Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

BAME donor crisis: "People could die"

by LAUREN CODLING

ETHNIC minorities in the UK face a grave health risk – especially those who require a donor – as the number of eligible donors has fallen while the demand for blood, stem cell and organs has risen, a new report has revealed.


Ending the Silent Crisis reviews the epidemic surrounding donors among BAME groups, with an estimated 27,000 blood donations needed in 2018-19 to keep up with increasing demands.

Labour MP Eleanor Smith, who chaired the review, told Eastern Eye on Tuesday (5) that if more donors don’t come forward, lives will be lost.

“[If things don’t change,] the situation looks pretty dire,” Smith said. “I’m saying it quite bluntly, but people could die.”

Statistics found only 61 per cent of BAME patients in need of a stem cell transplant found a match, compared to 96 per cent of white northern Europeans, while more than a third of those on the waiting list for a kidney transplant are from ethnic minority groups.

On average, BAME individuals wait for a kidney transplant a year longer than their white counterparts.

In 2016-17, more than 1,400 people donated their organs after they died. However, just 29 of these were Asian; 22 were black and 14 were mixed race.

Key findings and recommendations in the review included implementing a longterm government strategy to increase the BAME donation rate; cultural competence training for members of the medical workforce who encounter potential donors; and a public health campaign targeting BAME communities, developed by the community itself.

Smith, who worked as a nurse before she pursued a career in politics, explained that it is a lack of understanding within communities that can discourage individuals from signing the donor list. She believed some misconceptions, including ideas of the procedures being painful, can act as a deterrent.

“We have to start with young people,” she recommended. “It needs to be part of the public health ethos, I think, so children understand it from the beginning and understand what it means.”

Dr Kailesh Chand OBE, the vice-president of the British Medical Association (BMA), shared Smith’s sentiments and agreed that education, especially within the younger generation, is key to the community realising how important donation is.

“The outlook is not terribly bright, but it will not change overnight,” he told Eastern Eye. “Education and awareness is lacking, and it does take time. We

have to be patient.”

Dr Chand, who has worked as a GP since 1983, said one of the most common myths include the fear that care will be compromised if doctors find out a patient is a donor. He asserted this is inaccurate and the loyalty of doctors lies with the patient under their current care.

Other worries include the potential pain from the procedure and concerns that a donor is too old to be eligible.

“When explained properly, people are generous,” Dr Chand said. “But to explain it, not many organisations or gatherings will let the speakers have a platform since it is very low on the priority list.”

Last week, Eastern Eye reported on how Conservative MP Priti Patel called for a nationwide

drive to increase the number of donors from ethnic minority communities as figures show a significant lack of Asians on the list.

The Witham MP raised the issue during Prime Minister’s Questions in the House of Commons requesting Theresa May to lead a national campaign for donor registration.

In response, May said she was aware more needed to be done, and added nearly £20 million has been provided to the NHS Blood and Transplant Service and blood cancer charity Anthony Nolan for stem cell donation since 2015.

Smith acknowledged the issue had been raised in parliament but hoped more action would be taken, especially taking into account the release of the latest statistics.

“I want this always to be out there in the communities and in schools, it needs to be normalised. I don’t want to be having this conversation in a year’s time,” she said.

Harpreet Bhoot is the aunt of 11-year old Rajie, who was diagnosed with leukaemia last November. His best chance of survival is to find a suitable stem cell donor, but no match has been found.

According to blood cancer charity Anthony Nolan, there is only a 20.5 per cent chance of finding a suitable stem cell donor for Asians, compared to 69 per cent for people with white or European heritage.

Bhoot revealed the family are determined to keep positive and have hope as the situation is out of their hands. “You have to rely on doctors and people who are donating, so positivity is the only way to go,” she told Eastern Eye.

Admitting she was not aware of the lack of donors before Rajie was diagnosed, Bhoot said it is only when families are put into the situation that they realise the issue.

