Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Inclusive approach needed for cricket’s equality drive

Inclusive approach needed for cricket’s equality drive

FEW Commons inquiries have had so dramatic an impact as the Culture Select Committee’s probe into racism in cricket published last week.

Just announcing the hearings had proved a crucial tipping point towards regime change at Yorkshire County Cricket Club (YCCC), once the chair and chief executive has been invited to come to Westminster to give testimony alongside their former player Azeem Rafiq.


But after all the public drama, the committee published a strikingly short report of just seven pages or so.

The challenge in 2022 is different – how to make the hard yards of progress and sustain momentum once the headlines have moved on.

‘Money talks’ was one key message from the select committee, in recommending that public funding should depend on the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) making sufficient progress.

The sponsors had played a decisive role last year, moving more quickly than the governing body. The ECB followed suit in choosing to flex its financial muscle – removing, temporarily at least, the international matches due to be played at Headingley this summer.

The focus on financial threat will secure attention, but the roadmap to reform will also need stamina to sustain action once financial sanctions are lifted.

LEAD September 11 INSET Sunder Katwala Sunder Katwala

The select committee announced that it wants the ECB and Yorkshire to report quarterly on progress against key indicators, starting this month – a useful way to institutionalise the pressure for change. But it will need the right indicators for both short- and long-term progress.

More Asian professionals breaking through into county sides will take time. So, this timescale will require new indicators to assess whether the game is getting on track.

A 12-point ECB Action Plan was published quickly as the crisis broke last year, following a summit convened in response to the demand for rapid action. It is a sensible, gradualist framework for change, though several of its aims are long-term and overlap with those of previous initiatives.

These include cricket’s South Asian Action Plan of 2017, which did not shift the dial as much as had been hoped, nor address the institutional culture in boardrooms and dressing rooms in the professional game.

The question asked most by attendees at last week’s Eastern Eye-British Future event on racism in cricket was how to make sure that the plan for change does not turn into the latest “box-ticking” exercise.

That is, above all, a question of organisational culture. Creating policies and procedures that say all the right things is often the easy part. There can be a world of difference in how the same rules and policies may play out in different institutional cultures – whether the values stated in the mission statements and corporate brochures are felt to be reflected in practice, or whether those who speak up fear being labelled as trouble-makers.

In Rafiq’s employment tribunal case, both Rafiq and Adil Rashid spoke about the culture of racism at Yorkshire, as early as autumn 2017, to a new Asian board member who had just been appointed as head of diversity.

When Rafiq escalated this into a formal complaint the following summer, he found the board member attentive, but heard him explain “how the board meetings worked and the lack of interaction and input he had as head of diversity”.

For all of the diversity dinners and mission statements, Rashid, even as an England international, cannot get his voice heard about either the toxic culture in the dressing room nor the denial about it at the top table.

Inclusion is fundamentally a matter of hearts and minds, so it matters who owns the plan for change.

The ECB needs deeper engagement to secure the trust of British Asians in the process – but it is not only black and Asian engagement that matters.

The select committee’s MPs, who report shocking language in correspondence after the Rafiq hearing, warn against complacency in assuming everybody buys into the need for change.

In the past, cricket has approached inclusion in silos – talking to Asians about minority outreach, while projecting anti-racism slogans to the majority group. The push for reform must break this segmented pattern.

The Independent Commission for Equity in Cricket will collect personal testimonies and give those who have experienced prejudice a voice. That should be joined up with an engagement effort to ensure that the push for reform does not belong only to minority voices and groups.

In these difficult times, ‘bridging’ voices who can build common ground between different groups will play an important role. There needs to be a positive vision, not just a compliance-led approach. It will require honesty and generosity too.

Rafiq’s latest intervention was to call for Yorkshire to get its Test match status back. That could symbolise the approach we need – one that is about securing sustainable change, rather than cancellation for the mistakes of the past, and a shared vision of a more inclusive future.

More For You

Chelsea Flower Show highlights Royal-inspired roses and eco-friendly innovation

King Charles III, patron of the Royal Horticultural Society, walks through the RHS and BBC Radio 2 Dog Garden during a visit to the RHS Chelsea Flower Show at Royal Hospital Chelsea on May 20, 2025 in London, England.

Getty Images

Chelsea Flower Show highlights Royal-inspired roses and eco-friendly innovation

Rashmita Solanki

This particular year at the Royal Horticultural Society’s Chelsea Flower Show, there have been two members of the Royal Family who have had roses named after them.

‘The King’s Rose’, named after King Charles III, and ‘Catherine’s Rose’, named after Catherine, Princess of Wales. Both roses have been grown by two of the most well-known rose growers in the United Kingdom.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Going Dutch may be a solution to get the UK’s jobless into work’

The growing number of working-age adults not in jobs places a huge financial burden on Britain, according to recent reports

‘Going Dutch may be a solution to get the UK’s jobless into work’

Dr Nik Kotecha

ECONOMIC inactivity is a major obstacle to the UK’s productivity and competitiveness.

As a business owner and employer with over 30 years of experience, I have seen firsthand how this challenge has intensified as the economically inactive population approaches 10 million nationally - almost one million more than pre-pandemic.

Keep ReadingShow less
Understanding the Hindu Psyche: Averse to Confrontation?

Artistic depiction of Arjuna and Krishna with the chariot

Is Hindu psyche averse to confrontation?

Nitin Mehta

Over 5,000 years ago, on the battlefield of Kurukshetra, two armies comprising tens of thousands of men were ready to begin a war. The Pandavs were led by Arjuna, a warrior whose archery skills were unbeatable. At the last minute, before the war was to commence, Arjuna put down his weapons and declared to Krishna his decision not to fight. He reasoned that the war would kill tens of thousands of people all for a kingdom. It took the whole of the Bhagavad Gita to convince Arjuna to fight.

Even after Krishna destroyed all his doubts, Arjuna asked to see Krishna in his form as a supreme God. In short, Arjuna wanted to avoid confrontation at any cost.

Keep ReadingShow less
How Indian news channels used fake stories and AI to grab attention

The mainstream print media in India, both in English and regional languages, has remained largely responsible and sober

How Indian news channels used fake stories and AI to grab attention

MISINFORMATION and disinformation are not new in the age of social media, but India’s mainstream news channels peddling them during a time of war was a new low.

Hours after India launched Operation Sindoor, most channels went into overdrive with ‘breaking news’ meant to shock, or worse, excite.

Keep ReadingShow less
war and peace

A vivid depiction of the Kurukshetra battlefield, where Arjuna and Krishna stand amidst the chaos, embodying the eternal conflict between duty and morality

Artvee

War and Peace are two sides of the same coin

Nitin Mehta

War and peace have exercised the minds of human beings for as far back as history goes. It is no wonder then that the Mahabharata war, which took place over 5,000 years ago, became a moment of intense discussion between Lord Krishna and Arjuna.

Hundreds of thousands of people on either side were ready to begin battle on the site of Kurukshetra. Seeing the armies and his near and dear combatants, Arjuna lost the will to fight. How could he fight his grandfather Bhisma and his guru Dronacharya? He asked Krishna what all the bloodshed would achieve.

Keep ReadingShow less