Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

UK migration plan ‘badly flawed’, business leaders claim

by LAUREN CODLING

THE government’s immigration plans post-Brexit could impose an £80 million barrier to EU students and leave more than 100,000 jobs vacant if a £30,000-a-year minimum salary threshold for migrants is introduced, a new report has revealed this week.


Global Future, a thinktank which supports open trade and immigration, published analysis on the government’s immigration white paper on Monday (11).

The report, entitled Closing the Door: The True Cost of the Immigration White Paper, suggested the proposal’s call for a £30,000-a-year threshold could leave over 100,000 jobs unfilled in social care and nursing, causing the total EU workforce to shrink by 2025.

Koolesh Shah, the founder of London Town Group, called the plan “fundamentally flawed” for the hospitality industry.

Shah said the industry currently employs an estimated 70,000 EU workers, many of whom earn less than the required wage put forward by the government.

The white paper also outlined plans for a 12-month visa which would allow “tens of thousands” of low-skilled migrants to work in the UK for up to a year.

However, Shah believes the temporary visa could prove problematic.

“This type of visa could risk creating unfair opportunities in the workforce, encouraging investment in those able to stay and not for those on temporary visas,” he told Eastern Eye on Monday.

Dr Rami Ranger, founder and chairman of Sun Mark, also believes the suggested policies were “badly flawed”.

“It will not only increase the cost to the employers of employing staff, it will also discourage them to take on extra staff needed to grow their businesses,” he told Eastern Eye. “The higher wage costs will also fuel inflation which will make Britain uncompetitive.”

Dr Ranger said that due to the uncertainty around Brexit, many European employees were already leaving Britain. If UK employers were not able to fill the gap left by the European migrants, he added, many businesses may go under.

“Exerting unnecessary pressure on British employers who are already struggling will prove counterproductive,” he said. “In fact, the government’s revenue will actually decrease rather than increase due to reduced employment and productivity in Britain.”

Dr Nikhil Shah, director of London Town Group and COO of S-Cube, raised doubts about the government’s idea of placing highly paid immigrants on visas sponsored by the employer.

“Lose your employment and you must leave the country in one month? Imagine the kind of leverage a work visa gives to the employer over the employee,” he said, adding that the idea needed to be challenged in parliament.

Global Future also claimed the government’s proposals could cause “vast new barriers” for European students. The white paper has said it would end free movement and that students who chose to study in the UK would have to pay visa and health surcharge costs of almost £1,300 over a three-year period.

No competing universities would be imposing this charge, Global Future pointed out, and it would be taken across all EU students which would amount to a £79.8m annual barrier to entry.

Lord Karan Bilimoria, the founding chair of the UK-India Business Council and president of the UK Council for International Student Affairs, insisted the government should maintain an open relationship with the EU which allows free movement of students and researchers.

Higher education is one of the UK’s greatest exports and international students bring an estimated £26 billion into the UK economy, Lord Bilimoria noted.

“They should be exempted from the immigration health surcharge, excluded from migration calculations and should be celebrated for all that they contribute to the UK economy and life on campuses,” the peer told Eastern Eye.

Claiming that the white paper “formalises the UK government’s longstanding hostile immigration rhetoric”, Lord Bilimoria said it would see the country face “acute” shortages in labour and trade.

“The white paper was an opportunity to show our prospective and current international students that they are welcome in the UK,” he said. “It failed to do so.”

The analysis also flagged up a potential Windrush-style scandal related to the government’s settled status scheme. The system, which is expected to open fully by March 30, is already “creaking” and “will struggle to manage more than three million applications for fresh status”.

“Even if it works, the new system will leave EU citizens with one of six different kinds of status,” the report said.

In response, a Home Office spokesman said the report’s estimated costs “are entirely

speculative”.

“To attract talented workers we need, we are bringing forward a new skills-based immigration system designed to drive up wages and productivity across the UK,” he

said. “This will include supporting businesses by stripping out bureaucracy through streamlining and digitising the system and committing to process the vast majority

of work visas within three weeks.”

More For You

Shein-Reuters

Shein had aimed to go public in London in the first half of this year, subject to regulatory approvals in the UK and China. (Photo: Reuters)

Shein cuts valuation to £40 billion for London listing

SHEIN is preparing to lower its valuation to around £40 billion for a potential initial public offering (IPO) in London, according to three Reuters sources familiar with the matter.

This is nearly 25 per cent lower than the company's 2023 fundraising valuation as it faces increasing challenges.

Keep ReadingShow less
Northern-Superchargers-Getty

Ben Stokes and Matthew Short of Northern Superchargers walk out to bat during The Hundred match between Manchester Originals and Northern Superchargers on August 11, 2024 in Manchester, England. (Photo: Getty Images)

Sunrisers Hyderabad to acquire Northern Superchargers in £100 million deal

INDIAN Premier League franchise Sunrisers Hyderabad is set to become the first full owners of an English Hundred team after agreeing to buy Yorkshire’s Northern Superchargers for a reported £100 million.

The Sun Group will be the third IPL-linked investor in the eight-team Hundred competition, following Reliance Industries, which owns Mumbai Indians, and RPSG, which runs Lucknow Super Giants.

Keep ReadingShow less
BT-Getty

A view of the British Telecom (BT) headquarters in central London. (Photo: Getty Images)

BT to remove diversity targets from manager bonuses

BT will remove diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) targets from its manager bonus scheme, replacing them with a measure of overall employee engagement.

The change, set to take effect in April, follows consultation with major investors and has received “strong support,” according to the company, The Telegraph reported.

Keep ReadingShow less
India's central bank cuts interest rates for first time since 2020

The central bank announced a 25-basis-point cut in the benchmark repo rate to 6.25 per cent, the rate at which it lends to commercial banks.. (Photo credit: Reuters)

India's central bank cuts interest rates for first time since 2020

THE RESERVE BANK OF INDIA (RBI) reduced interest rates on Friday for the first time in nearly five years, citing concerns over economic growth despite inflation risks.

The central bank announced a 25-basis-point cut in the benchmark repo rate to 6.25 per cent, the rate at which it lends to commercial banks.

Keep ReadingShow less
Sri Lanka seeks to negotiate with Adani over renewable energy plants

Gautam Adani

Sri Lanka seeks to negotiate with Adani over renewable energy plants

SRI LANKA’S government started talks with India’s Adani Group to lower the cost of power from two wind power projects the group will build in the island nation’s northern province, the cabinet spokesman said last Tuesday (28).

Sri Lanka has been reviewing the group’s local projects after US authorities in November accused billionaire founder Gautam Adani and other executives of being part of a scheme to pay bribes to secure Indian power supply contracts. Adani has denied the allegations.

Keep ReadingShow less