Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Expert not given vital info before recommending surgery that killed doctor

Amit Patel, a leading doctor at the Christie cancer hospital died in 2021 after a procedure recommended to diagnose his illness went wrong.

Expert not given vital info before recommending surgery that killed doctor

A national medical expert has said she wouldn't have suggested a procedure that tragically led to the death of a leading doctor, had she known crucial details about his health.

Professor Amit Patel, a leading doctor at the Christie cancer hospital, became seriously ill and was admitted to Wythenshawe Hospital in August 2021. Despite efforts to understand and treat his condition, a surgical test recommended to diagnose his illness went wrong, leaving him with a slim chance of survival. He later passed away.


During an inquest into his death at Manchester Coroner’s Court, Dr Jessica Manson, a consultant rheumatologist, revealed that she hadn't been informed about Patel's serious blood clotting disorder, disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC), before recommending the procedure, reported Manchester Evening News.

She also noted that if she had known about the DIC, she wouldn't have suggested the procedure.

Dr Manson also said she wasn't told that the recommended procedure had a low chance of providing useful diagnostic information, reported the newspaper. The court agreed that the recommendation was made without complete information.

Patel's wife testified that he was not aware of his DIC status before the procedure.

Despite being a leading expert in his field, Patel's condition deteriorated rapidly, and a diagnosis of Still's disease, an inflammatory illness, was considered.

Treatment for Still's disease was ineffective, and Patel's condition worsened, leading to his transfer to intensive care.

A national panel, along with doctors from Wythenshawe Hospital, recommended an endobronchial ultrasound-guided biopsy (EBUS) to diagnose lung disorders. However, the procedure led to complications, and Patel's chances of survival drastically decreased.

There was a dispute over whether Patel was fully able to consent to the procedure, with conflicting accounts from medical staff and his wife, as reported by Manchester Evening News. Despite emergency treatment, Patel's condition continued to worsen until his passing in October 2021.

Professor Amit Patel was the first person to be qualified in stem cell transplantation and cellular therapy in the UK.

More For You

Lancashire Health Warning

Dr. Sakthi Karunanithi, director of public health, Lancashire County Council

Via LDRS

Lancashire warned health pressures ‘not sustainable’ without stronger prevention plan

Paul Faulkner

Highlights

  • Lancashire’s public health chief says rising demand on services cannot continue.
  • New prevention strategy aims to involve entire public sector and local communities.
  • Funding concerns raised as council explores co-investment and partnerships.
Lancashire’s public sector will struggle to cope with rising demand unless more is done to prevent people from falling ill in the first place, the county’s public health director has warned.
Dr. Sakthi Karunanithi told Lancashire County Council’s health and adult services scrutiny committee that poor health levels were placing “not sustainable” pressure on local services, prompting the authority to begin work on a new illness prevention strategy.

The plan, still in its early stages, aims to widen responsibility for preventing ill health beyond the public health department and make it a shared priority across the county council and the wider public sector.

Dr. Karunanithi said the approach must also be a “partnership” with society, supporting people to make healthier choices around smoking, alcohol use, weight and physical activity. He pointed that improving our health is greater than improving the NHS.

Keep ReadingShow less