Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Neuroscientists challenge classic findings on free will, point out flaws in Libet's experiments

The results were concluded to mean that the brain made a decision and sent a readiness potential before the person realised it

Neuroscientists challenge classic findings on free will, point out flaws in Libet's experiments

Neuroscientists have recently concluded that a direct correlation between pre-action brain activity and the intention to execute an action might not exist.

They argue that the well-known Libet paradigm from the 1970s and 1980s, often used to investigate the presence of free will in decision-making, may not be entirely suitable for this purpose.


During the above-mentioned period, Benjamin Libet, an eminent American neuroscientist in the realm of human consciousness, conducted research revealing that the brain exhibited electroencephalogram (EEG) activity predicting a forthcoming movement approximately 0.5-1.5 seconds before conscious awareness of the intention to perform the action.

The results were concluded to mean that the brain made a decision and sent a readiness potential before the person realised it, and that our actions were nothing more than a result of an unconscious physiological process in the brain.

The researchers at the National Research University Higher School of Economics, Moscow, Russia, questioned this experimental paradigm and in their new study confirmed that the time of intention awareness in Libet's experiments was determined incorrectly.

Further, EEG activity, or the brain signal indicating the readiness of a decision, recorded by Libet before the decision was made, actually had no direct link to this decision, they said in their study published in the journal Neuropsychologia.

In Libet's original experiment, the subjects were asked to occasionally bend their wrists and at the same time remember the moment when they felt ready to perform this action.

The time of intention awareness was recorded from the words of the subjects themselves - they observed a point that moved along the screen-dial, similar to a clock hand, and indicated the position of the point when they felt the desire to bend their hand.

The moment of the final decision was determined by the exact reading of the sensor attached to the wrist of the subjects.

In this study, the neuroscientists repeated the experiment with two groups of subjects, adding small changes to the task in one of the groups.

Using behavioural reports and hypersensitive EEG techniques, the scientists investigated the correlation between the time of intention awareness and the time of final decision.

They found that the time of awareness can be influenced by experimental procedures: for example, without certain training, the subjects were barely able to determine their intentions, and the traditional Libet paradigm pushed them to the feeling that they can determine the moment of decision-making and intention.

Apparently, the instruction itself in the Libet task made the participants feel that the intention should emerge long before the final decision is made, the researchers said.

Confirming the absence of a correlation between the brain signal and decision-making, they said that the sense of intention emerged in the subjects at different points in time, whereas the readiness potential was always registered at about the same time.

Thus, they said, the readiness potential may reflect the general dynamics of the decision-making process about making a move, but it did not mean that the intention to act has already been generated.

"It appears that the classical Libet paradigm is not suitable for answering the question of whether we have free will while making decisions. We need to come up with a new approach to this extremely interesting scientific puzzle," Dmitry Bredikhin, study author said.

(PTI)

More For You

Arnold Schwarzenegger

“Stop whining and get to work,” urging people to push ahead with climate solutions

Getty Images

Arnold Schwarzenegger urges action on climate, tells critics to 'stop whining'

Arnold Schwarzenegger has called on environmentalists to stop complaining about US President Donald Trump’s climate policies and instead take action. Speaking at the Austrian World Summit in Vienna on 3 June, the actor and former California governor said focusing on local efforts could still make a difference.

“I keep hearing, ‘What’s the point of fighting for a clean environment when the US government says climate change is a hoax?’” Schwarzenegger said. “You can’t just sit around and make excuses because one guy in a very nice White House on Pennsylvania Avenue doesn’t agree with you.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Empowering Women in Motion: Ritika Ahuja’s Supercar Revolution

The inspiring motoring enthusiast spoke to Eastern Eye about female empowerment

Instagram/ ritika_jatin_ahuja

Ritika Jatin Ahuja drives change with India’s first all-women supercar club

In an industry long considered the domain of men and machines, Ritika Jatin Ahuja is rewriting the rules – at full throttle.

As the founder of Queen’s Drive Club, India’s first all-women supercar collective, Ahuja is on a mission to change how females are seen in the automotive world.

Keep ReadingShow less
Experts Warn Nimbus (NB.1.8.1) May Trigger COVID Summer Wave

‘Nimbus’, is raising concerns among health experts

iStock

New 'Nimbus' Covid variant could trigger summer infection wave, experts warn

A new highly transmissible Covid variant, known as ‘Nimbus’, is raising concerns among health experts as cases rise sharply in parts of Asia and begin to appear in the UK. Official data shows that the strain, which has been labelled N.B.1.8.1, could drive a summer wave of infections due to its increased contagiousness and potential to evade immunity from earlier vaccinations or infections.

Cases detected in the UK

According to the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA), 13 confirmed cases of the variant have already been recorded in England, and 25 British samples have been submitted to international databases since the end of March. However, experts say these figures likely underestimate the true spread, given the current limited Covid testing regime compared to the height of the pandemic.

Keep ReadingShow less
Romesh Ranganathan

Ranganathan discussed experiencing suicidal thoughts in the past and the steps he has taken to improve his mental health

BBC Radio 4

Romesh Ranganathan speaks candidly about mental health and family struggles

Comedian and presenter Romesh Ranganathan has opened up about his long-term mental health challenges, describing how he has found effective ways to manage his wellbeing and now feels he is in “one of the best places I’ve ever been in my life”.

Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Desert Island Discs, Ranganathan discussed experiencing suicidal thoughts in the past and the steps he has taken to improve his mental health. He also reflected on his Sri Lankan heritage, his upbringing, and the difficulties his family faced during his youth.

Keep ReadingShow less
Priya Mulji with participants

Priya Mulji with participants at a Thailand retreat

X/ Priya Mulji

Finding my tribe in an unexpected place

Priya Mulji

I turned 43 recently, and it was the best birthday of my life. Special for so many reasons. For the first time since my twenties, I spent my birthday abroad. (In case you were wondering – Phuket, Thailand.)

Last year, I impulsively booked myself onto my friend Urvashi’s mind, body and soul expansion experience. Since then, life has taken some unexpected turns – including being made redundant from my day job – so this trip could not have come at a better time.

Keep ReadingShow less