Skip to content 
Search

Latest Stories

Dispelling massacre myths

by AMIT ROY

THE “best book I have ever read on the Empire”, was how journalist Sathnam Sanghera described Kim Wagner’s book, Amritsar 1919: An Empire of Fear & The Making of a Massacre, when they both appeared at the National Army Museum last Saturday (13) on the centenary of Jallianwala Bagh to discuss the atrocity.


Wagner, who teaches the history of colonial India and the British Empire at Queen Mary College, University of London, said it was important to dispel some of the many myths about the massacre.

Also appearing on the panel, which was chaired by Sanghera, were Amandeep Singh Madra and Parmjit Singh, who said they were helped by Wagner to put together their illustrated book, Eyewitness at Amritsar: A Visual History of the 1919 Jallianwala Bagh Massacre.

Wagner began by analysing the makeup of the 379 people killed in the shooting ordered by Brig Gen Reginald Dyer. Unofficially, Indian sources put the toll at between 500 and 1,000.

“Sikhs made up 15 per cent of the population of Amritsar in 1919,” he said. “And they made up – as far as we can tell – 30 per cent of those who were killed. More than 50 per cent were Hindus and the rest were Muslims.”

Later, he put the proportion of Hindus at 55 per cent.

“So, this is a Punjabi event, not a Sikh event,” he emphasised. “There were possibly

Sikh soldiers among those who fired. And it forces us to face the hard facts and perhaps reassess some of the assumptions we have.”

Another myth is that 120 bodies were recovered from the well in the garden, into which people allegedly jumped to try and dodge the soldiers’ bullets.

“There weren’t any bodies recovered from the well,” Wagner said.

Pressed by Sanghera to identify his sources, Wagner said: “I have not come across that in the primary evidence. When Motilal Nehru and (educationist and politician) Pandit Madan Mohan Malaviya go there after martial law has been lifted, they think they see something in the well, and it is a clay pot and a cloth.

“There are no bodies in the well, which does not change the horrific nature of the massacre. I think it is a confusion with the well in Cawnpore – European women and

children (were found there) in 1857.

“You can’t depict the massacre on TV without seeing people jumping into a well. It’s not factually accurate.”

Wagner added: “There is another possibility. The canal that feeds the tank runs right under Jallianwala Bagh. There is a manhole and there are people who went in there to hide from the bullets and some of them were killed. So maybe bodies were pulled out of the canal and, in the retelling, that became 120 people pulled out of the well.”

Another myth was about Udham Singh, the man who assassinated Dyer’s political boss and the military governor of the Punjab, Michael O’Dwyer, in London in 1940 and was hanged for the crime: “So much about Udham Singh has been created afterwards. He wasn’t present at Jallianwala Bagh.”

Wagner believes Dyer was not a lone rogue soldier, but that his actions reflected how India was ruled by the British. He was responding to a question about the British officer, who had once been very popular with his Indian soldiers and had, in fact, resigned from a club for British officers because of its racist policy of excluding Indians.

“Gen Dyer was typical of British military personnel and, sadly, they were all capable of carrying out these kinds of acts,” he replied.

Asked by Sanghera whether books such as his on Amritsar would still be relevant in six months when the centenary had passed, Wagner replied: “The Amritsar massacre is not just about one particular moment in time. Rather than a unique event, it is actually quite revealing of the way the British ruled India.”

Wagner, who is of Danish origin but has lived in the UK for 20 years, later revealed: “I am named after Kipling’s (1900) novel (Kim) and my parents took me to India when I was a baby. So, it’s in my blood. I have been to Amritsar every year for the past five years.”

He accepted there was “a big difference” in the response to Jallianwala between Indians in the UK and those in India: “The hyper nationalist sentiments in India are usually absent from the south Asian community in the UK.”

More For You

Imran Khan

The announcement comes as the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party, led by jailed former prime minister Imran Khan, prepares for nationwide protests on August 5, marking two years since his arrest.

Getty Images

Pakistan announces new paramilitary force ahead of PTI protests

PAKISTAN has announced the creation of a new national paramilitary force, raising concerns among opposition parties and human rights groups about its possible use for political repression.

The new force will be called the Federal Constabulary and will be formed by restructuring an existing paramilitary unit currently operating along the northwestern border with Afghanistan, state minister for the Interior Talal Chaudhry said at a press conference in Faisalabad on Monday.

Keep ReadingShow less
Altaf Hussain

Hussain has been living in London since 1992 and holds British citizenship. (Photo credit: Getty Images)

Getty Images

Founder of Pakistan's MQM Altaf Hussain hospitalised in London

Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) founder Altaf Hussain has been hospitalised in London after falling seriously ill, according to a party official.

Hussain, 71, was admitted to a hospital on Thursday due to a severe illness, where doctors carried out various tests, Mustafa Azizabadi, Convener of MQM’s Central Coordination Committee, said on social media.

Keep ReadingShow less
Communities face 'powder keg' of unrest risk, report warns

Social media emerged as a significant threat to community cohesion, the British Future report said. (Photo: Getty Images)

Communities face 'powder keg' of unrest risk, report warns

COMMUNITIES remain at risk of fresh unrest unless urgent action is taken to address deep-seated social tensions, a new report, published one year after last summer's riots, has cautioned.

Titled 'The State of Us' by British Future thinktank and the Belong Network, the report published on Tuesday (15) said successive governments have failed to take action and warned that a "powder keg" of unresolved grievances could easily ignite again without immediate intervention.

Keep ReadingShow less
Metropolitan police

The Metropolitan Police said the sentencing followed a 'comprehensive operation'. (Photo: Getty Images)

Getty Images

Gang jailed for stealing £1 million jewellery from London’s Indian community

FOUR members of an organised crime network that stole more than £1 million worth of jewellery from Indian and South Asian families in London have been sentenced to a total of 17 years and one month in prison.

The Metropolitan Police said the sentencing followed a “comprehensive operation” that led to the imprisonment of Jerry O’Donnell, 33, Barney Maloney, Quey Adger, 23, and Patrick Ward, 43. All four were sentenced at Snaresbrook Crown Court on Friday after previously pleading guilty to burglary.

Keep ReadingShow less
Air India flight crash
Air India's Boeing 787-8 aircraft, operating flight AI-171 to London Gatwick, crashed into a medical hostel complex shortly after take-off from Ahmedabad on June 12.
Getty Images

After report of CAA warning on Boeing fuel switches, regulator issues clarification

FOUR weeks before an Air India Boeing 787-8 crashed after takeoff from Ahmedabad, media reports cited a safety notice issued by the UK's Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) highlighting potential issues with fuel control switches on Boeing aircraft.

The CAA has now clarified that the safety notice in question — Safety Notice Number SN-2015/005 — was originally issued in 2015. The document was updated on 15 May 2025 only to change the contact email address. This routine administrative update caused the document to appear on the CAA website as if it were newly issued.

Keep ReadingShow less