Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Did race, ethnicity, or honour play a part in Will Smith's Oscars slap?

Did race, ethnicity, or honour play a part in Will Smith's Oscars slap?

ON ITS news website, the BBC, in an article entitled Why did Will Smith hit Chris Rock at the Oscars? discusses various theories, including ‘There were elements of performative alphamale behaviour at play here. An instinctiveness for a man to harm another man who insults his partner’.

In fact, this particular theory has been investigated in psychological research, for example, a study entitled, ‘The proof is in the punch: Gender differences in perceptions of action and aggression as components of manhood’.


The authors of the study argue that physical action, toughness, and aggression are central features of the masculine stereotype in the US, (perhaps ironically enough, reinforced by Hollywood).

They contend that men often experience anxiety stemming from the need to prove their manhood. Given this anxiety, acts of physical aggression become an opportunity for men to prove their masculine status.

Yet, perhaps there are other ways to convey to others that a man is strong, fearless, and willing to act, despite risks to personal safety.

Will Smith accepts the Actor in a Leading Role award for ‘King Richard’ onstage during the 94th Annual Academy Awards at Dolby Theatre on March 27, 2022, in Hollywood, California. Will Smith accepts the Actor in a Leading Role award for ‘King Richard’ onstage during the 94th Annual Academy Awards at Dolby Theatre on March 27, 2022 in Hollywood, California. (Photo by Neilson Barnard/Getty Images)

Dangerous activities, such as motorcycle riding without a helmet, and mountain climbing without a partner, represent another class of masculinity-confirming events because their performance, like overt acts of aggression, also confirms a man’s toughness and courage.

This idea is investigated in a study entitled ‘Living Dangerously: Culture of Honor, Risk-Taking, and the Nonrandomness of ‘‘Accidental’’ Deaths’. This investigation has shown it is even possible to predict which parts of the US have higher rates of deaths from excessively manliness.

This study focused on white people, not Asians or black people, indicating that the issue of ethnicity and violence may apply to wide variety of ethnic groups. The study investigated how deaths associated with accidental causes (automobile accidents, falls, electrocutions) might be encouraged by an underlying ‘culture of honour’, a characteristic of communities that place special emphasis on the aggressive defence of reputation.

“Accidental” deaths were indeed found to be more frequent in so-called “honour” states in the US, reflecting the influence of a culture in certain regions that places a premium on proving that one is strong and fearless.

Accidents include accidental deaths associated with falls, exposure to inanimate and animate forces, drowning, burning, overexertion and anything similar.

Chris Rock ‘still processing’ slap by Will Smith at Oscars Chris Rock (Photo by Neilson Barnard/Getty Images)

The authors of this research argue that the tougher economic conditions and pervasive lawlessness in the southern and western United States produced an unstable social environment that helped perpetuate the strong belief in “honour” of the Ulster Scots (or “Scotch-Irish”), who immigrated to the US in great numbers during the 18th century.

Dr Raj Persaud Dr Raj Persaud

Jane Campion’s The Power of the Dog, which became the first film directed by a woman to receive more than 10 Academy Award nominations, is said to deal directly with the issue of toxic masculinity. Campion, who won the best director Oscar for the movie, is quoted as explaining the meaning behind the title, ‘…As the title stands, it’s a kind of warning. The power of the dog is all those deep uncontrollable urges that come and destroy us...’

White males, in particular from ‘honour’ states, according to this research, respond to reputation threats with higher levels of hostility and violence, compared to people from “non-honour” states.

A study from the University of Southern California investigating a large sample of different ethnicity males in the US found a fierce sense of ethnic belonging was also linked with a strong attachment to traditional masculinity.

This study argued that African Americans growing up in father-absent homes may gravitate to masculinity derived from peer culture, therefore towards athletics, fighting, and risk-taking actions. The authors also say, of course, that father-absent homes would be likely to increase the influence of peer groups regardless of race.

According to a study published by a group of female analysts at the World Bank6, the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) estimates the annual worldwide number of so-caled ‘honour killings’ is as high as 5,000 women and girls, though some non-governmental organisations (NGOs) estimate as many as 20,000 ‘honour killings’ annually worldwide.

The World Bank authors argue that ‘honour killings’ are located mostly in particular parts of the world because south Asian men also face an idea of masculinity based on honour. They argue that men’s role is to maintain familial and community ‘honour’ by controlling the behaviour of their daughters, wives and mothers.

In other words, a woman’s sexual behaviour and public presence are tied to the honour of the household.

Male honour becomes violated when there is a lack of control over women, producing shame among men so that honour can only be restored through a punitive response towards women.

The need to protect a wife from a barbed yet supposedly humorous attack might have led some men to hit someone who made fun of a woman they might be feeling protective towards. But to show how psychologically complex what happened on Oscar night is, maybe it was the audience who laughed, who might be the people we really wanted to punch, if we had been the victim of a hurtful prank.

What if the Chris Rock joke had fallen flat and, indeed, some people had booed it as inappropriate and offensive?

Would Will Smith have felt the same motivation to respond? How much was the reaction of the audience part of what galvanised subsequent events?

We need to see that laughing, in fact, makes us complicit in hostility, if the joke itself is aggressive.

