NHS apologises following suicide of Dr Vaish Kumar
The court heard that doctor Vaish Kumar's difficulties began in December 2021 upon discovering that her training period at Queen Elizabeth Hospital was to be prolonged
NHS England's top medical training official has issued a heartfelt apology to the relatives of Dr Vaish Kumar, 35, who took her own life. Dr Kumar faced undue stress after being incorrectly informed that she had to undergo an additional six months of training before she could commence a new position.
This misinformation necessitated her continued presence at Queen Elizabeth Hospital (QE) in Birmingham, a setting where, according to an inquest, she experienced demeaning treatment from fellow staff members, the BBC reported.
In communications with Dr Kumar's grieving family, NHS leadership conceded the error regarding the training requirement.
Dr Navina Evans, chief workforce and training education officer for England, expressed deep regret over the oversight, stating in a letter to the Kumar family, "I wish to unreservedly apologise for these mistakes and for the impact they would have had."
She emphasised the organisation's commitment to learning from this incident to prevent similar failures in the future, promising action not just in the Midlands but nationwide.
The loss of Dr Kumar, who had assumed the role of chief registrar at Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals amidst the challenges of the Covid-19 crisis, has deeply affected her family and colleagues.
They revealed this year, that she left behind a note attributing her despair and subsequent death entirely on the hospital where she worked.
In November 2022, it was revealed at the Birmingham and Solihull Coroner's Court that her difficulties began in December 2021 upon discovering that her training period at QE was to be prolonged, a revelation that came as a shock and exacerbated her sense of being trapped in a "toxic" work environment.
Her father, Dr Ravi Kumar, contends that his daughter's life could have been spared if she had been allowed to leave the hostile atmosphere of QE as initially planned.
Dr Kumar was celebrated for her exemplary mentorship and leadership among junior doctors, qualities that her family who live in Leicester feels were overshadowed by the negative environment at QE.
The inquest into her death brought to light allegations of a pervasive toxic culture within University Hospitals Birmingham (UHB), the trust overseeing QE, which has since faced intense scrutiny.
Following these revelations, and in response to Dr Kumar's tragic death, UHB has extended its condolences, recognising Dr Kumar as a compassionate and esteemed physician whose dedication to patient care left an indelible mark.
The trust has acknowledged the necessity of addressing and learning from the "unacceptable behaviours" uncovered.
THE north east economy is at risk of losing tens of millions of pounds if a new tax on international student fees is imposed, university and business leaders have warned.
Labour ministers have proposed charging a six per cent levy on tuition fees paid by overseas students in England, which education secretary Bridget Phillipson announced will be used to pay for the return of means-tested maintenance grants for some learners from lower-income households.
But the organisation representing some of England’s top universities, including Newcastle and Durham, claims the move is the “wrong way” to reintroduce the grants abolished under the Conservatives in 2016 and risks doing “more harm than good”.
There are concerns that universities would pass the impact of the levy onto international students through tuition fee hikes, rather than absorbing the costs at a time when the higher education sector has been experiencing major budget cuts, resulting in a fall in the number of people coming from overseas to study in the UK.
international students make up almost a third of the student population in the north east
The Russell Group said international students currently make up almost a third of the student population at its universities in the north east – and account for over a quarter of their collective income.
A study from the Higher Education Policy Institute found the levy would cost Durham University £10 million and Newcastle University £9m, putting them in the top twenty worst affected institutions in the country.
Research by Public First has also warned the north east stands to lose £87m in the first year of a levy due to projected falls in international student numbers, which it estimates at 77,000 nationally over five years.
It names Newcastle Central and West as the constituency potentially suffering the eighth biggest hit in the country, just under £30m in Gross Value Added (GVA), with the City of Durham predicted to lose £14.5m and Sunderland Central £12.5m.
Henri Murison, chief executive of the Northern Powerhouse Partnership, said bringing back maintenance grants would help more young people in the north access higher education – but that funding them through this levy “risks undermining the financial sustainability of universities”.
Murison added: “This will mean losing a significant amount of the subsidy for domestic students that their international counterparts currently provide. If there are over 135,000 fewer places across our leading world-class institutions, that means fewer opportunities – especially for the most disadvantaged.
“We know that in cities like Manchester, Leeds, Sheffield and Newcastle there are constituencies with over £30 million in GVA to lose along with similar places in London, West Midlands and Scotland.”
Newcastle University said last year it was facing a £35m financial black hole due to a decline in international students and has since slashed £20m from its wage bill, with cuts having sparked prolonged strike action from academics.
Durham University also announced in January it had to cut costs by £20m over two years.
Dr Tim Bradshaw, chief executive of the Russell Group, said: “Universities like Newcastle and Durham, and many others across the north east contribute a huge amount to their local areas – from providing skills and training to the local workforce, to ground-breaking research and infrastructure projects.
“If the proposed levy goes ahead, it will add greater pressure on an already financially precarious sector to the detriment of the very students and communities that government is looking to support.
“Reinstating maintenance grants has been a long-standing campaign for us, because we know financial pressures are a huge challenge for students – especially those from under-privileged backgrounds. In fact, universities already spend millions of pounds each year on widening access, including bursaries and hardship funds. This spending would also be at risk if the levy goes ahead.”
The Department for Education was contacted for a response.
It said last month the levy would “maintain a competitive offer for international students while ensuring the benefits are shared more visibly at home, directly benefiting disadvantaged domestic students”.
By clicking the 'Subscribe’, you agree to receive our newsletter, marketing communications and industry
partners/sponsors sharing promotional product information via email and print communication from Garavi Gujarat
Publications Ltd and subsidiaries. You have the right to withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the
unsubscribe link in our emails. We will use your email address to personalize our communications and send you
relevant offers. Your data will be stored up to 30 days after unsubscribing.
Contact us at data@amg.biz to see how we manage and store your data.