Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Submit Guest Post

Shamima Begum’s ‘British’ baby tragedy

by Amit Roy

THE news that Shamima Begum had lost her baby son, when he might possibly have responded to medical care in the UK, was heartrending.


Perhaps the home secretary, Sajid Javid, who stripped her of her British nationality, thereby

making her stateless because she doesn’t have Bangladeshi nationality, should – exceptionally – review her case and let her back into Britain.

Most people don’t have sympathy for Shamima’s pro-Daesh political views and feel she is responsible for her own misfortune, but they are not heartless either. She is only 19 and lost three babies in succession. Surely, she has suffered enough.

Shamima is not the only problem for the home secretary, who has to consider the possible

long-term consequences of allowing in dozens of other Britons, many brainwashed by extremist ideology, and their children born in Syria.

Javid might have wanted to appear tough, but the decision has now backfired on him. For once, the shadow home secretary, Diane Abbott, reflected the views of many people when she tweeted: “It is against international law to make someone stateless, and now an innocent child has died as a result of a British woman being stripped of her citizenship. This is callous and inhumane.”

She later added: “This week a British baby died from pneumonia in a Syrian refugee camp. A tragedy that might have been avoided. If the mother and baby had been brought home, the mother Shamima Begum would have faced British justice, but the baby might have lived. Sajid Javid has behaved shamefully.”

Javid is also being targeted by his enemies in the Conservative Party who are putting the knife in so as to undermine his chances of succeeding Theresa May as prime minister.

Conservative MP Phillip Lee declared he was “deeply concerned” by Javid’s decision, which

was “driven by a sort of populism”, he claimed.

“Clearly Shamima Begum holds abhorrent views and to want to join Islamic State is beyond

all comprehension, but she was a child, a product of our society,” he argued.

Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesman Ed Davey said the boy will be remembered if courts rule that Javid acted “illegally in making a British citizen stateless”. “Many of us feared this tragic outcome when the home secretary washed his hands of Britain’s responsibility for a British citizen and a British baby,” he added.

Add EasternEye As Your Trusted Source
preferred source on google news

More For You

English identity

MADRID, SPAIN - NOVEMBER 15: Jude Bellingham of England celebrates after the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match between Spain and England at Riyadh Air Metropolitano on November 15, 2026 in Madrid, Spain.

(Photo by Carl Recine/Getty Images)

English identity must be defined by belonging, not race

DO YOU have to be white to be English? Few people watching England’s footballers last Sunday (15) night would doubt that the obvious answer is no. Jude Bellingham was man of the match in this famous English victory over world champions Spain. The iconic back-page sporting image was of goalscorer Ezri Konsa congratulating goalkeeper James Trafford for his match-winning saves in a nail-biting finale. Trafford, of Leeds United, was raised on his family's farm in Cumbria while Konsa, of Arsenal, was born in London to parents from Angola and the Congo. That they represent England together has little novelty value today since the reality of our multi-ethnic England has been a settled fact on the pitch for several decades.

Sporting symbolism helped to entrench a common-sense consensus: research shows the white English reject defining English as just for white people by a thumping eight-to-one margin. Ethnic minorities agree, but a bit less emphatically – by closer to three-to-one. That difference is partly because migrants coming to England have mostly identified as British, not English too, before English-born children and grandchildren more often adopt both. It reflects the damage a vocal toxic minority can do to this work-in-progress of an inclusive England.

Keep ReadingShow less