Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Former Post Office chair denies hiding crucial Horizon report

Tim Parker has denied intentionally hiding a critical report he commissioned on the Horizon IT system from the board

Former Post Office chair denies hiding crucial Horizon report

FORMER Post Office chair Tim Parker has denied intentionally hiding a critical report he commissioned on the Horizon IT system from the board.

In 2016, Jonathan Swift, a former senior Treasury lawyer, authored a report highlighting concerns about the Horizon accounting software, which was later discovered to be defective.


Faulty data from Horizon led to the wrongful convictions of 700 sub-postmasters for theft and fraud between 1999 and 2015.

During an inquiry last week, it was revealed that only four copies of the Swift report were produced, none of which were shared with the Post Office board or the government, the BBC reported.

Parker revealed he followed advice from Post Office lawyers to keep the document confidential.

"It's one of my regrets that I got this advice and I took it," Parker said. "Could we have shared it? I wish we had, in a way. I had this report commissioned to get some result from it, but then I received this advice."

The convictions of all sub-postmasters have since been overturned, but many individuals suffered imprisonment or lost their businesses.

The Swift report was commissioned by the government following a BBC Panorama programme in 2015 that questioned the validity of the evidence against those convicted.

The report, while supportive of the Post Office in some aspects, raised significant concerns about the sufficiency of evidence for theft charges and the integrity of Horizon data, which was later found to be alterable remotely by Fujitsu, the software developer.

Parker, who served as chair from October 2015 to September 2022, explained that top Post Office lawyer Jane MacLeod advised him against sharing the report due to its legal privilege, equating it to confidential communications between a lawyer and client.

He was informed that breaching this confidentiality could result in the report becoming public and thus it had to be confined within the Post Office legal team.

When questioned by inquiry lead counsel Jason Beer, Parker admitted that his actions prevented the board from discussing the report's findings but denied any improper motives.

"What possible motive would I have had at the time from hiding this report from my fellow board members, other than receiving advice that I shouldn't share it? I had no vested interest in trying to protect the Post Office," he was quoted as saying.

Parker conceded that, in hindsight, the advice he received might not have been entirely fair or right. However, he believed at the time that the advice was given in good faith and that it was the right thing to do.

During further questioning, lawyer Sam Stein criticised Parker for being a "part-time" chair with "part-baked" decisions. Initially, Parker dedicated one-and-a-half days per week to his Post Office duties, later reducing this to half-a-day per week.

Parker, however, denied it, saying that he provided sufficient time and attention to his responsibilities.

Following the Swift review, auditors Deloitte were hired in February 2016 to investigate Horizon transactions dating back to 1999. This investigation was abandoned in June 2016 when sub-postmasters, led by campaigner Sir Alan Bates, initiated legal action against the Post Office.

Parker agreed that, had the report not been kept secret, the Post Office might have approached the High Court action differently, which ultimately cost more than £100 million.

However, he also noted that resolving all the issues might have required judicial intervention by that stage.

More For You

modi-meeting

In the wake of the terrorist attack in Pahalgam, PM Modi chaired a meeting of the Cabinet Committee of Security in Delhi on Wednesday. (Photo: X/@narendramodi)

X/@narendramodi

India suspends Indus Water Treaty with Pakistan after Kashmir attack

INDIA has suspended the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) with Pakistan and taken other diplomatic measures after gunmen killed 26 people, mostly tourists, in Pahalgam in Jammu and Kashmir on Tuesday.

The attack, which left 25 Indian nationals and one Nepali dead, is the deadliest targeting civilians in Kashmir in 25 years. Gunmen emerged from forests and fired on the crowd using automatic weapons.

Keep ReadingShow less
Terror attack in Pahalgam triggers tourist exodus

Security personnel inspect the site in the aftermath of an attack as food stall chairs lie empty in Pahalgam, about 90km (55 miles) from Srinagar on April 23, 2025. (Photo by TAUSEEF MUSTAFA/AFP via Getty Images)

Terror attack in Pahalgam triggers tourist exodus

INDIAN tourist brochures dub the Himalayan region of Kashmir "Little Switzerland", and its mountain meadows are usually packed with visitors escaping the sweltering summer heat in the lowland plains of India.

On Wednesday (23), a day after gunmen killed 26 men in an attack on the popular tourist site of Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir chief minister Omar Abdullah reported an "exodus of our guests".

Keep ReadingShow less
 Yvette Cooper

Home secretary Yvette Cooper has instructed officials to release the data, which includes the types of crimes committed.

Getty Images

Foreign criminals’ data to be released by year-end

THE UK government will publish the nationalities and offences of foreign criminals for the first time by the end of the year.

Home secretary Yvette Cooper has reportedly instructed officials to release the data, which includes the types of crimes committed.

Keep ReadingShow less
Modi arrives in Saudi Arabia to strengthen strategic ties

Prime minister Narendra Modi during his visit to Saudi Arabia on Tuesday (22)

Modi arrives in Saudi Arabia to strengthen strategic ties

INDIA’S prime minister Narendra Modi arrived in Saudi Arabia’s Jeddah on Tuesday (22) for his third visit as prime minister to the oil-rich Gulf kingdom.

The trip came a day after Modi held talks with US vice-president JD Vance in India, with New Delhi looking to seal a trade deal with Washington and stave off punishing tariffs.

Keep ReadingShow less
Veterans urge nation to 'unite and remember' in VE Day letter

Samina Mahroof, a cutter at the JW Plant Flag Company works on flag orders ahead of the VE Day 80th anniversary on March 18, 2025 in Leeds, England. (Photo by Ian Forsyth/Getty Images)

Veterans urge nation to 'unite and remember' in VE Day letter

TEN surviving Second World War veterans, including three from the British Indian Army, have written an open letter urging people across the UK to come together and remember the sacrifices made during the war.

Launched on Wednesday (23) by the /Together Coalition, the letter is part of a wider campaign marking the 80th anniversary of Victory in Europe (VE) Day, which falls on May 5.

Keep ReadingShow less