She also added that a lot of misconceptions of becoming a donor appeared to stem from the older generation.

“The younger generation are quite happy to put their names forward as a donor, and a lot of the time it is their parents or their parent’s parents who will be against it – the question of: ‘Why you are doing it and what will happen to you?’” she said.

In response to the report, health minister Jackie Doyle-Price said she was personally committed to doing all she could to help change the low statistics so more lives could be saved.

“To donate is to give someone the gift of life… I encourage community leaders to work with us and help spread awareness and understanding of donation so that we can break down

the taboos,” she said. When contacted by Eastern Eye,

NHS Blood and Transplant (NHSBT) said they welcomed any debate on how to increase the number of BME donors.

“NHSBT is already investing significant resources and working closely with partners to

achieve this,” a spokesperson said.

“We look forward to working with the authors of this report as NHSBT works to meet the

challenges around donation.”

More For You

Kamala Harris calls Biden’s 2024 run ‘recklessness’ in new memoir

Former US vice president Kamala Harris speaks at the Emerge 20th Anniversary Gala in San Francisco, California, on April 30, 2025. (Photo by CAMILLE COHEN/AFP via Getty Images)

Kamala Harris calls Biden’s 2024 run ‘recklessness’ in new memoir

FORMER US vice president Kamala Harris said it was "recklessness" to let Joe Biden run for a second term as president, in an excerpt released on Wednesday (10) from her upcoming memoir.

Harris -- who replaced Biden as the 2024 Democratic presidential candidate but lost to Donald Trump -- admitted that the then-81-year-old got "tired" and was prone to stumbles that showed his age.

Keep ReadingShow less
Tejasvi Manoj

Manoj, from Frisco, Texas, created an innovation called ‘Shield Seniors’, a website designed to help people over 60 identify and report fraudulent messages and emails. (Photo credit: LinkedIn/Tejasvi Manoj)

Indian-American teen Tejasvi Manoj named Time’s ‘Kid of the Year’ 2025

SEVENTEEN-year-old Indian-American Tejasvi Manoj has been named Time magazine’s ‘Kid of the Year’ for 2025 for her work on protecting senior citizens from online scams.

Manoj, from Frisco, Texas, created an innovation called ‘Shield Seniors’, a website designed to help people over 60 identify and report fraudulent messages and emails.

Keep ReadingShow less
Mark Rowley

Met chief Sir Mark Rowley (Photo: Getty Images)

Police watchdog calls for end to recording non-crime hate incidents

THE head of the police inspectorate has said that non-crime hate incidents should be scrapped, arguing that officers must draw a clear line between what is offensive and what is criminal.

Sir Andy Cooke, His Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Constabulary, made the comments as he released his annual report on the state of policing in England and Wales. He said that while much of the public expect officers to tackle serious crime and anti-social behaviour, too much time is being spent on matters that do not amount to criminality.

Keep ReadingShow less
 University of Kent

The Office for Students welcomed the move, saying more universities may look at mergers as many face financial difficulties. (Photo credit: University of Kent)

University of Kent

Kent and Greenwich to merge into UK’s first regional university group

THE UNIVERSITIES of Kent and Greenwich will merge in 2026 to form the UK’s first regional “super-university”.

The new institution, to be called the London and South East University Group, will have one vice-chancellor and around 50,000 students, the BBC reported.

Keep ReadingShow less
British Sikh MPs

Sardar Tarlochan Singh

British Sikh MPs asked to preserve Maharaja Ranjit Singh’s legacy

FORMER Indian lawmaker Sardar Tarlochan Singh has urged British Sikh MPs and peers to commission proper research into the scattered treasures of Maharaja Ranjit Singh so they can be catalogued and preserved in a museum for future generations.

The 92-year-old former Rajya Sabha (Upper House of Indian parliament) MP and former chairman of the National Commission for Minorities was speaking at an event hosted in his honour by the British Sikh Association at the House of Lords in London on Monday (8).

Keep ReadingShow less