Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Comment: Tory leadership contenders may face bigger hurdles after race is won

As Conservatives gather for their first conference since electoral defeat, the leadership contest raises questions about the future of the party

Comment: Tory leadership contenders may face bigger hurdles after race is won
Conservative Party leadership candidate, Robert Jenrick, conducts media interviews at Birmingham ICC Arena on October 01, 2024 in Birmingham, England (Photo by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

If somebody of soaring public ambition ever seeks your advice on how to become Prime Minister, history suggests one obvious starting point: get elected to lead the Conservative Party.

Every single Tory leader from 1922 until 1997 got to Downing Street – until that pattern was broken by William Hague, Iain Duncan Smith and Michael Howard in quick succession. Whoever wins this 2024 leadership contest is less likely to find themselves Prime Minister in five years’ time than to join that unhappy club of Tory leaders who didn’t quite make it.


Who will be the next leader is the dominant question among Conservatives at their first party conference since their election hammering. The question many outside the party are asking may be: how much does it matter anyway?

This Birmingham party conference is a showcase to test the four leadership contenders before MPs knock two out, leaving party members to choose a leader from the two finalists. Robert Jenrick came to Birmingham as the frontrunner for two reasons: that he is the sole member of the quartet who is almost certain to make the final ballot – and because Kemi Badenoch seems unlikely to hang on to second place to face him.

Pre-conference polling of party members by Conservative Home finds Jenrick would start with a 27-point lead against Tom Tugendhat, double his 14 per cent advantage against James Cleverly. He currently trails Kemi Badenoch by 13 percentage points, so would become the underdog against her.

A tiny parliamentary party - just 121 MPs – makes the run-off hard to predict. The votes of one-third of MPs guarantee a ballot place. Second or third preferences will decide who makes it into the final two. Over a third of MPs – at least 37 – will choose again when their candidate gets eliminated.

Robert Jenrick, on 33 votes, is almost through. Kemi Badenoch, on 28 votes, is worrying out loud about a Westminster “stitch-up” if MPs don’t put her through as the members favourite.

Britain's main opposition Conservative Party Shadow Housing, Communities and Local Government Secretary Kemi Badenoch hugs a delegate on the second day of the annual Conservative Party Conference in Birmingham, central England, on September 30, 2024. (Photo by HENRY NICHOLLS / AFP) (Photo by HENRY NICHOLLS/AFP via Getty Images)

James Cleverly and Tom Tugendhat, both on 21 votes, are now in a head-to-head elimination battle to become the “stop Kemi” candidate. Whoever survives the next round might overtake Badenoch by converting the other’s voters. Yet Badenoch could pitch herself to MPs as being the “stop Jenrick” candidate instead – if she could win over a dozen more centrist MPs, from supporters of Mel Stride, or whoever gets knocked out next. Yet Badenoch’s opening interventions at this conference – questioning whether those from all cultural backgrounds could integrate equally into British identity, and a muddled interview criticising maternity pay – have probably made her Westminster challenge harder.

This contest has been more about personality than party strategy or policy., though the candidates do have different priorities. Tugendhat made his name on foreign policy. Badenoch is best known for wanting conservatives to take a robust line on identity issues. Jenrick has reinvented his politics over immigration and asylum. But there are few policy arguments. All four candidates have said what they think party members want to hear – influenced by how Rishi Sunak lost to Liz Truss after criticising the tax plans which were to implode so spectacularly.

This quartet stand for lower taxes – but defend a universal winter fuel payment to pensioners. They want the state to do less, better – but with more emphasis on higher spending on defence, prisons and policing than on what to cut back from. Badenoch opposes the smoking ban and a football regulator as excessively statist projects bequeathed to Labour.

Jenrick says the Conservatives were wrong to accept the New Labour legacy of Equalities, Human Rights and Climate Change Acts, and wants to leave the European Convention on Human Rights. Tugendhat – somewhat implausibly – says he would be prepared to do so too, as a last resort.

Keir Starmer gives the new Tory leader hope. He made it to Downing Street in one term himself, after succeeding Jeremy Corbyn; and Starmer’s stuttering start as Prime Minister makes the new Opposition leader’s task less hopeless than that facing William Hague in 1997.

