Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Video shows Munira Mirza comparing use of 'N-word' with calling someone 'fat'

A 2011 VIDEO featuring Munira Mirza has resurfaced under the spotlight as she is seen arguing against banning hate speech, and asking a black youth how using the “N-word” was different from calling someone “fat”.

The head of Number 10’s policy unit – who’s been asked to set up UK’s commission on racial inequality -- can be seen opining that a professor in Leeds who said black people had “genetically lower IQ” should not have been fired.


Calling for wider public debates, rather than legal action in cases of hate speech, Mirza said she believed former British National Party leader Nick Griffin should not have been tried on charges of inciting racial hatred.

In a 2004 speech to BNP supporters in West Yorkshire, Griffin had called Islam a “wicked, vicious faith” and accused Muslims of making Britain a “multiracial hellhole”.

The video, recorded at Hackney charity WorldWrite’s headquarters, has come under scrutiny as there have been calls to keep Mirza out of the racial inequality commission, which was ordered by Prime Minister Boris Johnson amid Black Lives Matter protests that rocked the UK.

“People can respond or deal with hatred, and they should learn to,” Mirza, who was then Johnson’s cultural adviser at the London mayor's office, says in the video.

She argues that no group “is so vulnerable that it can’t be resilient enough to withstand some kind of attack against them”.

“When you talk about hate speech, you say that some words are so offensive and some people are so vulnerable they can’t hear it, which is really quite offensive, isn’t it really?” she asks a group of youngsters.

“We don’t want a culture where people can’t say what they think. Rather I would have a culture where people disagree strongly, and are willing to change their minds.”

As one of the participants airs his views on the “N-word”, Mirza asks: “But why is your offence graver and more serious than somebody who is very overweight… are you not saying ‘I am being victimised here’?”

She, however, adds that “it is true that in the past the ‘N-word’ would have had a much stronger political character to it, and it would have been about reflecting the inequalities between blacks and whites in society”.

Mirza also takes the example of “Paki”, saying it is a “horrible” word loaded with “prejudices and terrible feeling of humiliation and shame”.

“I still bristle at the sound of the it,” she says.

But, she added, authorities telling people not to use it would make the word more powerful, give it more “weight”.

Mirza also goes on to draw parallels between banning hate speech and to Nazi Germany suppressing free speech, though noting that the two scenarios in terms of hostility towards minorities were totally different.

Critics have maintained that Mirza is “unsuited” to lead the commission, as she had earlier been embroiled in row after criticising past inquiries into institutional racism.

Mirza had said “a lot of people in politics think it’s a good idea to exaggerate the problem of racism”, and that former prime minister Theresa May’s proposed racial disparities audit for public services meant “another bout of political self-flagellation regarding the subject of race in Britain”.

Mirza had also stated that “accusations of institutional racism — and their official endorsement — have corroded BAME communities’ trust in public services, thereby making things worse”.

Furthermore, in an article, she wrote: “By appeasing the anti-racism lobby and affirming its culture of grievance, public institutions and business leaders are not making Britain a fairer place but harming the very people they aspire to help.”

Labour MP Diane Abbott said the commission involving Mirza was “dead on arrival”.

“She has never believed in institutional racism,” the former shadow home secretary stressed.

Actor and Black Lives Matter leader Imarn Ayton said Mirza did not represent the anti-racism movement because she “does not believe in what we believe in, she’s not in line with what we believe in”.

“Boris Johnson has appointed a lady called Munira Mirza to head up our race inequality commission,” she recently told a group of protesters in London. “This is a woman who does not believe in institutional racism – she has argued it is more of a perception than a reality.

“So, let me tell you right now, so here to make sure that everyone knows this today. Munira Mirza must go.”

The prime minister’s office, meanwhile, had clarified that an “independent figure” -- not Mirza -- would lead the commission, and that an announcement would will be made soon.

“Munira is the prime minister’s head of policy, so you would expect her to be involved in setting this up,” added a spokesperson.

Trashing criticism against Mirza, Priti Patel said the No.10 adviser was “one of the most talented people working in government”.

“She has dedicated years of her life to public service,” the home secretary added. “A self-made woman who knows her own mind. This orchestrated pile-on is deeply unpleasant.”

Former chancellor Sajid Javid said Mirza was “smart, compassionate and deeply committed to social justice”.

“One of the sharpest minds inside No 10,” he said. “No wonder the Left don’t like her.”

Dr Rakib Ehsan, research fellow at Henry Jackson Society, opined that Mirza was being assailed by ‘progressive anti-racists’ who were “interested in neither social progress nor fighting all forms of racism”.

He also accused Mirza’s critics of trying to hold “non-white people under a perpetual state of victimhood”.

More For You

pubs-england-iStock

Previous VE Day anniversaries, royal events and sporting occasions such as the Euro 2024 final have also seen similar extensions. (Representational image: iStock)

iStock

Pubs in England and Wales to stay open late for VE Day 80th anniversary

PUBS and bars in England and Wales will be allowed to stay open until 01:00 BST on Thursday 8 May to mark the 80th anniversary of VE Day, the government has confirmed.

Prime minister Keir Starmer said venues that usually close at 23:00 will be able to continue serving for two extra hours.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bangladesh-Pakistan

The meeting took place days ahead of Pakistani deputy prime minister and foreign minister Ishaq Dar's scheduled visit to Dhaka on April 27 and 28. (Photo: X/@ForeignOfficePk)

Bangladesh, Pakistan resume top-level talks after 15 years

BANGLADESH on Thursday raised several longstanding concerns with Pakistan, including a public apology over the 1971 atrocities, during the first foreign secretary-level talks between the two countries in 15 years.

Bangladesh also asked Pakistan to pay USD 4.3 billion as its share of undivided assets from when East Pakistan became independent Bangladesh in 1971.

Keep ReadingShow less
Keir Starmer

Starmer thanked Christians for their community work, including support through night shelters, youth clubs, toddler groups, family services, elderly care and chaplaincy. (Photo: Getty Images)

Starmer thanks Christians for community work in Easter message

PRIME MINISTER Keir Starmer extended Easter wishes to Christians across the UK, marking the end of Lent and the celebration of the resurrection of Jesus Christ.

In his Easter message, Starmer said the story of Easter is central to the Christian faith. He acknowledged Christians facing hardship, persecution or conflict globally who cannot celebrate freely.

Keep ReadingShow less
Trump-Charles

Trump previously made a state visit to the UK in 2019 during his first term as president. (Photo: Getty Images)

Trump says he expects to meet King Charles in September

US PRESIDENT Donald Trump said on Thursday he expects to meet King Charles in the UK in September. It would be an unprecedented second state visit for Trump, which the British government hopes will strengthen ties between the two countries.

Prime minister Keir Starmer delivered an invitation from King Charles to Trump during a meeting in the Oval Office in February. The meeting focused on tariffs and the situation in Ukraine.

Keep ReadingShow less
Blackburn with Darwen vows to tackle mental health taboos among Asians

Efforts are being made to improve mental health service uptake among Asians

Blackburn with Darwen vows to tackle mental health taboos among Asians

BLACKBURN with Darwen will spend an additional £1.17 million over the next five years on tackling mental health in the borough, with an emphasis on reaching young people and residents of south Asian heritage, writes Bill Jacobs.

The worse than national average figures were set out in a report to senior councillors. Council leader Phil Riley told the meeting last Thursday (10) that figures in the survey, especially for young people, were shocking.

Keep ReadingShow less