Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

'Former Post Office chair was told of IT issues in 2011'

Alice Perkins said at the time she did not make a link between the two

'Former Post Office chair was told of IT issues in 2011'

THE former chair of the Post Office, Alice Perkins, was alerted to possible issues in the Horizon IT system as early as 2011, an inquiry has heard.

Despite this warning, the Post Office continued to prosecute hundreds of sub-postmasters for fraud, relying on inaccurate data from the Horizon accounting software. These prosecutions persisted until 2015, the BBC reported.


During the public inquiry, Perkins said that she didn't see a direct link between the system's issues and the ongoing legal actions.

She was also informed that the Post Office had pushed for a lower price on Horizon, leading its developer, Fujitsu, to compromise on software quality. In a meeting noted by Perkins, an auditor expressed concerns about Horizon's accuracy, highlighting it as a risk for auditing Post Office accounts.

Perkins acknowledged receiving this information but didn't immediately connect it to Horizon's operations at branch level.

The inquiry was shown a handwritten note from Alice Perkins detailing a meeting on September 27, 2011, with Ernst & Young auditor Angus Grant.

In the note, Grant raised concerns about the Horizon system, labelling it "a real risk for us." He cautioned that if Horizon's data was inaccurate, EY would be unable to approve the Post Office's company accounts.

Grant's concern about the system's data accuracy was evident in Perkins' note. Lead counsel Jason Beer stressed the significance of Grant's information, noting that in 2011, around 11,900 Post Office branches relied on Horizon to handle millions of transactions worth billions of pounds annually.

Beer suggested that if the system posed a risk to independent auditors, it would also be a significant risk for the Post Office.

Perkins said that her meeting with Grant was one of her first as chair and she had understood his point to be from the auditors' perspective regarding their ability to audit the accounts.

She, however, admitted that she had not connected this concern to the operation of Horizon at the branch level.

In response, Beer questioned whether one issue logically followed from the other, to which Perkins replied that she did not remember making that connection at the time.

According to Perkins' note, Grant had discussed cases of alleged fraud by sub-postmasters, indicating that "suspects suggest it's a systems problem."

When Beer asked if the note was "deeply problematic" for her because she took no action with the provided information, Perkins disagreed.

She explained that during that period, she was meeting numerous people who were providing extensive information about the Post Office, which she was trying to process and understand. It "did not ring alarm bells," she added.

The note also mentioned Grant's comments that the Post Office had driven "a very hard bargain" on Horizon's price, but Fujitsu compromised on "quality/assurance," suggesting the Post Office was being "naive."

Perkins acknowledged to the inquiry that it was common for organisations contracting with IT companies to be at a disadvantage and expressed concerns about the unequal relationship with Fujitsu.

More For You

Sri Lanka forms committee to address UK sanctions
Anura Kumara Dissanayake

Sri Lanka forms committee to address UK sanctions

THE Sri Lanka government on Wednesday (2) formed a committee to recommend measures regarding the UK's decision to impose sanctions on three former military commanders who led the campaign that crushed the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) in 2009.

Health minister Nalinda Jayatissa told reporters that foreign minister Vijitha Herath, justice minister Harshana Nanayakkara and deputy minister of defence Aruna Jayasekara would comprise the committee that would consult experts for the purpose.

Keep ReadingShow less
Gujarat-blast-ANI

The blast caused the factory’s concrete roof to collapse, scattering debris and body parts across the area, officials confirmed. (Photo: ANI)

ANI

Death toll rises to 21 in Gujarat firework factory explosion

AN EXPLOSION at an illegal firecracker factory in Gujarat's Deesa town killed 21 people and injured several others on Tuesday, officials said.

The blast caused the factory’s concrete roof to collapse, scattering debris and body parts across the area, officials confirmed.

Keep ReadingShow less
Child benefit payments set to rise for UK families

Child benefit, normally paid every four weeks directly into bank accounts, has undergone significant changes in recent months (Photo: Getty Images)

Child benefit payments set to rise for UK families

MILLIONS of British families are set to receive a financial boost as child benefit payments increase from April 7, according to HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC).

From next week, parents will receive £26.05 per week for the eldest or only child, amounting to £1,354.60 annually - up from the current rate of £25.60. For each additional child, payments will rise to £17.25 weekly, totalling £897 per year - an increase from the present £16.95 rate. This represents a 1.7 per cent increase across all payment categories.

Keep ReadingShow less
Anant Ambani Walks 140 Km in Spiritual Tribute on 30th Birthday

Anant’s padyatra is a reflection of the larger cultural fabric of India

Getty

Anant Ambani embarks on a 140-kilometer spiritual journey on foot to celebrate 30th birthday

Anant Ambani, a director of Reliance Industries Limited and a prominent figure in Indian industry, has chosen a unique and spiritual way to mark his 30th birthday. As part of his celebrations, he is currently undertaking a padyatra—a traditional pilgrimage on foot—from Jamnagar to Dwarka, covering a distance of approximately 140 kilometres. The journey reflects his devotion to Lord Dwarkadhish, the presiding deity of the Dwarkadhish Temple in the city of Dwarka.

Anant began his journey from his family’s residence in Moti Khavdi, Jamnagar, and has been progressing steadily for the past five days. Walking an estimated 10-12 kilometres each night, he travels under the protection of Z+ security and local police, ensuring his safety during this significant journey. The padyatra is expected to take between seven to nine days in total, with plans to conclude at the Dwarkadhish Temple in time for his birthday on April 10.

Keep ReadingShow less
New TB action plan proposed as cases surge

Government urged experts to come forward to help draw up a new five-year TB action plan. (Photo: Getty Images)

New TB action plan proposed as cases surge

BRITAIN on Wednesday (2) urged health experts and sufferers of tuberculosis (TB) to come forward to help draw up a new five-year action plan as it deals with record rises in the disease.

In 2023, England recorded its largest annual increase (11 per cent) in cases since enhanced surveillance began in 2000.

Keep ReadingShow less