Everyone is taking sides – some say Rock went too far and others that this kind of physical attack on a comedian is never justifiable.

Yet there is one guilty party which so far has got away without attracting any blame, and which always escapes under the radar in these predicaments.

It’s the audience, who laughed at the joke, who have successfully avoided being seen as guilty in any way. In which case, Rock took one for the team.

Dr Raj Persaud is a consultant psychiatrist and author of The Mental Vaccine for Covid-19, published by Amberley Press. 

References

  • bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-60896604
  • The Proof is in the Punch: Gender Differences in Perceptions of Action and Aggression as Components of Manhood; Jonathan R Weaver & Joseph A Vandello & Jennifer K Bosson & Rochelle M Burnaford; Sex Roles (2010) 62:241–251
  • Living Dangerously: Culture of Honor, Risk-Taking, and the Non-randomness of ‘‘Accidental’’ Deaths; Collin D Barnes, Ryan P Brown, and Michael Tamborski; Social Psychological and Personality Science 3(1) 100-107
  • www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/why-jane-campion-2021-movie-called-the-power-of-the-dog-what-does-it-mean.html/
  • Psychology of Men & Masculinity Vol 1, No 2, 75-86 Ethnic Belonging and Traditional Masculinity Ideology Among African Americans, European Americans, and Latinos; Josh M Abreu, Rodney K Goodyear, Alvaro Campos, and Michael D. Newcomb
  • For the Sake of Family and Tradition: Honour Killings in India and Pakistan; Tanya D’Lima, Jennifer L Solotaroff, Rohini Prabha Pande; Indian Journal of Women and Social Change, 2020 Vol 5, Issue 1, 2020

More For You

Starmer Mandelson

Starmer talks with Mandelson during a welcome reception at the ambassador's residence on February 26, 2025 in Washington, DC.

Getty

Starmer under pressure from party MPs after Mandelson dismissal

PRIME MINISTER Keir Starmer is facing questions within the Labour party after the sacking of US ambassador Peter Mandelson.

Mandelson was removed last week after Bloomberg published emails showing messages of support he sent following Jeffrey Epstein’s conviction for sex offences. The dismissal comes just ahead of US president Donald Trump’s state visit.

Keep ReadingShow less
Nepal’s new leader pledges to act on Gen Z calls to end corruption

Officials greet newly-elected Prime Minister of Nepal's interim government Sushila Karki (R) as she arrives at the prime minister's office in Kathmandu on September 14, 2025. (Photo by PRABIN RANABHAT/AFP via Getty Images)

Nepal’s new leader pledges to act on Gen Z calls to end corruption

NEPAL’s new interim prime minister Sushila Karki on Sunday (14) pledged to act on protesters’ calls to end corruption and restore trust in government, as the country struggles with the aftermath of its worst political unrest in decades.

“We have to work according to the thinking of the Gen Z generation,” Karki said in her first address to the nation since taking office on Friday (12). “What this group is demanding is the end of corruption, good governance and economic equality. We will not stay here more than six months in any situation. We will complete our responsibilities and hand over to the next parliament and ministers.”

Keep ReadingShow less
UK secures £1.25bn US investment ahead of Trump’s visit

US president Donald Trump and UK prime minister Sir Keir Starmer arrive at Trump International Golf Links on July 28, 2025 in Balmedie, Scotland. (Photo by Jane Barlow-WPA Pool/Getty Images)

UK secures £1.25bn US investment ahead of Trump’s visit

THE British government has announced over £1.25 billion ($1.69bn) in fresh investment from major US financial firms, including PayPal, Bank of America, Citigroup and S&P Global, ahead of a state visit by president Donald Trump.

The investment is expected to create 1,800 jobs across London, Edinburgh, Belfast and Manchester, and deepen transatlantic financial ties, the Department for Business and Trade said.

Keep ReadingShow less
Nearly 150,000 join anti-migrant protest in London as clashes erupt

Protesters wave Union Jack and St George's England flags during the "Unite The Kingdom" rally on Westminster Bridge by the Houses of Parliament on September 13, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)

Nearly 150,000 join anti-migrant protest in London as clashes erupt

MORE THAN 100,000 protesters marched through central London on Saturday (13), carrying flags of England and Britain and scuffling with police in one of the UK's biggest right-wing demonstrations of modern times.

London's Metropolitan Police said the "Unite the Kingdom" march, organised by anti-immigrant activist Tommy Robinson, was attended by nearly 150,000 people, who were kept apart from a "Stand Up to Racism" counter-protest attended by around 5,000.

Keep ReadingShow less
Piyush Goyal

Piyush Goyal recalled that in February, Narendra Modi and Donald Trump had instructed their trade ministers to conclude the first phase of the bilateral trade agreement (BTA) by November 2025. (Photo: Getty Images)

Getty Images

Trade talks with US moving forward positively, says Indian minister Goyal

INDIA’s commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal on Thursday said that negotiations on the proposed trade agreement between India and the United States, which began in March, are progressing in a positive atmosphere and both sides are satisfied with the discussions.

He recalled that in February, Indian prime minister Narendra Modi and US president Donald Trump had instructed their trade ministers to conclude the first phase of the bilateral trade agreement (BTA) by November 2025.

Keep ReadingShow less