think tank criticised the UK’s failure to enforce laws against polygamy, calling for urgent reforms.

Haddad’s council has also drawn scrutiny for initiatives such as a sharia-compliant will-writing app, which includes a dropdown menu for men to declare up to four wives. Haddad himself has faced backlash for visiting the Taliban in Afghanistan last year, a trip he described as a fact-finding mission to promote peace.

The use of a fatwa in a High Court decision has left many questioning the boundaries between religious and secular law in the UK. While some see it as a compassionate recognition of cultural values, others argue it risks eroding the country’s commitment to equality and liberal democracy.

More For You

Radhakrishnan

Modi’s ruling coalition nominated Radhakrishnan, 68, who is the governor of the western state of Maharashtra, as its candidate for the post.

X/@narendramodi

India elects BJP’s CP Radhakrishnan as vice president

INDIAN lawmakers elected CP Radhakrishnan, a former parliamentarian from Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), as the country’s new vice president on Tuesday. The election comes more than a month after the previous vice president resigned.

Jagdeep Dhankhar, whose term was to end in 2027, stepped down in July, citing health reasons.

Keep ReadingShow less
Peter Mandelson

Mandelson, 71, a veteran Labour politician and key figure in the party under former leader Tony Blair, had come under scrutiny after letters and emails to Epstein were published. (Photo: Getty Images)

Peter Mandelson removed as UK ambassador to US over Epstein links

PETER MANDELSON, the UK's ambassador to the United States, has been sacked over revelations about his friendship with the late sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, the government said.

"The Prime Minister has asked the Foreign Secretary to withdraw him as ambassador," a foreign ministry statement said, adding that new messages showed "the depth and extent of Peter Mandelson’s relationship with Jeffrey Epstein".

Keep ReadingShow less
High-stakes India–EU trade talks in New Delhi aim to break deadlock

European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen with Narendra Modi during a meeting in New Delhi in February

High-stakes India–EU trade talks in New Delhi aim to break deadlock

INDIA and the European Union are holding potentially decisive trade negotiations in New Delhi this week, seeking to resolve differences over agriculture, dairy and non-tariff barriers to meet an ambitious end of year deadline for a deal, Indian government and EU sources said.

New Delhi is seeking to deepen global partnerships after US president Donald Trump doubled tariffs on Indian goods to 50 per cent last month over India’s Russian oil purchases, hitting exports such as textiles, leather and chemicals.

Keep ReadingShow less
Charlie Kirk

Kirk co-founded Turning Point USA in 2012 at the age of 18, building it into the largest conservative youth organisation in the country. (Photo: Getty Images)

Trump ally Charlie Kirk shot dead: The key details

Highlights:

  • Conservative activist Charlie Kirk fatally shot at Utah Valley University
  • Shooter fired from a rooftop in what police called a “targeted attack”
  • Federal, state and local agencies involved in ongoing manhunt
  • Political leaders across parties condemn the killing

A MANHUNT was underway Thursday after conservative activist Charlie Kirk was fatally shot at Utah Valley University, an attack that has sparked concerns of rising political violence in the United States.

Keep ReadingShow less
Tejasvi Manoj

Manoj, from Frisco, Texas, created an innovation called ‘Shield Seniors’, a website designed to help people over 60 identify and report fraudulent messages and emails. (Photo credit: LinkedIn/Tejasvi Manoj)

Indian-American teen Tejasvi Manoj named Time’s ‘Kid of the Year’ 2025

SEVENTEEN-year-old Indian-American Tejasvi Manoj has been named Time magazine’s ‘Kid of the Year’ for 2025 for her work on protecting senior citizens from online scams.

Manoj, from Frisco, Texas, created an innovation called ‘Shield Seniors’, a website designed to help people over 60 identify and report fraudulent messages and emails.

Keep ReadingShow less