Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

New generation of Asian trying to fit in Britain

by SUNDER KATWALA.

NEW GENERATION CAN BENEFIT FROM EFFORTS OF ‘PIONEERING MIGRANTS’.


THE days when spotting an Asian face on television was an event to announce to the whole household are long gone.This summer, the BBC has gone to town with its Big British Asian Summer, spanning themes from Bollywood to family history, and comedy to a Gardener’s World special with an Asian theme.

Previewing the season, the BBC published a survey of contemporary British Asian attitudes today.The most distinctive feature that the 2,000-strong opinion poll identified is the much greater importance of religious faith, with almost half of respondents (46 per cent) describing religion as very important, four times the 12 per cent who do so among the British population overall.

Most headlines tended to focus on the increased social conservatism which goes with this, with greater opposition to sex before marriage and same sex relationships. Among those polled, 36 per cent of Asian respondents said that same-sex relationships were not acceptable, compared to 15 per cent of the British public generally.

Perhaps less obvious was that this one-in-three number represents a considerable recent liberalisation of Asian attitudes on gay rights. British Social Attitudes data shows that most of the British public saw homosexual relationships as wrong when Tony Blair become prime minister, and that a third did when he left office in 2007. So the socially conservative British Asian attitudes of 2018 are as liberal as those of the general public just a decade ago, as people gradually adapt to this new social norm.

Most British Asians have a sense of confidence about opportunity in Britain, with 72 per cent seeing the country as somewhere they can fulfil their aspirations, a higher proportion than the UK public overall, among whom 65 per cent agree.

Yet that sense of confidence is perhaps checked by the striking finding was that half of Asian respondents to the poll said they had sometimes “toned down” their Asian identity in order to be able to fit in better.

Some caution is advisable in how to interpret these findings. The poll does not reveal what people tend to do, when or where, if they feel they want to “tone down” their Asian identity. The responses also do not indicate whether people were thinking primarily of workplace and professional encounters, or social occasions. Twelve per cent of respondents said they did this “frequently”, 23 per cent “occasionally” and 18 per cent “rarely”. This suggests that most people who said this were thinking of specific circumstances and contexts, rather than it being an everyday occurrence.

It surely remains troubling that so many people would worry about being “too Asian” in modern Britain, if we aspire to be a society of equal citizenship, where fair chances should depend on talent and effort, not on ethnicity or faith background.

Perhaps this finding is best interpreted as illuminating some of the dynamics of how integration works and how it has been something of a work-in-progress for British Asians over three generations.

The respondents reflected the national demographics of the Asian population, with half having come as migrants, mostly from India and Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, and half having been born in Britain.

The life experience of second-generation British Asians has often been one of upward mobility – many have had educational success and wider professional opportunities that their migrant parents had hoped their children would enjoy. That created new encounters, not just for British Asians themselves. This first British-born generation found themselves having to pioneer and navigate cultural change in the companies and professions they joined. People want to fit in and do well, but companies that are serious about fairness also need to consider, for example, the cultural implications if chances of promotion seem to depend heavily on team drinks in the pub.

In the Britain of 2018, there should be less of a novelty factor about British Asians. One in 10 of the population is Asian – and a significantly higher proportion in the classrooms of Britain, not just in urban centres, but increasingly across suburban England too. With a high proportion of British Asians going to university, it should be increasingly rare for people to find themselves as the only Asian on a graduate trainee scheme. Yet, because integration is a work in progress, that might still remain the case towards the snowy peaks of the boardroom.

In politics too, there were no female Asian MPs in this country until 2010 – and home secretary Sajid Javid is the only British Asian in the cabinet. He will not, however, feel the need to play down his Asianness as he bids to make a historic breakthrough when his party next chooses a prime minister.

Previous successful minority groups, such as British Jews, could take a more assimilationist view in the 1950s, but there is an obvious limit to how far more visible minorities can tone down the very fact of being British Asian. That is perhaps helpful for integration – everybody has to deal with the fact of diversity in order to put our values of equal opportunity into practice. The next generation of British Asians should benefit from that.

