Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Two-tier Test cricket sparks debate on the format’s future

Shastri and Vaughan among those backing reform despite widespread concerns

Two-tier Test cricket sparks debate on the format’s future

Ravi Shastri

A PROPOSED two-tier structure for Test cricket has sparked intense debate across the cricketing world, with former players and administrators sharply divided over its potential impact on the sport’s longest format.

As the International Cricket Council (ICC) reportedly prepares to discuss this significant restructuring this month, voices both for and against the proposal have grown louder.


The recent thrilling five-Test series between Australia and India, which saw the hosts triumph 3-1 amid packed stadiums, has reignited discussions about Test cricket’s future structure.

England ex-captain Michael Vaughan has emerged as one of the strongest advocates for the two-tier system, viewing it as crucial for the format’s survival.

“I believe it is a four-day product with a set number of overs each day enforced, three matches minimum per series and two divisions of six, including promotion and relegation,” Vaughan said.

He expressed particular enthusiasm about the possibility of more frequent Ashes series: “I was delighted to read ... the ICC are considering a two-tier structure from 2027 which could see the Ashes staged twice every three years.”

Former India coach Ravi Shastri has aligned himself with this perspective. He argued that the Australia-India series demonstrated Test cricket’s enduring appeal to audiences while reinforcing the need for top teams to play each other more frequently.

“The top teams play against each other more often, so there is a contest. You want contests,” Shastri stressed during his commentary stint on SEN radio.

Supporting this view, UAE national cricket team’s head coach Lalchand Rajput suggested that the proposed system “would foster healthy competition and enhance the excitement of the sport.

“In this setup, the best teams would face each other more frequently, while lower-ranked teams would have a clear incentive to perform well in order to climb into the top tier.”

Clive Lloyd

However, the proposal has met with fierce resistance from several cricket luminaries, particularly those representing nations outside cricket’s “Big Three” of India, Australia, and England.

West Indies cricket legend Clive Lloyd, who led his team during their dominant era in the 1970s and 1980s, expressed deep concerns about the potential consequences.

“I think it will be terrible for all those countries who worked so hard to get the Test status,” the 80-year-old Lloyd stated during an online media interaction.

“Now they’ll be playing among themselves in the lower section. How are they going to make it to the top? When you play against better teams.”

Lloyd particularly pointed out the historical contribution of West Indies cricket. He noted, “We were the cash cows for a lot of countries over the years ... people must recognise that. But we are at that situation now where we need the help, and we can’t get it.”

Sri Lanka’s 1996 World Cup-winning captain Arjuna Ranatunga has also voiced strong opposition to the proposal. “I understand the economics. Such a move will certainly line the pockets of the three boards, but sport isn’t just about pounds, dollars and rupees.

“Administrators must nurture and protect the game, not just fatten their coffers,” Ranatunga said.

Former Australian cricketer Mark Taylor has taken a more nuanced position, suggesting that a de facto two-tier system already exists. “It’s something that’s been discussed for a number of years – that very topic, and I’m certainly not against it. In a way that’s almost what we’ve got now,” Taylor observed, pointing to the current World Test Championship (WTC) structure, where the Test-playing teams naturally separate into different tiers based on their competitive levels.

According to reports, ICC chairman Jay Shah is scheduled to meet with Australian and English board representatives this month to discuss the proposed restructuring. Any changes would be implemented after the conclusion of the current Future Tours Programme in 2027.

Michael Vaughan

This isn’t the first time such a proposal has been considered. In 2016, plans for a de facto premier league featuring the top seven sides were scrapped after the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) led opposition efforts, citing concerns about the impact on smaller cricket nations.

The debate reflects broader challenges facing Test cricket in an era dominated by T20 franchise leagues. While recent series between major nations have shown the format’s appeal, concerns persist about maintaining competitive balance and financial viability of all Test-playing nations.

As the ICC prepares to deliberate on this crucial matter, the cricket world watches closely. The outcome could fundamentally reshape international cricket’s landscape, potentially creating more frequent contests between top nations while raising questions about the development and sustainability of the sport in countries with a less established cricketing infrastructure, experts say.

