Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Putting history in today’s time frame

by Amit Roy

IF YOU are comfortably seated, here is your starter question for 10: what row unites Oxford and Aligarh Mus­lim universities?


The answer is, of course, a con­troversy over removing portraits.

Since 1938, the Aligarh Muslim University, a respected educational establishment in India founded in 1875, has had a portrait of Muham­mad Ali Jinnah, once a champion of Hindu-Muslim unity, but later the foremost champion of a separate Pakistan for India’s Muslims.

It is for this reason that the pre­sent chief minister of the Bharatiya Janata Party-ruled state of Uttar Pradesh, Yogi Adityanath, wants Jinnah’s portrait to be consigned to the dustbin of history.

The students see this as more of an anti-Muslim move.

“No way, sir... The portrait will remain there,” was the defiant re­sponse from Mashkoor Ahmad Usmani, the students’ union presi­dent at the university.

“Whatever it is, you can’t erase history and Jinnah is part of the his­tory of undivided India.”

There have been minor skirmish­es between students and the police, who are accused of taking their or­ders from the state administration and various extremist Hindu groups. The portrait was taken down, but quickly restored.

“I think the glorification of Jinnah is unfortunate,” Adiyanath fumed. “My government would act strictly against all those who were behind the trouble.”

In Oxford, meanwhile, a portrait of Theresa May has been removed from the geography school where the prime minster was once a stu­dent. It had been put up a couple of weeks ago, along with pictures of other female geographers, as an en­couragement to future generations.

But quite a few students posted critical notices on the photograph because they felt the prime minister had not shown very much diversity in her immigration policy – over Windrush, for example.

An Oxford University spokesman said: “The portrait was being in­creasingly obscured by posters bearing mainly humorous satirical messages. It has now been taken down and will be re-displayed, so it can be seen as intended.”

It can be argued that the cases of Jinnah and May are different. But to avoid double standards, May’s por­trait should also be restored.

More For You

Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment

Vicky Kaushal in 'Chhaava'

Chhaava

Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment

UK SHOW IS A SHOCKER

THE recent Rewind Queens tour was an absolute shocker. The concerts had already been postponed from 2024 due to Alka Yagnik’s severe illness, yet organisers likely knew she wouldn’t be able to perform in the January shows in London and Birmingham – but only announced her absence days before.

Keep ReadingShow less
Column: How much longer will Rachel Reeves stay on as chancellor?

Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves

Column: How much longer will Rachel Reeves stay on as chancellor?

THERE are a few Labour MPs who think “Rachel from accounts will be gone sooner than you think”.

She has certainly outdone Liz Truss in trashing the economy, but the prime minister, Sir Keir Starmer, will be loath to sack Rachel Reeves as chancellor because his own future is tied up with hers.

Keep ReadingShow less
​Himesh Reshammiya's silly quest for acting stardom

Himesh Reshammiya

​Himesh Reshammiya's silly quest for acting stardom

IN THE early 1950s, legendary music icon Mukesh was so desperate to become a leading man that he stopped singing for major movies to focus on making an acting breakthrough.

Decades later, Sonu Nigam also tried his hand at acting by starring in a few films. What these two singing stars had in common was that they both failed as actors and quickly realised when to stop. Both quit acting, concentrated on music, and went on to have incredible singing careers.

Keep ReadingShow less
Reeves set to revise non-doms tax rules

Rachel Reeves

Reeves set to revise non-doms tax rules

ANY day now Rachel Reeves will be sending a “cease and desist” letter to Liz Truss, demanding that the former prime minister stop saying she has “crashed the economy”.

Such “false and defamatory” allegations were harming her political reputation, the chancellor will probably add.

Keep ReadingShow less
Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment
Saif Ali Khan
Saif Ali Khan

Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment

COMIC SINGH IN UK

PUNJABI-language stand-up comedian Manpreet Singh will return to the UK in March for a series of shows at Midlands Arts Centre in Birmingham (21), The Urban Building in Slough (22), and Chutney Ivy in Leicester (23). Affectionately known as Comic Singh, the top Indian talent promises a performance powered by family-friendly humour. He will follow up the UK tour with his first-ever shows in Germany and Holland in April.

Keep ReadingShow less