  • Sunder Katwala is director of British Future, an independent thintank on integration and identity. See www.britishfuture.org for more.

More For You

Viras’ book 'Art Under the Indian Sun' dives into artistic legacies of Raj

Jennifer Howes, Ratna Vira and Sona Datta

Viras’ book 'Art Under the Indian Sun' dives into artistic legacies of Raj

Dr Sona Datta

ON A crisp evening before Christmas, I found myself at the Traveller’s Club in London’s posh Pall Mall.

Like other anachronisms of old England, this particular place doesn’t permit unaccompanied women. So, Jennifer Howes (an expat Canadian) and me (a British-born Bengali) arrived as two arch Indophiles, sporting silk scarves and lipstick, for an author-talk at the invitation of the Indian High Commissioner, Vikram Doraiswami.

Keep ReadingShow less
Aga Khan IV tribute: ‘His vision and impact transcended borders, faiths and generations’

His Highness the Aga Khan IV with the then Duke and Duchess of Cornwall, at the Aga Khan Centre, London, in 2019.

Aga Khan IV tribute: ‘His vision and impact transcended borders, faiths and generations’

Naushad Jivraj

WITH profound sorrow and deep gratitude, we reflect on the life and legacy of Prince Karim al-Hussaini Aga Khan IV, our beloved 49th hereditary Imam.

For nearly seven decades, His Highness Aga Khan IV dedicated his life to the spiritual and material wellbeing of the Ismaili community. He was not only our spiritual leader but also a visionary, whose work improved the lives of millions worldwide, leaving an impact that transcended borders, faiths and generations.

Keep ReadingShow less
Aga Khan IV tribute: ‘Life defined by service to humanity

His Highness Prince Karim Aga Khan IV and Lord Tariq Ahmad

Aga Khan IV tribute: ‘Life defined by service to humanity

Lord Tariq Ahmad

LAST Tuesday (4), I learned of the sad news of the passing of an incredible humanitarian, scholar and religious leader, who inspired and brought hope to millions – His Highness Prince Karim Aga Khan IV, the Imam of the Ismaili Muslims. (To god we belong, to god we shall return).

He was a global leader renowned for his contribution to humanitarian work, development and the promotion of pluralism, religious coexistence and was a guardian of cultural heritage. Prince Karim Aga Khan studied in Switzerland and later at Harvard University, where he earned a degree in Islamic history in 1959. His studies provided him with a deep understanding of his faith and global affairs, shaping his leadership and vision for his community and his service to humanitarian causes.

Keep ReadingShow less
Will government inaction on science, trade & innovation cost the UK its economic future?

The life sciences and science tech sectors more widely continue to see out migration of companies

iStock

Will government inaction on science, trade & innovation cost the UK its economic future?

Dr Nik Kotecha OBE

As the government wrestles with market backlash and deep business concern from early economic decisions, the layers of economic complexity are building.

The Independent reported earlier in January on the government watchdog’s own assessment of the cost of Brexit - something which is still being fully weighed up, but their estimates show that “the economy will take a 15 per cent hit to trade in the long term”. Bloomberg Economics valued the impact to date (in 2023) at £100bn in lost output each year - values and impact which must be read alongside the now over-reported and repetitively stated “black hole” in government finances, being used to rationalise decisions which are already proving damaging.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Peace in Middle East hinges on Trump’s volatile decisions’

Israeli military vehicles stationed in Nabatieh, Lebanon, last Sunday (26)

‘Peace in Middle East hinges on Trump’s volatile decisions’

CAN the ceasefire endure for any significant length of time? This would go some way to ameliorating the incredible suffering in the region, but does it all hinge on one man, more than the future of the region has ever depended in its entire history?

Ceasefires can’t hold if no progress is made in addressing the underlying issues that led to the conflict in the first place.

Keep ReadingShow less