Skip to content 
Search

Latest Stories

‘Consent and clarity’ vital in NHS data sharing plan

‘Consent and clarity’ vital in NHS data sharing plan

A CONTROVERSIAL NHS data sharing plan has been backed by leading doctors and experts, but they have called for transparency over what is being gathered and for what purpose.

The new system will collect information on a patient’s physical, mental and sexual health held by GP surgeries in England over the past 10 years for a central database.


The scheme, due to start in July, was delayed until September over fears from doctors’ groups that it was being pushed through too quickly.

NHS Digital said during the Covid pandemic, data from GPs helped to identify the most vulnerable people, roll out the vaccine programme and determine hospital treatments which helped prevent further deaths from the disease.

It said the new system will also help plan health services to tackle the long-term impact of coronavirus.

Critics, however, raised concerns that third parties – including researchers at universities, charities or private firms – will be able to access the data.

Kiran Kaur Manku, a neuroscience, ethics and society researcher at the University of Oxford, said the British Indian community understood and valued data sharing for good policy and practice.

He told Eastern Eye: “Despite supporting the concept, due to the lack of information and transparency, much of the community feel mistrust towards the government project. We welcome the delayed deadline for the government NHS data sharing plan.

“However, we call for inclusive actualisation of informed consent and transparency at the data sharing level.

“Much of the British Indian community feel the data sharing plan was not explained to them, and are unaware of the important choice to be made. There are not enough resources to explain the decision to members of the community who are disabled, those not fluent in English, and those excluded in the digital divide.”

Patients can opt out before the data transfer begins next Wednesday (1) by filling in a “Type 1 opt-out” form and sending it to their GP surgery.

They can still opt out of future information being shared after September, but data from the past 10 years may have already been taken from their medical records.

Manku, co-founder of research group The 1928 Institute, added: “In addition to a nuanced informative campaign, we urge the government to be transparent in their decision-making. For example, will an independent ethics committee be making data sharing decisions on a case-by-case basis or will there be blanket rules? Will the independent committee include ethicists, healthcare  stakeholders, and lay community members?”

Kamlesh Khunti photo Professor Kamlesh Khunti

Professor Kamlesh Khunti, professor of primary care diabetes and vascular medicine at the University of Leicester, was among over 200 people from the medical and social research profession who backed NHS Digital’s data sharing plans in June.

He told Eastern Eye: “My view is that it is important for individuals to give access to data as we have seen the power of UK data during the pandemic.

“However, it is important that patients are well informed about what data is being collected, shared and for what purpose.

“Overall, if done properly, data sharing will help management of patients within

health and social care as currently, a number of these organisations cannot access this data to deliver care.”

The move is part of a wider drive to digitise the NHS, including allowing people to access their medical information, procedures and care plans, manage appointments and order repeat prescriptions via mobile phone apps.

Dr Farah Jameel, the British Medical Association’s GP committee executive team lead for IT, believes that when used effectively, ethically and legally, data can play a pivotal role in improving the nation’s health through planning, research or for direct patient care.

She said: “When patients interact with the NHS, they expect that the right staff have access to the necessary information about them, so they get the treatment they need, regardless of whether this is at their GP practice, in a hospital or elsewhere.

“When this doesn’t happen, it’s frustrating for both patients and clinicians. The situation we have at present needs improving, to facilitate better data-sharing between settings.

“Everyone has a right to know what is happening with their healthcare data,  what is being shared for wider purposes than just their own care, and who has access to it – as well as to have the final say on whether to share it or not.

“We have seen in recent weeks with the pausing of the GP Data for Planning and Research programme roll-out, what happens when these issues are not communicated properly, and patients are not given an opportunity to take part in such important discussions.”

The social care sector has also asked NHS chiefs to ensure they are included as equal partners in the collection and analysis of patients’ data.

Nadra Ahmed, chairwoman of the National Care Association, said: “There has been an increased focus on the use of data over the past year, which has put increased pressure on care providers to input and keep up to date.

“While we understand the importance of data collection, it is critical that providers are clear about the context of how the data is to be used to improve and support the people we care for in social care.

