Skip to content 
Search

Latest Stories

Legal experts doubt Sunak’s Rwanda treaty will satisfy Supreme Court

The Law Society expresses alarm at the government’s attempt to use law to alter facts, stating that such actions significantly undermine the rule of law and the constitutional role of the courts

Legal experts doubt Sunak’s Rwanda treaty will satisfy Supreme Court

A House of Lords inquiry has conveyed that Rishi Sunak’s Rwanda treaty is unlikely to alleviate concerns raised by the Supreme Court regarding the country's suitability for sending asylum seekers.

As the legal and human rights communities prepare for a showdown on the legislation, the Law Society, along with academics and human rights groups, voices apprehensions that the treaty could undermine the rule of law and emphasises the untested nature of Rwanda's proposed asylum system.


The Law Society points to the recent supreme court judgment against Rwanda's asylum policy, highlighting structural issues within the country's asylum system.

They express doubts about the treaty and additional measures effectively addressing the supreme court's concerns.

In their evidence to the Lords international agreements committee, the Law Society expresses alarm at the UK government's attempt to use law to alter facts, stating that such actions significantly undermine the rule of law and the constitutional role of the courts, The Guardian reported.

The Immigration Lawyers Practitioners Association, in collaboration with the human rights organisation Justice, also expresses skepticism, suggesting that the treaty and Rwanda's assurances may not be enough to alleviate the concerns raised by the supreme court.

Academic legal experts, Prof Catherine Briddick and Prof Cathryn Costello, jointly release an assessment arguing that the use of an international treaty does not automatically make Rwanda a safe country.

They emphasise that the assessment of safety is an empirical matter, not solely a legal one, and caution against assuming safety based solely on the conclusion of an international treaty.

The Bar Council raises concerns about the untested nature of the proposed new arrangements for Rwanda's asylum system, stating that their effectiveness depends on implementation and scrutiny. They anticipate that the treaty's alignment with the supreme court's concerns may be tested in the courts.

The treaty, signed after the supreme court struck down Sunak's initial plan, seeks to overhaul Rwanda's asylum system and introduce independent scrutiny mechanisms. It forms the basis for Sunak's new legislation declaring Rwanda a safe place for deporting asylum seekers entering the UK via small boats.

While the UK government defends the legal robustness of the treaty's proposed system, critics, including the Commons home affairs committee, call for a separate debate on the UK-Rwanda treaty.

The prime minister is preparing for a Commons battle on Tuesday and Wednesday next week over the legislation. Sir Robert Buckland, the former justice secretary, has proposed several amendments to the safety of Rwanda bill, including one that would eliminate clauses declaring it a safe country.

Conservative moderates are anticipated to refrain from rebellion unless concessions are made by Sunak to right-wing MPs representing the “five families” of factions opposing international treaties that can impede flights.

Suella Braverman, the former home secretary, and a prominent figure among the right-wing rebels, confirmed on Friday (12) that she would vote against it in its current form.

Speaking to GB News, she said, “I’m only going to support a bill that works as currently drafted. This bill does not work. And if there are no improvements to it, I will have to vote against it. I’m sent to parliament to vote for things or to be against them, not to sit on the fence.”

On Friday, the Commons home affairs committee called for the government to allocate time for MPs to deliberate and form an opinion on the UK-Rwanda treaty, distinct from their work on the Rwanda legislation.

The House of Lords inquiry into the Rwanda treaty by the international agreements committee, led by Peter Goldsmith KC, serves as the primary venue where the deal itself is undergoing comprehensive scrutiny within parliament.

More For You

Priyanka Chopra

Priyanka Chopra says she wants strong roles not just ornamental characters

Getty Images

Priyanka Chopra says she is just getting started in Hollywood with 'Heads of State' on Prime Video

Quick highlights:

  • Priyanka Chopra Jonas says she’s just getting started in Hollywood.
  • Stars as a fierce MI6 agent alongside Idris Elba and John Cena.
  • Gets into serious action mode with explosions, helicopters, and hand-to-hand combat.
  • Says her journey is still evolving, with much more to explore in the West.

Priyanka Chopra Jonas may have ruled Bollywood for over two decades, but the global star believes she’s still “nascent” in her Hollywood journey, and that’s what makes it exciting.

The Quantico and Citadel actor stars in the new Amazon Prime Video film Heads of State, playing a sharp MI6 agent named Noel Bisset. Her character has a complicated history with British Prime Minister Sam Clarke (played by Idris Elba) and is tasked with protecting him and the newly elected US President Will Derringer (John Cena) when they're attacked before a major NATO conference.

Keep ReadingShow less
Arijit Singh

Arijit Singh becomes most followed musician on Spotify

Getty Images

Arijit Singh overtakes Taylor Swift and Ed Sheeran to become most followed artist on Spotify

Quick highlights:

• Arijit Singh makes global music history with 151 million Spotify followers

• Surpasses Taylor Swift and Ed Sheeran in follower count

Keep ReadingShow less
Manchester Police probes over 1,000 child sexual abuse suspects

Photo for representation. (iStock)

Getty Images/iStockphoto

Manchester Police probes over 1,000 child sexual abuse suspects

GREATER MANCHESTER POLICE is now investigating more than 1,000 child sexual abuse suspects, following years of public criticism and institutional failings in tackling child sexual exploitation.

A new report by His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS) has revealed the force has made “significant improvements” in dealing with group-based sexual abuse and related crimes.

Keep ReadingShow less
Diwali

This year’s Diwali event will still see Belgrave Road continue to host what is left of the festival. (Representational image)

Major changes announced for Leicester’s Diwali celebrations amid safety fears

LDRS

THIS year’s annual Diwali celebrations will be stripped back amid public safety fears. Leicester City Council has said there will be no fireworks or stage entertainment as part of major changes announced for the event.

Cossington Street Recreation Ground will also not be used for the festivities, the council has revealed. The green space previously was the location for the main stage and the Diwali Village with its food stalls, funfair rides, fashion and arts. The annual fire garden display was also based there, offering “a peaceful oasis amid the festive excitement”.

Keep ReadingShow less
Liam Gallagher

Liam Gallagher arrives for the special screening of Oasis documentary "Supersonic"

Getty Images

Liam Gallagher apologises for racial slur after backlash as Oasis reunion tour kicks off

Quick highlights:

  • Liam Gallagher issued an apology after using a racial slur in a now-deleted social media post.
  • The offensive post appeared just days before Oasis kicked off their reunion tour in Cardiff.
  • Fans criticised the singer on X, prompting him to clarify it was unintentional.
  • Oasis will perform over 40 shows globally, starting 5 July in Wales.

Liam Gallagher has apologised for using a racial slur in a post on X, as Oasis reunites for their first tour in 15 years. The singer shared a one-word reply on Monday that included a derogatory term aimed at East Asian people. Though he quickly deleted it, screenshots circulated online, sparking widespread criticism.

In a follow-up post on Tuesday, Gallagher wrote: “Sorry if I offended anyone with my tweet before it wasn’t intentional you know I love you all and I do not discriminate. Peace and love LG x.”

Keep ReadingShow less