Yet the Conservatives look in deeper trouble than Labour in 2019. Their MPs are outnumbered more than three-to-one-, and the-party membership is ageing and shrinking. The next leader must win back many of the voters lost to Nigel Farage’s Reform party while also winning back most of the 65 seats lost to the Liberal Democrats in the new “Yellow Wall” across the south of England and bridging the generational gulf in the party’s vote. It may take a minor political miracle to achieve all of that in one term – yet David Cameron’s four successors as Tory leader since 2016 have only lasted an average of two years. The next leader – announced on November 2nd – will need to prove this once-glittering prize in British politics is not now a poisoned chalice.

(The author is the director of British Future)

More For You

My top 10 books by Nilesha Chauvet

Nilesha Chauvet

My top 10 books by Nilesha Chauvet

Eastern Eye

NILESHA CHAUVET made her mark in 2024 with her deliciously dark debut crime novel Her Two Lives.

The psychological suspense thriller revolves around a woman who cares for the elderly by day and becomes a vigilante by night. The acclaimed book grew from her love for literature.

Keep ReadingShow less
Empuraan Storm: Success, Censorship Debate & Political Attacks

Prithviraj Sukumaran and Mohanlal at a press meet for L2: Empuraan

Instagram/empuraanmovie

L2: Empuraan - A film that shattered records and sparked a political storm

Few films manage to be both a record-breaking success and a lightning rod for controversy at the same time. But L2: Empuraan, the much-hyped sequel to Lucifer, has done exactly that. The Prithviraj Sukumaran directorial, starring Mohanlal, has not only rewritten and shattered box office history but also sparked a nationwide debate on censorship, political narratives, and artistic freedom.

On one hand, it’s the fastest Malayalam film to gross £5.1 million (₹50 crore) in Kerala, the first Malayalam film to cross £10.2 million (₹100 crore) overseas, and a £20.4 million (₹200 crore) club entrant within just five days. On the other hand, it has been accused of pushing a political agenda, leading to 2m 8s, 24 last-minute cuts, a legal battle, and a full-blown culture war.

Keep ReadingShow less
My playlist with Nachiket Lele

Nachiket Lele

My playlist with Nachiket Lele

POPULAR Indian Idol contestants Sayli Kamble, Nitin Kumar, and Nachiket Lele will headline a UK concert at Brentford Studios on April 19. The talented singers will perform hit songs from across the decades, including from Bollywood.

Eastern Eye caught up with Nachiket Lele ahead of the highly anticipated show and asked him to select 10 songs he loves.

Keep ReadingShow less
british-muslims-iStock

The study noted that this identification was not due to any doctrinal obligation but was influenced by the perception that many Muslims do not feel fully accepted as British. (Representational image: iStock)

iStock

Majority of British Muslims identify by faith first, study finds

A STUDY by the Institute for the Impact of Faith in Life (IIFL) has found that most British Muslims identify primarily with their religion rather than their nationality.

The research, based on a survey of 815 British Muslim adults by Whitestone Insight, revealed that 71 per cent of respondents identified as Muslim first, while 27 per cent identified as British, English, or Scottish first.

Keep ReadingShow less
Hayley Atwell Reveals Tom Cruise’s Advice on Social Anxiety

Atwell explained that Cruise’s advice helped her focus on identifying the sources of her anxiety

Getty

Mission Impossible star Hayley Atwell reveals Tom Cruise's advice to overcome social anxiety

Hayley Atwell has opened up about the helpful advice Tom Cruise gave her on how to cope with social anxiety, a topic that resonates with many, including those working in the intense world of Hollywood. Atwell, known for her role as Peggy Carter in Marvel films and for starring alongside Cruise in Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning (2023), revealed how Cruise's wisdom has helped her deal with nervousness in large social gatherings, something she’s not immune to despite her prominent career.

As Atwell prepares to reprise her role in what is expected to be the last chapter of the Mission: Impossible series, The Final Reckoning, due for release in May, her reflections on social anxiety offer an insightful perspective on how even the most successful stars experience self-doubt. She recently discussed this on the Reign with Josh Smith podcast, explaining how she often battles the feelings that come with being in a room full of people.

Keep ReadingShow less