“Providers must be given the tools to collate and submit meaningful data as requested, as these tasks will be in addition to our primary responsibility, which is to care for vulnerable people across the nation.

“It is also critical that we must not duplicate data collection as providers are currently expected to collate and submit data for several purposes”.

Gurch Randhawa, professor of diversity and public health at the University of Bedfordshire, said informed consent was important to maintain trust between the NHS and patients.

He added: “As health service researchers, we are always open and transparent as to how any data we collect from patients will be used and reported upon, and we provide this information to patients and seek their consent prior to data collection.

“It is important that these principles are also adhered to when introducing the General Practice Data for Planning and Research programme.”

In June, then health secretary Matt Hancock said the move would revolutionise patient care and insisted “data saves lives”. He added: “We have got to get healthcare and how the NHS communicates into the 21st century.”

More For You

Starmer-Getty

Starmer is facing a Labour backbench revolt over plans to reform special needs support in schools without guaranteeing existing legal rights. (Photo: Getty Images)

Getty Images)

Starmer faces Labour pushback over SEND reform plans

KEIR STARMER is facing a backlash from Labour MPs over plans to reform special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) support, after ministers stopped short of guaranteeing legal rights for parents.

Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson said the government was committed to reforming the current system, which costs £12 billion a year. However, she did not confirm if legally enforceable rights, such as those provided by education, health and care plans (EHCPs), would remain.

Keep ReadingShow less
Heavy rain and thunderstorms hit London

Londoners faced a wet and stormy start to the week

iStock

Heavy rain and thunderstorms hit London before 30°C heatwave

Key points

  • Heavy rain and thunderstorms drench London at the start of the week
  • Temperatures set to rise with highs of 31°C expected by Thursday
  • Heatwave could be declared by Friday if warm conditions persist
  • Night-time temperatures to remain high, increasing discomfort
  • UV and pollen levels forecast to be very high across the south

Thunderstorms soak London before summer heat returns

Londoners faced a wet and stormy start to the week as heavy rain and overnight thunderstorms swept through the capital. Monday morning saw widespread downpours, leaving commuters reaching for umbrellas and Wimbledon ticket hopefuls queuing in ponchos.

The unsettled conditions followed a burst of thunderstorms on Sunday afternoon and continued into the early hours of Monday, prompting caution across the city. The Met Office has not issued a formal weather warning for thunderstorms, but conditions remain unstable.

Keep ReadingShow less
National Trust sets vision to heal
nature and engage more Asians

Lisa Nandy, Steve Reed, René Olivieri and Hilary McGrady at a National Trust event marking its 130th anniversary

National Trust sets vision to heal nature and engage more Asians

THE National Trust, which is seeking to broaden its appeal to British Asians, is marking its 130th anniversary with a renewed commitment to restoring nature and widening access under a 10-year strategy.

Its director-general, Hilary McGrady, also aims to inspire more people to get involved in caring for the country’s natural resources.

Keep ReadingShow less
 7/7 bombings

The King said the public should draw on the 'extraordinary courage and compassion' shown in response to the attacks. (Photo credit: X/@RoyalFamily)

Starmer and King Charles pay tribute on 20th anniversary of 7/7 bombings

PRIME MINISTER Keir Starmer and King Charles on Monday paid tribute to the unity shown in the aftermath of the 7 July bombings in London, as the country marked 20 years since the attacks.

On 7 July 2005, four Islamist extremists carried out suicide bombings at Aldgate Station, Edgware Road, King's Cross and Tavistock Square. The attacks killed 52 people and injured hundreds more.

Keep ReadingShow less
Navroop Singh

Navroop Singh was convicted of five charges including rape and was sentenced on July 4 at Isleworth Crown Court. (Photo credit: Metropolitan Police)

Man jailed for life over rape and attempted rape in west London

A 24-year-old man has been sentenced to life in prison for rape, attempted rape and firearm offences following a Metropolitan Police investigation in west London.

Navroop Singh, of Mellow Lane East, Hayes, was convicted of five charges including rape and was sentenced on Friday, July 4 at Isleworth Crown Court. He must serve a minimum of 14 years.

Keep ReadingShow less