Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

FCA to scale back 'naming and shaming' plan amid backlash

Lawyers say plan remains too problematic

FCA to scale back 'naming and shaming' plan amid backlash

THE Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) is expected to scale back its plans to publicly name companies under investigation, following criticism from four lawyers who said that a government and industry backlash has labelled the proposals as misjudged and harmful to London's competitive standing.

The anticipated decision by the markets regulator aims to address concerns over the controversial plans, which critics argue could cause undue and lasting harm to companies and the finance industry, a sector contributing over 10 per cent of UK tax revenues.


The FCA in February published proposals to publicly name some companies when investigations are opened in an effort to deter wrongdoing and encourage whistleblowing and transparency. But they met with unprecedented calls from trade bodies, lawyers and the Treasury to rethink or ditch the plans.

Legal sources, who declined to be named, say the FCA's co-head of enforcement, Therese Chambers, started rowing back almost immediately during a charm offensive with corporate clients at their law firms' offices around March.

Fielding "challenging questions", she made concessions to February's consultation paper that included a longer notice period than the proposed one day - or no notice at all - before an investigation is announced, one source said. However, without a route to appeal, that is unlikely to be enough, lawyers said.

Chambers was also open to taking account of firms' interests when applying a proposed, looser "public interest test" to naming corporate suspects. At present, companies under investigation are named only in "exceptional" circumstances.

"We all saw those as immediate concessions," the source said.

Since unveiling the proposal, the FCA has said its plans remain subject to discussions, but details on how it rowed back during industry meetings have not previously been reported.

"We have listened carefully and we're considering all the feedback that we've received as we decide on next steps," an FCA spokesperson said when asked about Chambers' meetings.

Bank of England governor Andrew Bailey, a former FCA CEO, is one of the few high-profile officials to back the plans. He said last month that a lengthy probe into unsuitable pension advice for former steelworkers demonstrated how consumers could be harmed if they were unaware of a regulatory inquiry.

And when asked by lawmakers why the FCA cannot use existing rules to name companies in exceptional circumstances, FCA CEO Nikhil Rathi said investment fraud was "sadly ... not exceptional".

However, Chambers and her joint enforcement head Steve Smart told lawmakers in a public letter last month that there might be value in potential alternatives, such as publishing anonymised new investigations in the FCA's "enforcement watch" newsletter.

Rathi told a parliamentary hearing in May that the regulator would take "several months" to consider feedback before publishing a final policy.

Some lawyers say the FCA's aims are laudable, but that the original proposals allow the regulator too broad a discretion when publishing details of investigations - and offer scant due process.

Finance minister Jeremy Hunt, trade bodies and some lawyers say that investment in London is at risk if companies are publicly shamed before evidence is gathered, when 65 per cent of FCA investigations end without action.

"Our clients are unanimously opposed to these proposals," said Thomas Donegan, a partner at law firm A&O Shearman, who did not meet with the FCA.

He said many investigations involve isolated incidents that put neither consumers nor investors at risk. "There is no public interest in disclosing run-of-the-mill investigations like these until they have run their course," he added.

Read Also: Cillian Murphy reprises his role in Peaky Blinders film

Laura Bridgewater, a partner at law firm Macfarlanes, said even watered-down proposals deserved a fresh consultation and a cost-benefit analysis.

The row tests the mettle of a relatively new FCA leadership team, which is being accused of sidelining a mandatory remit to boost London's global financial competitiveness as it squares off against rivals, such as New York, Amsterdam, Paris and Frankfurt to attract new stock market listings.

"The deterrence effect of this proposal is not evidence-based and risks diminishing the UK's attractiveness as a leading international financial centre," said Miles Celic, CEO of TheCityUK, which promotes the UK financial sector globally.

(Reuters)

More For You

Octopus Energy Unveils Smart Home EV Charger to Slash Charging Costs

It follows a broader strategy by Octopus Energy to offer home energy hardware

Getty Images

Octopus Energy unveils first smart home EV charger to cut charging costs

Octopus Energy, the UK’s largest electricity supplier, has launched its first home electric vehicle (EV) charger, named Octopus Charge. The charger is designed to integrate with the company’s smart energy system to enable cost-effective and environmentally friendly charging.

Smart charging through Kraken platform

The new Octopus Charge device connects to the energy supplier’s proprietary Kraken platform, which automatically adjusts charging to coincide with times when electricity is cheapest and greenest. This enables EV owners to take advantage of lower rates and reduce their carbon footprint.

Keep ReadingShow less
Record-breaking data breach

The data is spread across 30 different datasets

iStock

Record-breaking data breach exposes 16 billion credentials, raising global cybersecurity concerns

A massive new cybersecurity report has revealed what experts are calling the largest data breach in history, involving over 16 billion login credentials. The records, uncovered by researchers at Cybernews, appear to come from a variety of sources and have raised alarm bells across the tech and cybersecurity industries.

Unprecedented scale of exposure

The data is spread across 30 different datasets, with individual troves containing between tens of millions and more than 3.5 billion credentials each. In total, the exposed records add up to 16 billion, a staggering number that equates to more than two credentials for every person on Earth.

Keep ReadingShow less
leaders discussed the new Defence Cooperation Accord between the UK and Bahrain,

The leaders discussed the new Defence Cooperation Accord between the UK and Bahrain, aimed at deepening joint military training and naval ties.

Crown Prince of Bahrain's website

UK and Bahrain strengthen defence and investment ties

PRIME MINISTER Keir Starmer met Crown Prince Salman bin Hamad Al Khalifa, prime minister of Bahrain, at Downing Street on Thursday.

A Downing Street spokesperson said the leaders discussed the UK-Bahrain relationship and welcomed the UK becoming a full member of the Comprehensive Security Integration and Prosperity Agreement (C-SIPA), a trilateral pact with Bahrain and the United States focused on regional security.

Keep ReadingShow less
Swiss banks

Funds held in customer accounts by Indian clients rose by 11 per cent in the year to 346 million Swiss francs (£3.14m) and accounted for about one-tenth of overall funds.

iStock

Indian funds in Swiss banks triple to £3.1bn in 2024

INDIAN money in Swiss banks more than trebled in 2024 to 3.5 billion Swiss francs (£3.1bn), attributed to a rise in funds held through local branches and other financial institutions, annual data released by Switzerland's central bank showed on Thursday (19).

However, funds held in customer accounts by Indian clients rose by 11 per cent in the year to 346 million Swiss francs (£3.14m) and accounted for about one-tenth of overall funds, the report showed.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bank of England

In a statement, the central bank pointed to a recent rise in energy prices, citing the 'escalation of the conflict in the Middle East' as a factor.

Getty Images

Bank of England holds interest rate at 4.25 per cent

THE BANK OF ENGLAND (BoE) kept its key interest rate at 4.25 per cent on Thursday, citing persistent inflation and rising risks from US tariffs and the conflict between Israel and Iran.

The decision, which was widely expected, came a day after the US Federal Reserve also left its interest rates unchanged, pointing to continued inflation and slowing growth in the United States.

Keep ReadingShow less