More For You

SRH vs DC IPL 2025: The Ultimate Clash Between Hyderabad and Delhi

Both teams are coming off contrasting results in their previous games

Getty

IPL 2025 - SRH vs DC: Thrilling showdown between Hyderabad and Delhi awaits

The 10th match of IPL 2025 will see Delhi Capitals (DC) locking horns with Sunrisers Hyderabad (SRH) at the ACA-VDCA Cricket Stadium in Visakhapatnam on Sunday, March 30. Both teams are coming off contrasting results in their previous games, and this match promises to be a gripping contest, with several exciting player battles to watch out for.

Match overview

Delhi Capitals are fresh off a thrilling one-wicket win over Lucknow Super Giants. Chasing a formidable 210, DC's middle-order showed resilience, with Tristan Stubbs and Ashutosh Sharma forming a crucial 48-run partnership after an early collapse. Vipraj Nigam’s late cameo and Ashutosh’s calm composure at the death saw DC edge out a nail-biting finish with three balls to spare.

Keep ReadingShow less
RR vs CSK

Both teams coming off contrasting starts to their campaigns

Getty

IPL 2025 - RR vs CSK: Rajasthan takes on Chennai in high-stakes battle


The electrifying action of IPL 2025 continues as Rajasthan Royals (RR) lock horns with Chennai Super Kings (CSK) in match number 11 at the Barsapara Cricket Stadium in Guwahati on Sunday, March 30. With both teams coming off contrasting starts to their campaigns, this clash promises to be a thrilling battle of experience, skill, and determination.

Keep ReadingShow less
Indian and American investors delay Hundred deals: report

FILE PHOTO: The Oval Invincibles celebrate after The Hundred Final between Oval Invincibles and Southern Brave at Lord's Cricket Ground on August 18, 2024. (Photo: Getty Images)

Indian and American investors delay Hundred deals: report


THE England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) has extended the deadline for finalising the £520 million sale of The Hundred franchises after pushback from several prospective owners, particularly the Indian and American investors behind the two London teams.

The eight-week exclusivity window agreed in February has passed without contracts being signed, with negotiations now expected to continue until at least the end of April. While all parties remain committed to completing the deals, several key issues remain unresolved, the Telegraph reported.

Keep ReadingShow less
IPL 2025: RCB crush Chennai as Hazlewood stars

Josh Hazlewood in action during the match against Chennai Super Kings at MA Chidambaram Stadium in Chennai. (ANI Photo)

IPL 2025: RCB crush Chennai as Hazlewood stars

TABLE-TOPPING Royal Challengers Bengaluru thrashed Chennai Super Kings by 50 runs on Friday (28) for a second win in this year's IPL, inspired by a "game-changing" performance from fast bowler Josh Hazlewood.

Chasing 197, Chennai wilted despite a late cameo by veteran MS Dhoni who clubbed 30 runs off 16 balls, batting low down at nine in the order.

Keep ReadingShow less
IPL 2025 – GT vs MI: Who Will Secure Their First Win

Both teams eager to secure their maiden win of IPL 2025

Getty

IPL 2025 - GT vs MI: Gujarat Titans and Mumbai Indians aim for first win

The ninth match of the Indian Premier League (IPL) 2025 will take place on March 29 at the Narendra Modi Stadium in Ahmedabad, featuring a highly anticipated clash between Gujarat Titans (GT) and Mumbai Indians (MI). Both teams will be keen to register their first win of the season after disappointing starts in their respective opening matches. This game is expected to be a closely fought contest, with each side eager to make an early impact in the tournament.

Gujarat Titans: Seeking redemption after high-scoring defeat

Gujarat Titans, led by Shubman Gill, began their IPL 2025 campaign with a high-scoring encounter against the Punjab Kings, but unfortunately ended up on the losing side. Despite some positive individual performances, the team was unable to secure a victory, and they will be keen to turn things around against MI.

Keep ReadingShow less