Skip to content 
Search

Latest Stories

Wes Streeting says mental health conditions are overdiagnosed, sparks debate

Streeting’s remarks on overdiagnosis have added fuel to the debate on mental health and welfare in the UK

Wes Streeting says mental health conditions are overdiagnosed, sparks debate

Streeting’s comments have drawn a mixed response

Getty Images

Health Secretary Wes Streeting has sparked controversy by suggesting that mental health conditions are being overdiagnosed, leading to too many people being "written off." Streeting’s comments, made during an appearance on the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, coincide with the government’s preparations to introduce significant welfare reforms aimed at reducing the benefits bill.

Streeting’s remarks come as more than half of the rise in working-age disability claims since the Covid pandemic is attributed to mental health or behavioural conditions, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies. The government is expected to tighten eligibility criteria for Personal Independence Payments (PIP), the primary benefit for working-age adults with long-term disabilities.


PIP provides crucial support for individuals living with physical or mental health conditions, helping them cover extra costs related to their condition. According to the Office for Budget Responsibility, spending on PIP is projected to nearly double to £34 billion by 2029-30.

Mental health overdiagnosis: A controversial issue

Wes Streeting Youtube / The London Standard

When asked if he agreed with experts warning of overdiagnosis of mental health conditions, Streeting said: "I agree with that point about overdiagnosis." He acknowledged that mental health exists on a spectrum and added that many people were not receiving the support they need, while some were being overdiagnosed and prematurely written off.

Streeting’s comments have drawn a mixed response. Mental health charity Mind warned that language around diagnosis must be handled carefully to avoid stigmatising people with mental health issues. Minesh Patel, associate director of policy and campaigns for Mind, supported Streeting’s call for better access to mental health support but cautioned against oversimplifying the issue.

“Applying for benefits is not an easy process,” Patel said, noting that people with mental health problems face a lengthy assessment process, with many decisions to deny support overturned on appeal. He also acknowledged the wider challenges facing people’s mental health, including the pandemic, cost-of-living crisis, poverty, and systemic racism.

The strain on mental health services

Brian Dow, deputy chief executive of the charity Rethink Mental Illness, also weighed in, highlighting that the crisis in the nation's mental health is "very real." He noted that systemic pressures have created barriers to accessing diagnoses and treatments, and he warned that mental health services are at "breaking point."

The welfare reforms

Streeting’s comments come in the context of broader welfare reforms, expected to be outlined by Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall. These reforms are anticipated to focus on tightening eligibility for PIP, a move that has already sparked resistance from disability advocates and opposition parties.

While Streeting refused to discuss the specifics of the reforms, it is understood that the government is considering dropping plans to freeze PIP increases in line with inflation for a year, following significant opposition from within the Labour Party.

Part of Kendall’s proposal is expected to include a "right to try" guarantee, which would allow people with disabilities to attempt work without the fear of losing their benefits if the job does not work out. This is seen as a way to encourage more disabled individuals to participate in the workforce, while still providing a safety net.

Opposition to the reforms

Labour’s welfare reform plans have faced criticism from various quarters. Shadow Education Secretary Laura Trott accused the government of being “divided” on welfare policy. Although Trott expressed support for the principle of welfare reform, she criticised the lack of clarity around the proposals.

The SNP also voiced its opposition, with Westminster leader Stephen Flynn urging Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer to abandon what he called “cuts to disabled people.” Flynn argued that the government was being restricted by “Tory austerity rules” on public spending, a reference to Chancellor Rachel Reeves’ draft plans to cut several billion pounds from the welfare budget ahead of the Spring Statement.

A precarious future for mental health support

As the government moves forward with welfare reform, concerns remain about the impact on people with mental health conditions. Total spending on health and disability benefits is forecast to rise significantly, largely due to rising claims linked to mental health. The challenge lies in finding a balance between sustainable public spending and providing adequate support for people struggling with mental health conditions.

Streeting’s remarks on overdiagnosis have added fuel to the debate on mental health and welfare in the UK. As the government finalises its welfare reforms, it must address the need to provide vital support for those in need, while ensuring a fair and manageable welfare system.

More For You

New Covid strain

Experts have raised concerns about the immune-evasive nature of the Stratus strain

iStock

New Covid strain Stratus spreads in UK with unusual hoarse voice symptom

Key points

  • A new Covid strain known as Stratus is spreading across the UK
  • The variant is marked by a distinctive symptom: a hoarse or raspy voice
  • Sub-variants XFG and XFG.3 now account for 30% of cases in England
  • Experts say there is no evidence of more severe disease
  • Lower immunity levels may make more people vulnerable to infection

Covid variant Stratus on the rise in the UK

A new strain of Covid-19, known as Stratus, is spreading across the UK and drawing attention for its unusual symptom — a hoarse or raspy voice. According to data from the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA), Stratus and its two sub-variants, XFG and XFG.3, are responsible for around 30 per cent of Covid cases in England.

