Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

EXCLUSIVE: Government 'failed whole generation' of Asians

Ministers have not learned lessons from the pandemic, say campaigners

EXCLUSIVE: Government 'failed whole generation' of Asians

THE government continues to fail south Asian women, girls and boys who are suffering domestic abuse, and it has not learnt lessons from the pandemic, campaigners have told Eastern Eye.

They said they remain concerned that should there be another pandemic, south Asians and minority groups would be in unnecessary danger.


One charity, Southall Black Sisters (SBS), has given written evidence to the Covid inquiry.

Dr Hannana Siddiqui, revealed to this newspaper that during the pandemic about 23,000 people phoned SBS for help to escape their abusers, tripling the demand for support.

“We’re very concerned because I think what happened with this pandemic was that they [the government] didn't have a plan quick enough.

“They should have planned, they should have intervened a lot more quickly and have everything in place, before the lockdown.

“Because the lockdown was a shock to the system, and if they had emergency funding, if they had lifted the no recourse to public funds requirements, and introduced other measures that would have made it easier for victims to go and report abuse.

“There’s a lot to be learned from this pandemic that you don't want to repeat it again.

“This is why we're intervening in the inquiry, because we want to make sure it's not repeated.”

Priorities

LEAD Maaate INSET Aneeta Prem 1a Aneeta Prem

She was backed by the founder and president of the Freedom Charity, Aneeta Prem.

“I want to be optimistic and say it will be completely different [next time], the perpetrators won't be there at home, they [victims] will have places of safety to go to, they will have ways to talk to people,” she said.

“But those mechanisms haven't been put in place.

“One thing often we learn from history is we don't learn from history.

“What are we learning? What are we doing differently?

“At the moment that doesn't appear again to be a priority.

“At Freedom Charity, we are starting to plan if there was something else as horrendous as a pandemic, that girls, women are protected, we have to ensure we do more to make sure their voices are heard.”

Punch bags

During Covid, Eastern Eye reported that south Asian women and girls were being abused.

They could not seek help because the government ordered places of work and schools to close.

iStock 1165976387 Many young girls involved in a forced marriage or dishonour abuse are stuck in an abusive relationship at home with their family, where as a girl, they are less valued (Pic credit: iStock)

Prem told Eastern Eye that this meant that men, in particular, had a charter to abuse.

“During Covid, which for many of us might seem like a lifetime ago, it was incredibly haunting for anybody that had suffered any kind of domestic abuse in the past, because they were suddenly trapped in their homes, a place of safety, with the perpetrators.

“And if there hadn't been abuse in the past, Covid seemed to accelerate that whole bottleneck.

“It was like being in a pressure cooker, people told me, you're surrounded by people that are supposed to love and care for you, be it your partner, your husband.

“But you're in a situation where you can't go out, you're incredibly petrified about what's going on in the news, and you're in a situation where, for many people, income was substantially reduced, and people were using their partners as punchbags, literally.”

GettyImages 1240845642 The case of migrants who were in violent relationships had no recourse to public funds or with immigration problems, were particularly vulnerable (Photo by ALLISON DINNER/AFP via Getty Images)

Prem said the charity’s helpline heard heart breaking and frightening stories from children.

“For young girls that were involved in forced marriage or dishonour abuse, that we deal with all the time, unfortunately, at Freedom Charity, it just highlighted the problem for them.

“They didn't have that escape of school, they didn't have the chance to be out amongst normal people doing normal everyday things.

“They were stuck in an abusive relationship at home with their family, where as a girl, they were less valued.

“We had a case of a young girl that contacted us covertly during Covid, who had Covid, who was in her bedroom self-isolating, and her brother had said, quite loudly, outside her bedroom door, ‘You need to stop giving her food, she's not worth it.’

“And she was petrified she was going to be in her room and be starved to death by her family.

“This is in UK a couple of years ago, how is that possible that that could even be a thought?”

In that case, Prem’s mother cooked meals and sent the food parcel to the young girl’s home pretending it came from the school – to give the teenager “a sense of self-worth”, she explained.

Arrest fear

Campaigners have told Eastern Eye that during the pandemic women’s refugees were full up.

SBS was also concerned for migrants who were in violent relationships because they had no “recourse to public fund”.

In effect, that meant they were penniless and relied on their abuser for food, shelter and clothing.

“Those who had no recourse to public funds or with immigration problems, were particularly vulnerable, because they felt that they had no rights in this country.

“So, they felt that if they left the house, they would be arrested by the police for leaving the house for no social distancing.

“What's emerging is, there was no messages to say that victims of domestic abuse were exempt and could leave the house and get help.

