Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Comment: Why Starmer should not try to be a bad copy of Trump

Labour urged to implement change without using populist politics

Comment: Why Starmer should not try to be a bad copy of Trump

Sir Keir Starmer

NOBODY would ever mistake Sir Keir Starmer for Donald Trump.

The two men could hardly differ more in style, substance, or their core political instincts. It is the populist showman versus the gradualist social democrat, the multilateralist versus the unilateralist.


So Downing Street is relieved that the diplomatic courtesies of an initial 45-minute call between the leaders went well enough. The Trump administration’s aggressive clashes with Denmark, a NATO ally, over its designs on Greenland, and its clashes with its neighbour Canada show that this cannot be taken for granted. There will be more contentious topics – from tariffs, Ukraine and defence spending – when the two men meet.

They do share a calendar – each has four years to show what they can deliver. Starmer needs opposites to attract sufficiently to avoid conflict with Washington on economics, defence or foreign policy from derailing his domestic agenda.

The case for Trumpism as a political style is its confidence in dominating the political agenda. Trump won a decisive narrow victory, and intends to use it to declare a lasting realignment.

Trump’s first fortnight in office has seen a blizzard of executive actions, an advertisement for the politics of shock and awe. Make America Great Again [MAGA] is both a much punchier and more polarising pitch. Starmer’s vision of a decade of national renewal is unlikely to have been heard yet, so his government struggles for public definition.

Trump revels in his ability to use political power to break and remake the rules of the game. His opening blitz of executive orders included the pardoning of those who took part in the rioting and disorder of January 6, 2021.

But trying to amend the constitution by executive order is unlikely to get very far, such as in the attempt to ignore the 14th amendment which grants birthright citizenship to those born in the US.

Trump’s immigration deportation efforts are dominating the airwaves with images of raids, though this may well backfire if his push to scale up these efforts targets families long settled in America.

Another Trump order promotes the death penalty. The practical impact of this has been hampered by former president Joe Biden commuting the sentences of 37 of the 40 federal prisoners who were on death row. The two leaders are unlikely to find time to debate such matters of life and death.

Adherence to the rule of law is a core value for Starmer, reflecting his background as a lawyer and a prosecutor. The opposition Tory leader, Kemi Badenoch, wants to try to make this a weakness, calling the prime minister a “lawyer, not a leader”.

Donald Trump

Noises off suggest the Trump administration would like “regime change” in London. But ‘America first’ is likely to remain Trump’s focus. It is mainly those such as billionaire businessman Elon Musk using a ‘Make Europe Great Again’ slogan who have an expansionist vision for the export of Trumpism. Musk is actively campaigning for the far right AfD in next month’s German elections, but is uncertain who he would back in Britain.

The strongest effort to fan TrumpStarmer tensions is coming from Nigel Farage’s Reform party. It wants to maintain as high a media profile as possible, as it seeks to call into question whether the Conservatives will be the main alternative to Labour at the next election.

Reform was out in force during the US inauguration. Farage may be overspinning his access to Trump. He ended up seeing the president’s inauguration address on a television screen, having not been among the 600 people invited to witness the indoor event in person.

The front-page coverage in the British press speculating that Trump may reject Starmer’s appointment of Peter Mandelson as UK ambassador has not yet been given any credence by US media outlets.

Gossip from Washington parties and from Reform’s friends in the MAGA movement may not reflect White House thinking.

Starmer’s social democratic politics sought to offer an antidote in Britain to Trump-style performative populism. His anti-Trump instinct is to Make Politics Boring Again, having political arguments tread lighter on people’s lives. That could be an attractive offer on exhausting culture war conflicts – if it does not mean ducking real challenges and has delivered on public priorities.

Starmer wants to call a 2029 general election, after Trump has left the White House. The president cannot be re-elected, under the US constitution, though he may try to bend the rules, or at least seek a loyal successor to continue his legacy.

There is little point in the prime minister trying to become a bad copy of Trump. Starmer will need to show he has delivered change that can be felt on the economy and the NHS. He needs to show a balanced approach to immigration and asylum can work too.

Any effective anti-populist politics depends on showing that change can happen – not just explaining that it is more complicated than populist slogans recognise.



Sunder Katwala

Sunder Katwala is the director of thinktank British Future and the author of the book How to Be a Patriot: The must-read book on British national identity and immigration

More For You

Parliament backs assisted dying in historic law shift

Supporters of the assisted dying law for terminally ill people hold a banner, on the day British lawmakers are preparing to vote on the bill, in London, Britain, June 20, 2025. REUTERS/Isabel Infantes

Parliament backs assisted dying in historic law shift

PARLIAMENT voted on Friday (20) in favour of a bill to legalise assisted dying, paving the way for the country's biggest social change in a generation.

314 lawmakers voted in favour with 291 against the bill, clearing its biggest parliamentary hurdle.

Keep ReadingShow less
assisted dying bill

Pro and anti-assisted dying campaigners protest ahead of a parliamentary decision later today, on June 20, 2025 in London.

Getty Images

MPs to vote on assisted dying bill amid divided views

UK MPs are set to hold a key vote on assisted dying on Friday, which could either advance or halt a proposed law that would allow terminally ill adults to end their lives under strict conditions.

The vote follows several hours of debate in the House of Commons and will decide whether the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill moves to the House of Lords for further scrutiny or is dropped altogether.

Keep ReadingShow less
Zhenhao Zou

Zhenhao Zou, 28, was jailed on Thursday after being found guilty of multiple offences. (Photo: Reuters)

Reuters

Chinese student jailed for life for raping women in UK and China

A CHINESE postgraduate student convicted of drugging and raping 10 women in the UK and China has been sentenced to life imprisonment by a London court.

Zhenhao Zou, 28, was jailed on Thursday after being found guilty of multiple offences. Police say there is evidence he may have targeted more than 50 other women.

Keep ReadingShow less
Air India crash victims

Family members and relatives of Megha Mehta, who died in the Air India plane crash, during her funeral at a crematorium, in Ahmedabad, Sunday, June 15, 2025.

Getty Images

Air India crash: 220 victims identified, 202 bodies returned to families

MORE than a week after an Air India flight crashed in Ahmedabad, 220 victims have been identified through DNA testing and the remains of 202 of them handed over to their families, Gujarat health minister Rushikesh Patel said on Friday.

The London-bound Air India flight AI-171 was carrying 242 passengers and crew when it crashed on June 12, killing all but one person on board. Nearly 29 others were killed on the ground when the aircraft hit a medical complex in Meghaninagar shortly after take-off.

Keep ReadingShow less
Survivors demand politicians step back from child sexual exploitation inquiry

Photo for representation (iStock)

Survivors demand politicians step back from child sexual exploitation inquiry

TWO survivors of grooming gangs have called for politicians to step back and let women shape the new national inquiry into child sexual exploitation.

Holly Archer and Scarlett Jones, who helped run a local inquiry in Telford, said the political fighting over vulnerable women must stop before the investigation begins, the Guardian reported.

Keep ReadingShow less