Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Why Remember Together?

by SUNDER KATWALA

Director, British Future


REMEMBRANCE Sunday this year marks the centenary of the armistice of the First World War, that moment at 11 o’clock on the 11th day of the 11th month when the guns finally fell silent.

A tumultuous global conflict, which had claimed 16 million lives, finally came to an end.

The anniversary also closes the four-year commemoration of the First World War centenary.

The scale of public engagement, starting with the emotional response to the sea of poppies at the Tower of London in the summer of 2014, reflected a curious paradox. We feel that the world wars played a formative role in our national identity, yet most people began this centenary with a fairly sketchy sense of that history.

People sometimes wonder whether Britain’s traditions and rituals of Remembrance will retain their relevance to new generations in our fast-changing and increasingly diverse society.

Yet the centenary has made many more people aware of the surprising fact that the armies that fought a century ago looked much more like the Britain of 2018 than that of 1918, certainly when it comes to their multi-ethnic and multi-faith mix. Ten million soldiers came from across Britain, the Empire and Commonwealth. The 1.5 million servicemen from what was then undivided India – present-day India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka – would still be the largest-ever volunteer army in global history, had it not been for the even-larger Indian Army contribution to the Second World War a generation later.

Just four out of 10 people were aware that Indian soldiers took part in the First World War before the centenary began; that had risen to seven out of 10 people in the first two years of the event. What was minority knowledge has become something that most people have heard of.

British Future’s research into public views of the centenary finds the Commonwealth contribution is the issue on which public awareness has grown most. It has not been a minor tributary, but a major theme of the commemorations.

There has been an enormous level of activity in the Sikh community, with the UK Punjab Heritage Association helping many people discover their family connections. Few people realise that 400,000 Muslim soldiers fought in the First World War as part of the Indian Army, but New Horizons in British Islam and British Future have worked together to take that untold story around the country.

Muslim soldiers who lost their lives in the First World War were buried in Woking, Surrey, near the 19th century Shah Jahan Mosque. That burial ground has become a strikingly beautiful new memorial garden – its restoration covered in a BBC documentary – and a site for commemoration and education.

The role of Brighton’s Royal Pavilion as a makeshift hospital for Indian troops was commemorated in the post-war Chattri memorial, where events have swollen in numbers.

At the Oval Test during the summer, India’s Virat Kohli and England’s Joe Root wore special khadi poppies made of handwoven cotton, to support the Royal British Legion’s efforts to raise further awareness of the Commonwealth contribution.

The centenary has made our shared history better known than ever before. There is more work to do to ensure that this effort does not stop when the centenary ends, and it matters when extremists of different stripes do still try to co-opt national symbols of Remembrance to promote hate.

The far-right racists of Britain First and Anjem Choudary’s Islamist extremists both depend on an ignorance of the history of the world wars to claim that minorities can never be accepted as British. The real history of the Commonwealth contribution can provide a powerful antidote to these simplistic narratives.

Britain’s schools have found that our shared history of contribution resonates powerfully in classrooms that are more diverse than ever before. Yet, one wonders how many of those children’s parents, looking at local Remembrance services that mostly still look much “whiter” than the local communities in which they are located, conclude that Remembrance isn’t for them – or is something to which they don’t yet feel fully invited. More work is needed before the participation in local civic Remembrance activities fully reflects the diversity of the local population today.

Remembrance is powerful because it is voluntary. Everybody makes their own decisions about whether or how to participate. This Remembrance season will be more prominent than ever before in temples and mosques, as well as synagogues and churches, as different faiths support a new “Remember Together” campaign, which shows how our traditions of Remembrance can and do belong to us all.

The message at the end of this centenary should be clear – because they fought together, we remember together. Everybody is invited to participate in these moments that bring us together today.

Sunder Katwala is the director of British Future, which is coordinating Remember Together with the Royal British Legion. Visit www.remembertogether.uk for more information.

More For You

Comment: Can Starmer government find the antidote to populist politics?

Keir Starmer

Getty Images

Comment: Can Starmer government find the antidote to populist politics?

Donald Trump’s second inauguration as America's President next week is the sequel that few of us here wanted to see. Trump was the democratic choice of 50% of America's voters again this time, baffling most people on this side of the Atlantic. We share a common language and many cultural influences, but Britain is not America when it comes to politics.

But how confident can we be that Britain will not become as deeply divided as Donald Trump's America? The frenzy with which Elon Musk made himself the main character, opening this year in British politics, showed how technology shrinks the ocean between us. Britain is far from immune from the populist, polarised politics that took Trump to victory. This is a less deeply divided society than America, but the next four years are likely to see that tested as never before.

Keep ReadingShow less
Cambridge shaped Manmohan Singh’s economic vision

Manmohan Singh

Cambridge shaped Manmohan Singh’s economic vision

DR MANMOHAN SINGH’S passing at the age of 92 on December 26 reminds me of my interview with the then prime minister of India in 2006 in Delhi. He told me his economic thinking had been shaped to a great extent by his time in Cambridge.

The man credited with opening up India to globalisation, serving as minister of finance from 1991 to 1996 under prime minister PV Narasimha Rao, said he viewed economics as a tool to help the poorest in society.

Keep ReadingShow less
Comment: Dealing with Trump and Musk may dominate the politics of 2025

Elon Musk (L) and Donald Trump

Getty Images

Comment: Dealing with Trump and Musk may dominate the politics of 2025

How to deal with US president-elect Donald Trump may dominate global politics in 2025. The question generates existential concern in Ukraine, but a sense of opportunity in Moscow and Tel Aviv. India's growing status makes prime minister Narendra Modi’s government less nervous about another Trump era than most. Anxiety about security, trade and diplomacy dominates European capitals.

Keir Starmer’s British government will seek as much ‘business as usual’ as possible in such volatile times. It may sound like wishful thinking, but no obvious alternative strategy is available. Peter Mandelson’s mission in Washington as UK ambassador will be to limit the damage that tariffs could do to economic growth, or that erratic diplomacy might do to NATO.The new year proved there will be no mutual non-aggression pact from Trump’s allies in America, as Elon Musk embarked on a freelance mission to destroy Starmer’s government.

Keep ReadingShow less
Football with Faris: The week’s hottest stories from the beautiful game

Despite a new manager in Arne Slot, Liverpool have taken this season by storm, only dropping points in three out of the 14 games they’ve played. (Photo: Getty Images)

Football with Faris: The week’s hottest stories from the beautiful game

By: Faris Gohir

The Premier League title race has heated up. Which teams are favourites for Champions League places? Which teams are as good as relegated, and who is the surprise package? Time for a mid-season wrap-up.

Keep ReadingShow less
Dangers of culture wars and how to defuse them

Kemi Badenoch

Getty Images

Dangers of culture wars and how to defuse them

Kemi Badenoch has decided to be out and proud as a culture warrior. “It is meant to be pejorative, but I love the title the left-wing media give me”, she told her Washington DC audience last week. “I believe in tradition. And if we don’t defend our culture, who will?”, the Conservative leader said, even declaring herself to be “descended from warriors”.

Since most people don't want a culture war, British politicians usually blame the other side for starting them. Even now, while embracing the label, Badenoch will return to her earlier complaint that the term is a ‘dog whistle’ to delegitimise conservative voices. Labour Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy had used her very first speech in the role to declare that “the era of culture wars is over”. Badenoch’s appetite for the cultural argument illustrates why unilateral disarmament of cultural conflict is challenging. So how could we ‘call off’ the culture wars - or at least defuse unconstructive arguments about identity?

Keep ReadingShow less