“That didn't happen till early April, when Priti Patel [then home secretary] made some announcements, then later on, there were mixed messages, Boris Johnson never gave a message that victims of domestic abuse were exempt until January 2021.

“So, there wasn't sufficient mainstream messaging going out for victims, to say, first of all, that they could leave, and secondly, that they should be able to approach any service for help.

“The problem is, those victims don't approach the police for help anyway, because they feel that they'd be arrested and deported, they were even less likely to go to the police.”

GettyImages 1287236884 A lot of the women that needed help didn't want to sleep rough, therefore, they would more likely stay in abusive relationships or return to abusive relationships (Photo by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

The government’s decision making was not culturally appropriate either, she said.

“The rough sleepers initiative, which if you were sleeping rough, you could get help from the local authority.

“But a lot of the women that needed help didn't want to sleep rough, therefore, they would more likely stay in abusive relationships or return to abusive relationships, rather than sleep rough.

“This made them very vulnerable to violence and exploitation, so that was the only kind of initiative that they [the government] did around homelessness, and institutions, which didn't really suit the women that we were trying to assist.

“They needed safe refuge accommodation, or at least safe, hotel or bed and breakfast accommodation, but they couldn't afford that because they couldn't access benefits.”

Siddiqui also told Eastern Eye that minority organisations were not being funded properly because of one reason.

“Racism, there's discrimination,” she said.

“There's always been discrimination, all our campaigns around migrant women we have not been able to achieve mainly because we don't get the same level of services support for migrant women, even if they are victims of domestic abuse, who they say they want to support and protect.”

Extra cash

Because of restricted movement and rules about households mixing during the pandemic, survivors could not seek help from relatives to escape their abuser.

A barrister, Liz Davies KC, is representing SBS at the inquiry.

Last week (1), she questioned the former health secretary, Matt Hancock, about whether the government had considered allowing relative to become places of sanctuary for women and children being abused.

Matt Hancock Matt Hancock leaves after testifying for the second time at the Covid inquiry on December 1, 2023 (Photo by Carl Court/Getty Images)

“I don’t recall that being brought to my attention, that consideration,” Hancock responded.

“I had an excellent team who cared very deeply about this subject, and the impact of the regulations on people, as you say mostly women who are subject to domestic abuse and violence.

“Had it been I’m highly confident that I would have said that we should have put in place such provision because the impact on the overall virus would have been relatively low because although the numbers are far too big, they are, as a part of the population, relatively low.

“And in the same way that we realised that our initial regulations in terms of how they impacted funerals, for example, were much firmer in their interpretation on the ground than we had intended, and therefore changed them, that is the sort of thing I certainty would have been open to considering.”

Siddiqui said that SBS lobbied the government for extra money to help those being beaten or coerced.

In March 2020, the government allocated an extra £27 million, but SBS did not get any money until June that year.

“The surge in demand wasn't really being tackled, we didn't get funding from government and national government until about June 2020, after a lot of lobbying, and after we tried to take them to court, then some money was released from central government.

“We went to the mayor of London [Sadiq Khan] before that, and the mayor of London actually did fund a hotel, a crisis project with us and Women's Aid.

“So, we were able to find some temporary emergency accommodation for women through the mayor of London, but not national government.”

Legal concerns

Former home secretary, Dame Priti Patel, told the inquiry last month (9 November) that she could not be certain whether the threat of legal action was the reason why the government released the money.

INSET Priti Patel GettyImages 1772232961 Priti Patel leaves after giving evidence at the Covid-19 inquiry on November 9, 2023 (Photo by Carl Court/Getty Images)

But she was certain that her colleagues and she took the problem of domestic abuse seriously.

“We were working with Louisa Rolfe at the Metropolitan Police, and within our policing call frameworks as well early on in anticipation, lockdown, post lockdown, the surges that would come within helplines, and also the inevitability of the consequences of domestic abuse, violence, vulnerabilities.

“So, I would absolutely say, particularly with policing colleagues, and that’s predominantly where our equities were at the time in the run-up to lockdown, there were a range of discussions taking place within the Home Office and with policing colleagues.”

The barrister also asked why the government refused to let abused migrant women have recourse to public fund during a time of emergency.

“We could get into a wider debate about the implications of suspending that condition, because there are then legal implications,” said Patel.

“If you suspend a condition for a period of time, if you then reinstate those conditions, it then takes — and I do recall reading advice at the time, some of the legal challenges just around suspending — it may seem straightforward to organisations lobbying for that change.

“But I do specifically recall receiving advice at that time saying that it would be legally challenging to then go back and restate.

“And I appreciate, the organisation you’re representing, the position that you take around no recourse to public funds, but obviously that condition exists for a reason.”

Lost generation

In our reporting at the time, we revealed how parents were forcing their young children to marry in virtual ceremonies.

