Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Judge: "Failures endemic" at Judicial Appointments Commission

Judge: "Failures endemic" at Judicial Appointments Commission

JUDGES are sharing so-called “live questions” used in recruitment exercises with consultants offering to coach candidates to get top judicial appointments, a tribunal has heard from a senior south Asian judge. 

On the second day of the online hearing, Judge Abbas Mithani KC, suggested the current process could be open to abuse.


It emerged that the Judicial Appointments Commission [JAC] uses “a bank of questions” which are swapped around for different recruitment dates.

Ian Thomson Ian Thomson (Pic: LinkedIn)

During cross examination of the JAC’s head of corporate services, Ian Thomson, Mithani asked, “It is a fallacy, isn’t it Mr Thomson, to assume that those who have been successful or unsuccessful in the past will not wish to share such information as they are able to with these consultancy organisations?”

The judge heading the General Regulatory Chamber hearing, Lynn Griffin, asked whether Mithani had any evidence for his allegations.

He had not included any evidence because it would mean naming some of the consultancies which he “didn’t think was right”, he responded.

Possible abuse

The designated civil judge for the West Midlands and Warwickshire, also accused the body which appoints members to the judiciary of allowing some candidates to have an advantage over others.

Abbas Mithani Abbas Mithani

The tribunal is determining whether the JAC and the Information Commissioner’s Office [ICO] were wrong to withhold material sought by Mithani through three of his freedom of information requests. The judge wanted the information to investigate whether there was racial discrimination and gender bias when it came to judicial appointments.

The tribunal heard that in one part of the exercise, candidates are asked to answer scenario questions.

In a detailed cross examination, Mithani took Thomson through evidence of how candidates who had previously applied to become a judge and failed could be given the same questions when they reapplied.

“A applies in the 2015 resident judge competition,” he surmised, “he’s given an interview and refused.

“Three years later, he applies for an identical position either in that circuit or another circuit.

“Are you saying that the JAC will go back to see whether he has applied in the previous exercise?”

Thomson told the three-member panel that while the JAC would not look at the records of the individual applicants, it would not repeat the same questions in successive job competitions in the same region.

He said, “I would imagine if, for example, that only two people applied for a particular exercise, which was four years apart, and people were aware of that there is a connection, the information is not finalised until the last possible moment, things could alter.

“That’s why we have reserve situational questions that we can use.

“But I don’t think we would look back on the candidates because that would be unfair looking back because a candidate should have the right to apply when they feel they are suitable.”

Thomson conceded that it was possible that someone from the selection team could recognise a candidate who had previously applied for the same role.

In that case, he said, the team would decide the “whether the situational question is appropriate”.

Endemic failures

In a testy exchange, Mithani asked Thomson whether he “seriously expected” the panel or him to believe that the JAC relied on the memories of staff members to recognise repeat candidates.

The head of corporate services maintained that in certain situations, such as the team which organises selection processes for senior leaders, where the numbers were few, then JAC staff would remember those who had applied before.

Natasha Simonsen Natasha Simonsen

“In any selection exercise,” argued Mithani, “whether it’s for a senior leadership position, circuit judge, district judge, or deputy district judge, if that situational question is used again, it is inconceivable that the staff would be able to recall them.”

He continued that there were “failures which are endemic at the JAC” and that it “pays lip service to the regulations and the provisions which govern it.”

Counsel for the JAC, Natasha Simonsen reiterated her contention that Mithani’s allegations were “serious, unsubstantiated and baseless”.

In re-examining Thomson, the barrister asked whether the JAC or he had misled the ICO, or whether “there was some sort of a cover up”, or whether he was “trying to hide anything”, to which he said no.

The Information Commissioner’s Office is not taking part in this tribunal, which is expected to resume in June.

Also read: Judicial head “guilty of gross negligence and deliberate recklessness”

More For You

Rockstar Boots GTA Player Mid-Stream After Jailbroken PS5 Leak

The footage of the removal quickly circulated on social media

iStock

Rockstar kicks GTA Online player mid-stream for leaking new DLC via jailbroken PS5

Rockstar Games has taken swift action against a GTA Online player who streamed unreleased content from the upcoming Money Fronts update using a jailbroken PlayStation 5. The player was removed from an online session in real-time by a Rockstar administrator, reinforcing the studio’s zero-tolerance stance on leaks and unauthorised access.

Player ejected during livestream

During the livestream, the user was showcasing content from the Money Fronts downloadable content (DLC), which is officially due for release on 17 June 2025. Midway through the broadcast, the stream was interrupted with an on-screen message that read:

Keep ReadingShow less
Simone Ashley

Simone Ashley appears without dialogue in Brad Pitt’s F1 after major cuts to her role

Getty Images

Simone Ashley cut from Brad Pitt’s 'F1' as director confirms her storyline was removed

Simone Ashley, best known for her breakout role in Bridgerton, won’t have the screen time fans expected in Brad Pitt’s upcoming Formula 1 film F1. Despite being part of the film’s promotional buzz and having filmed scenes alongside the main cast, Ashley’s role was trimmed down to a blink-and-miss appearance with no dialogue.

Director Joseph Kosinski confirmed the change, stating that the edit came down to tough decisions made during the final cut. Speaking in an interview, he said, “Every movie has more content than it can use. We had to drop two or three storylines for pacing. Unfortunately, Simone’s was one of them.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Air India CEO

Social media users quickly pointed out that large portions of the statement

Reuters

Air India CEO’s crash statement draws plagiarism claims over striking similarity to US airline speech

Air India has come under fresh scrutiny following the deadly crash of Flight AI171 in Ahmedabad on 12 June 2025, which claimed more than 270 lives. This time, controversy surrounds the airline’s chief executive, Campbell Wilson, who is facing allegations of plagiarism over the phrasing used in his speech following the tragedy.

Speech similarity sparks online backlash

Two days after the crash, Air India released a video of Wilson expressing condolences and detailing the airline’s response. However, social media users quickly pointed out that large portions of the statement closely resembled remarks made by American Airlines CEO Robert Isom after a separate fatal mid-air incident in the US earlier this year.

Keep ReadingShow less
Air India flight crash

Debris of Air India flight 171 is pictured after it crashed in a residential area near the airport in Ahmedabad on June 13, 2025.

Getty Images

Leicester to observe silence for Air India crash victims during Rathayatra festival

A MINUTE of silence will be observed in Leicester on Sunday, June 22, to remember those who died in the recent Air India crash. The silence will take place during the inauguration of the annual Rathayatra festival of chariots in the city centre.

Organisers from the International Society for Krishna Consciousness confirmed the silence will be held at 11.20am, followed by traditional Hindu performances from Gujarat at Gallowtree Gate, outside Sports Direct.

Keep ReadingShow less
Dua Lipa

Dua Lipa prepares to take over Wembley Stadium with back-to-back shows this weekend

Getty Images

Dua Lipa to headline Wembley Stadium for the first time with Radical Optimism tour

Dua Lipa is heading home. For the first time in her career, the chart-topping pop star will headline Wembley Stadium in London this weekend, and fans are buzzing with anticipation. The two-night stop is part of her Radical Optimism world tour, which kicked off in Asia and will continue through the end of 2025. Here’s everything you need to know before heading to one of the capital’s biggest gigs this summer.

When, where, and what to expect from Dua’s Radical Optimism shows

Keep ReadingShow less