Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Back on public view, Koh-i-Noor carries weight of UK's colonial past

India, Afghanistan, Iran and Pakistan are laying claim to the gem

Back on public view, Koh-i-Noor carries weight of UK's colonial past

THE star of Britain's crown jewels, the Koh-i-Noor diamond, is back on view after a notable absence from King Charles's coronation that highlighted the nation's awkward ties with its colonial past.

The massive stone has appeared at formal occasions for more than 150 years, but Charles's wife Camilla opted not to wear it for May's coronation amid debate in the UK over imperial artefacts and calls in India for the diamond's return.

Months after the coronation, with the crown jewels returned to public display in the Tower of London, the question remains: Where does the priceless gem rightfully belong?

Legend has it that the 186 carat diamond, which was cut down to 106 carats by Queen Victoria, has denoted supreme authority since at least the time of the Delhi Sultanate's invasion of the kingdoms of southern India in the 14th century.

The British state-chartered East India Company formally annexed the Kingdom of Punjab in 1849 after winning the Second Anglo-Sikh War, gaining the diamond as part of the resulting peace treaty and giving it to Queen Victoria.

Yet, New Delhi has repeatedly sought its return and foreign ministry spokesman Arindam Bagchi said last year: "We have been raising this matter from time to time with the UK government and we will continue to explore ways and means for obtaining a satisfactory resolution of the matter."

One man with a long connection to the diamond is Eddie LeVian, CEO of the US-based Le Vian fine jewellers - which counts Rihanna and Jennifer Lopez as clients - whose family looked after the diamond while it was in the hands of the Persian shah in the 18th century.

"I don't know what the legal argument would be to say that it should be returned to India, considering that it was gifted to Queen Victoria by the East India Company and was not taken from India by the British," LeVian said at the Tower of London, which his company had taken over for an event.

"This diamond wasn't discovered by the Indian government," he added, saying that India didn't exist as a sovereign entity at the time of its discovery.

"I don't know if the claim went to an international court that the evidence would mean that the government of India has a right to the Koh-i-Noor diamond.

"As time passes, the question for India is becoming more frequently asked, but I don't see how India's claim could be resolved," he said.

'Unusable'

Part of the problem for India is the diamond's uncertain history steeped in conquest.

While there is little doubt it was mined in India, its history thereafter is a mixture of myth and fact, with several countries including Afghanistan, Iran and Pakistan also laying claim to the gem.

Martin Bayly, assistant professor at the London School of Economics' Department of International Relations, said "the history is so contested that it would be impossible to agree upon any kind of legal ownership.

"And I don't know what authority would judge on that anyway."

The diamond came into British hands while India was made up of multiple different kingdoms and states rather than being a single country, and the family of the maharaja ruler who had prior possession argue that they are the rightful owners, not the Indian government.

"The arguments on legal ownership are coming from a contemporary legal context of sovereign nation states, reaching back in time to a period where legal nation state sovereignty meant something different," said Bayly.

Instead, India's best hope rests with the moral argument currently raging within the UK itself, he added.

"The public debate on this has become tied up in what's not very satisfactorily called the culture wars."

The diamond's display at the Tower of London now contains a label reading "a symbol of conquest", saying the peace treaty "compelled" the 10-year-old maharaja to "surrender" it.

Bayly also highlighted the recent return of various Benin Bronzes by different British institutions as an example of how the tide was generally turning.

"You can apply the same argument to the Koh-i-Noor diamond," he said.

"But I think probably the Koh-i-Noor diamond is in a separate class of politicised debate... because it's a symbol of rulership."

While the priceless gem has become "so diplomatically toxic" that it is "almost unusable" in state occasions, it would be "politically naive to believe" that any government would agree to its return, Bayly added.

"We're stuck," he added.

(AFP)

More For You

Sri Lanka seeks to negotiate with Adani over renewable energy plants

Gautam Adani

Sri Lanka seeks to negotiate with Adani over renewable energy plants

SRI LANKA’S government started talks with India’s Adani Group to lower the cost of power from two wind power projects the group will build in the island nation’s northern province, the cabinet spokesman said last Tuesday (28).

Sri Lanka has been reviewing the group’s local projects after US authorities in November accused billionaire founder Gautam Adani and other executives of being part of a scheme to pay bribes to secure Indian power supply contracts. Adani has denied the allegations.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bank-of-England-Getty

The BoE also revised its economic growth forecast for 2025, reducing it by half. (Photo credit: Getty Images)

Bank of England cuts rates, lowers growth outlook

THE BANK OF ENGLAND (BoE) has cut interest rates by 0.25 percentage points to 4.5 per cent, with some policymakers supporting a bigger reduction to counter economic slowdown. However, the central bank signalled a cautious approach to future cuts, citing inflation concerns and global uncertainty.

The BoE also revised its economic growth forecast for 2025, reducing it by half. Chancellor Rachel Reeves, who has been advocating for faster economic growth, faces a challenge as inflation is now projected to be nearly double the 2 per cent target this year.

Keep ReadingShow less
Mina Anwar: A trailblazer on stage and screen brings Shirley Valentine to life

Mina Anwar

Mina Anwar: A trailblazer on stage and screen brings Shirley Valentine to life

MINA ANWAR has left a lasting mark on British popular culture with outstanding performances across film, theatre, and TV.

The acclaimed actress is part of a generation that broke new ground for British Asians, with a remarkable body of work that includes a trailblazing role in the hit sitcom The Thin Blue Line and major theatrical productions.

Keep ReadingShow less
Indian billionaires and tech titans shake up English cricket with major investments in The Hundred

The Oval Invincibles, now co-owned by Mukesh Ambani, are two-time defending champions in the men’s 100-ball competition

Indian billionaires and tech titans shake up English cricket with major investments in The Hundred

INDIAN billionaires and Indian American tech tycoons are among new owners of franchises in the Hundred cricket league.

Mukesh Ambani, Nikesh Arora and Sanjiv Goenka have in recent days invested in English cricket by acquiring a minority share in some of the Hundred teams.

Keep ReadingShow less
Netflix's 'The Roshans' leaves out negative side of Hrithik Roshan's family

(From left) Hrithik Roshan, Rajesh Roshan and Rakesh Roshan

Netflix's 'The Roshans' leaves out negative side of Hrithik Roshan's family

THE recently released Netflix documentary The Roshans has been attracting global attention since its premiere. The series devotes an episode to each member of the film family, starting with music director Roshan Lal Nagrath.

Featuring a star-studded lineup of contributors, along with archival photos and film footage, it traces the journey of (musician) Rajesh, (filmmaker) Rakesh, and (actor) Hrithik Roshan.

Keep ReadingShow less