Because schools were closed, Prem said that a generation of children have disappeared.

This, she said, concerned her greatly and did not bode well for the future.

“We need to teach young men and boys that violence against anybody, but certainly among women and girls, is completely unacceptable and will not be tolerated in this country,” she said.

“And when it's going wrong, that if you come forward and report, you have help and support.

“People that were trapped in these horrendous violence situations at home, didn't have access to refuges, because they were full, they were trapped in their houses, in the most horrendous, scary situations that we can't even imagine.

“This went on, not just for days and hours, but weeks and months, and for many girls, they never returned to school, and they've been lost to us.

“We don't know what's happened to them.

“We know many did get forced into marriage, but what has happened to them now?

“We failed a whole generation, really.”

Eastern Eye contacted the government for comment.

More For You

HH Guruji performed the Dhwaja Ritual at Ambaji Temple

HH Guruji performed the Dhwaja Ritual at Ambaji Temple

Mahesh Liloriya

The holy town of Ambaji witnessed a spiritually significant day on Sunday as His Holiness Siri Rajrajeshwar Guruji, head of the International Siddhashram Shakti Centre, London, performed the Dhwaja ritual at the historic Ambaji Temple in Gujarat, one of the most revered Shakti Peeths of India.

Keep ReadingShow less
Eco-friendly Ganesh Utsav at Harrow’s Siddhashram Shakti Centre

Eco-friendly Ganesh Utsav at Harrow’s Siddhashram Shakti Centre

Mahesh Liloriya

The International Siddhashram Shakti Centre in Harrow witnessed an inspiring and environmentally responsible celebration of Ganesh Utsav 2025, which concluded on Saturday, 6 September, with the Ganesh Visarjan ritual performed on the sacred occasion of Anant Chaturdashi.

Keep ReadingShow less
Rick Davies

Rick Davies, British rock legend of Supertramp, dies at 81

Getty Images

Rick Davies, Supertramp co-founder who turned Breakfast in America into a Grammy-winning hit, dies at 81

Highlights:

  • Rick Davies, co-founder of Supertramp, has died at 81 after a long battle with cancer
  • The British musician wrote and sang classics including Goodbye Stranger and Bloody Well Right
  • Davies kept the band alive after Roger Hodgson’s departure in 1983 and toured until 2022
  • His music, especially Breakfast in America, continues to inspire generations worldwide

Rick Davies' death has left a profound mark on the music world, as fans remember the Supertramp co-founder who turned a progressive rock outfit into one of the most successful British bands of the late 1970s. Alongside partner Roger Hodgson, he penned songs that defined an era, while his unique keyboard style helped shape rock history. Beyond his artistry, Davies’ determination kept Supertramp going long after internal disputes and creative differences split the group.

Rick Davies Rick Davies, British rock legend of Supertramp, dies at 81 Getty Images

Keep ReadingShow less
Apple

Apple’s biggest hardware refresh in five years

Getty Images

Apple’s big September showcase: iPhone 17 line-up, AirPods and Vision Pro updates

Highlights:

  • Apple to unveil the iPhone 17 range, including a new ultrathin iPhone 17 Air.
  • Updates expected across Apple Watch, AirPods, iPad Pro, Vision Pro, Apple TV, and HomePod mini.
  • Major redesign for iPhone Pro models, marking Apple’s biggest hardware refresh in five years.
  • Event takes place on Tuesday, 9 September, ahead of the holiday season.

Apple’s biggest launch of the year

Apple will host its annual product showcase on Tuesday, 9 September, at Apple Park. The company is expected to unveil its iPhone 17 line-up, alongside new Apple Watches, AirPods, and updates to other devices. The event comes at a time when Apple is facing tougher competition from Samsung, Google and Chinese manufacturers, while lagging behind rivals in generative AI development.

iPhone 17, iPhone 17 Pro, Pro Max and iPhone 17 Air

Apple will launch four iPhone models this year. The highlight is the iPhone 17 Air, an ultrathin model measuring 5.5mm, about one-third thinner than the iPhone 16 Pro. Its slim design results in reduced battery life and a single rear camera but retains the A19 processor, a 6.6-inch display, USB-C, ProMotion support and eSIM-only connectivity.

Keep ReadingShow less
English Channel

People try to board a migrant dinghy into the English Channel on August 25, 2025 in Gravelines, France. (Photo: Getty Images)

Government plans to use military sites for migrant housing

THE UK government said on Sunday it is examining the use of military sites to house migrants, amid growing criticism over the practice of accommodating asylum seekers in hotels.

"We are looking at the potential use of military and non-military use sites for temporary accommodation for the people who come across on these small boats," defence secretary John Healey told Sky News.

Keep ReadingShow less