Of the two, XFG.3 is currently the more dominant. The UKHSA confirmed that monitoring of all circulating Covid-19 variants is ongoing as part of regular surveillance.

Keep ReadingShow less
Human brain continues forming neurons

Neurogenesis, the process by which new neurons form in the brain

iStock

Human brain continues forming neurons well into old age, study finds

Key points

  • New neurons continue forming in the brain’s hippocampus into old age
  • Study confirms presence of neural progenitor cells in adults
  • DNA carbon dating and single-nucleus RNA sequencing were used
  • Research shows variation in neuron production between individuals
  • Findings could aid treatments for neurodegenerative and psychiatric disorders

Human brain shows ongoing neuron formation into older age

A new study has confirmed that the human brain continues to produce new nerve cells well into late adulthood, challenging previous assumptions about age-related decline in neurogenesis. The findings, published in the journal Science, provide fresh insight into how adaptable the brain remains over a lifetime.

Neurogenesis, the process by which new neurons form in the brain, is known to occur in the hippocampus — a region involved in memory. While previous research has suggested that this process continues throughout life, there has been limited concrete evidence of the presence of neural progenitor cells in the adult brain.

Keep ReadingShow less
Black women cancer risk

Serious public health challenges in the decades ahead

iStock

Study warns of rising uterine cancer rates, with Black women hardest hit

Key points

  • Uterine cancer cases and deaths are projected to rise significantly in the US by 2050.
  • Black women are expected to experience the highest increase in incidence-based mortality.
  • A new model predicts incidence rising to 86.9 cases per 100,000 for Black women and 74.2 for White women.
  • Researchers stress the urgent need for improved prevention and early detection strategies.

Sharp increase in uterine cancer predicted over next three decades

Uterine cancer, currently the fourth most commonly diagnosed cancer among women in the United States, is projected to see a substantial rise in both cases and deaths by 2050, particularly among Black women. A new study led by researchers at Columbia University warns of worsening racial disparities in outcomes if preventative measures are not introduced.

This year alone, around 69,120 new cases of uterine cancer and nearly 14,000 deaths are expected in the United States. However, projections by the Columbia University research team, published in Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention, indicate a significant increase in both incidence and mortality over the next 30 years.

Keep ReadingShow less
Can dairy disrupt your sleep

The authors acknowledged potential limitations in their findings

iStock

Can dairy disrupt your sleep? Study links certain foods to nightmares

Key points

  • 40% of participants in a new study said food affects their sleep
  • Dairy and sweets were linked to worse sleep and more disturbing dreams
  • Fruit, herbal tea and vegetables were associated with better sleep quality
  • Authors suggest that lactose intolerance may play a role in dream disturbance

A recent study has explored how food may influence sleep and dreaming, with some participants reporting that certain items — particularly dairy and sweets — disrupted their rest and contributed to nightmares.

Study looked at food, sleep and dreams

The research, published in the journal Frontiers in Psychology on Monday, analysed responses from 1,082 college-aged participants who completed online surveys between January and April 2023. The survey asked about over a dozen food categories, including dairy, meat, fruit, desserts, and spicy foods.

Keep ReadingShow less
heatwave

The Met Office and UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) have issued amber heat-health alerts

Getty Images

Doctors warn of hidden signs of heat stroke as UK issues amber alerts

Key points

  • Amber heat-health alerts issued as temperatures approach 35°C in parts of the UK.
  • Early signs of heat stroke include confusion, slurred speech, and dizziness.
  • Heat exhaustion can develop into heat stroke if not treated within 30 minutes.
  • At-risk groups include the elderly, young children, and those with health conditions.
  • NHS and health experts urge people to stay hydrated, cool, and avoid midday sun.

Medical experts are urging the public to remain alert for the early signs of heat stroke, as temperatures across parts of England are expected to reach up to 35°C. The Met Office and UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) have issued amber heat-health alerts, warning that extreme heat can have serious health impacts. Doctors stress that symptoms can begin subtly, making early intervention crucial.

Heat alerts across multiple regions

Amber-level warnings are in effect for the West Midlands, East Midlands, Yorkshire and the Humber, South East, South West, London, and the East of England.

Keep ReadingShow less