Some TV characters don’t just steal scenes, instead they hijack the spotlight and refuse to let go. These are the sidekicks who outshone the leads, the villains we secretly rooted for, and the oddballs who made us laugh harder than anyone else. Yet, despite their brilliance, they never got the spin-off they deserved.
From chaotic con artists to deadpan queens, here are 10 unforgettable characters who should’ve headlined their own shows and why fans are still begging for them.
1.Dwight Schrute (The Office)
Rainn Wilson’s beet-farming, bear-defeating Assistant to the Regional Manager was this close to getting The Farm, a spin-off about Schrute Farms’ chaotic B&B life. Picture it: Dwight battling bedbugs, training his son to be a warrior, and fending off Angela’s judgemental glares. A mockumentary goldmine cancelled before it even began.
Beets, bears, and brilliant chaos—Dwight Schrute was ready to make Schrute Farms the weirdest B&B on TVGetty Images
2.Jean-Ralphio Saperstein (Parks and Recreation)
The human embodiment of a glitter explosion, Jean-Ralphio (Ben Schwartz) was a walking disaster with “spin-off” written all over him. A Catch Me If You Can-style comedy about his scams, fake deaths, and toxic synergy with sister Mona Lisa? The worst idea? Hardly. Ben Schwartz has expressed openness to revisiting the character, though no official plans have been announced.
Too fabulous to function—Jean-Ralphio was born to star in his own disaster-fuelled comedyGetty Images
3.Omar Little (The Wire)
The whistling, shotgun-toting Robin Hood of Baltimore was TV’s most charming antihero. A prequel exploring his early days robbing drug lords, navigating the streets, and living by his own moral code? That’s a show HBO should’ve greenlit.
Omar - a prequel about his early days could’ve been HBO’s next gritty masterpieceGetty Images
4.April Ludgate (Parks and Recreation)
Aubrey Plaza’s deadpan anarchist was a cult favourite. A spin-off following her FBI career or her and Andy’s hilariously dysfunctional parenting would’ve been dark, weird, and perfect.
Deadpan, dark, and delightful—April Ludgate’s FBI spin-off would’ve been everythingGetty Images
5.Lafayette Reynolds (True Blood)
Nelsan Ellis’ sassy, fearless medium and vampire-blood dealer was the show’s breakout star. A New Orleans-set prequel diving into the wild past including voodoo, underground deals, and sass for days would’ve been legendary.
Sassy, spiritual, and full of secrets—Lafayette’s backstory was screaming for a supernatural seriesGetty Images
6.Spike (Buffy the Vampire Slayer)
James Marsters’ snarky, soulful vampire had centuries of backstory to mine: Victorian poet, chaotic villain, reluctant hero. A Spike: Blood & Poetry spin-off? Fans would’ve lined up faster than he could say, “Out for a walk… bitch.”
From Victorian poetry to vampire slaying, Spike’s centuries-long saga deserved its own spotlightGetty Images
7.Schmidt (New Girl)
Max Greenfield’s high-strung, turtleneck-loving businessman was comedy gold. A Schmidt & Cece rom-com spin-off, bringing his neurotic charm and confidence, would’ve been the perfect follow-up. Fans have discussed the idea on forums, expressing interest in seeing Schmidt in a more centred role.
Confidence, quirks, and questionable fashion—Schmidt’s next chapter could’ve been rom-com goldGetty Images
8.Negan (The Walking Dead)
Jeffrey Dean Morgan’s bat-swinging villain turned antihero was too compelling to leave behind. Fortunately, fans got their wish with The Walking Dead: Dead City, a spin-off series that premiered in 2023, following Negan and Maggie's journey into a post-apocalyptic Manhattan. The series has been renewed for a second season, set to premiere on May 4, 2025.
The villain we hated to love—Negan did get his spin-off, and it’s a bloody good oneGetty Images
9.Luna Lovegood (Harry Potter)
Evanna Lynch’s whimsical conspiracy theorist was a total fan favourite. A Luna & the Crumple-Horned Snorkack adventure series; part X-Files, part magical road trip, would’ve been pure, quirky joy. Fans have long imagined Luna as a magical researcher travelling the world to solve mysteries.
Whimsical and wise—Luna’s magical adventures would’ve been a dreamy, otherworldly delightGetty Images
10.Gina Linetti (Brooklyn Nine-Nine)
Chelsea Peretti’s narcissistic, chaos-loving goddess deserved her own Gina Takes Manhattan influencer satire. Imagine her “advising” CEOs, crashing elite parties, and documenting it all for social media. Iconic. Peretti left the show after season 6, but fans continue to clamour for more Gina content.
Chaotic queen energy—Gina’s influencer-era spin-off would’ve broken the internetGetty Images
The spin-offs that got away
Some characters are so vivid, they don’t just live in their shows but haunt them, leaving fans wanting more. While we got gems like Frasier and Better Call Saul, these 10 icons were left in the spin-off graveyard.
So, who tops your list? A Creed Bratton crime thriller? A Tormund Giantsbane wildling comedy? But if there’s one thing TV taught us, it’s that the best characters never really say goodbye.
Stars at the Bvlgari event Getty Images 
Priyanka’s elegant beige look paired with Bvlgari jewellery turns heads on the red carpetGetty Images