Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Asian MP backs National Trust

By Amit Roy

VIRENDRA SHARMA, the vet­eran Labour MP for Ealing Southall, has congratulated the National Trust for publishing a report which reveals that nearly 100 of the properties it looks after were built with the pro­ceeds of either the slave trade or colonial loot from India.


He has also taken Baroness Ti­na Stowell, the chair of the Char­ity Commission, to task after she asked charities not to get in­volved in “culture wars”.

“If the National Trust isn’t go­ing to bring out the history of its properties, who is?” said Sharma.

“I congratulate the National Trust for publishing this report,” he told Eastern Eye.

Lady Stowell, a former Tory leader of the Lords and some 25 Conservative MPs who belong to a self-styled “Common Sense Group”, take a different view of the 115-page National Trust re­port, Addressing our histories of colonialism and historic slavery.

She set out her trenchant views in an article in a national news­paper, saying “if you want to im­prove lives and strengthen com­munities through charity, you need to leave party politics and the culture wars out of it”.

Lady Stowell said: “It has to be said that not all charities attract universal support for their cause.

“Even so, all can campaign in support of the causes they exist to fight for (or against) – as long as they don’t stray into party politics by doing so. The law is clear on that – and the job of the Charity Commission is to ensure that charities stick to it.

“But what we’ve seen in the past few years is the growth of new divisions which don’t neatly respect party lines.

“Issues like Brexit; the exercise and limits of free speech; the root causes of inequality; or how best to tell the story of British history. They are all defining politics at home and around the world.”

She said that goodwill for char­ities was returning “after serious scandals in recent years which dented public trust in charity”, stressing: “Now would be the worst possible moment to jeop­ardise that goodwill by getting drawn into culture wars, on any side of the argument.”

She did not mention the National Trust by name, but the paper made it clear this was indeed her tar­get: “Charities like the National Trust are told to avoid wokery and culture wars – by their own UK chief.”

A Charity Commission spokes­woman said: “In her article, the chair makes the point that the environment in which charities operate now is different from that experienced in the past, and that divisions beyond those that are strictly party political run deep in our society. Charities and their leaders should be mindful of this as they make decisions about campaigning and political activi­ty. Our CEO made a similar point in a blog last year, ahead of the most recent general election.”

Sharma, whose constituency in north-west London not far from Heathrow contains one of the biggest Asian populations in the country, has been prominent in seeking an official British gov­ernment apology for the Jallian­wala Bagh massacre of 1919.

Last week he tabled a Com­mons motion urging black and Asian history be taught in schools, saying he had backing from across the Commons.

He told Eastern Eye: “I have been campaigning to decolonial­ise our curriculum because Brit­ish children should learn not just about 1,000 years of British suc­cess and innovation, but also about the human cost across the world of expedition, exploration and exploitation.

“The horrific attack on a Sikh child in Telford just last week shows how much further we still need to go. It is right that the Na­tional Trust explores the origin of the houses they look after, and discuss what brought that wealth to Britain.

“The National Trust is home to some amazing spaces, and tells the story of this country through the houses of the gentry, nobility, aristocracy and royal family in a way that no other organisation does. It is a great national institu­tion that I am delighted is bring­ing so much of its past into the public realm.”

Sharma was supported by his colleague Barry Gardiner, the for­mer shadow sec­retary of state for international trade. His north Lon­don constituency, Brent North, also has a high con­centration of Asian voters. Referring to the “Common Sense Group” of Tory MPs, Gardiner commented: “It’s obvious that any group that calls itself ‘the Common Sense Group’ is not.”

He added: “The idea that char­ities are divorced from the wider political debates of the day is not sustainable. The Joseph Rown­tree Charitable Trust is a good example of a charity whose entire focus is on such matters, and for the Charity Commission to deny the validity of such issues is not only foolish but shows an alarm­ing level of ignorance.”

The director-general of the Na­tional Trust, Hilary McGrady, has addressed Lady Stowell’s criticisms in a personal blog, Finding places of calm amidst a ‘culture war’.

She said: “At a time when we most need understanding and tolerance to get us through a ter­rible crisis, some of our oldest institutions and independent charities have become a battle ground in so-called ‘culture wars’.

“In organisations that millions of people care about – and some of our most fierce critics are those who care a great deal – there will always be debate about how pro­gress is to be made. And we wel­come debate – that’s part of being a membership organisation. But the polarisation of views and quality of debate today surround­ing charities and independent organisations feels different.

“In recent months, I’ve received hundreds of letters and emails expressing all kinds of views about the many decisions we make every day – from passionate support to vicious threats. It’s the same picture on social media.

“Upsetting anyone is, of course, a matter of regret for me. Our founders wrote that we exist for the benefit of the nation. I take that seriously and I would never want anyone to feel at odds with an institution that is there to serve them.

“Cultural organisations should be places where people can find common ground. Places where debate can be had with shared understanding. Spaces to speak and to listen.”

More For You

Jolly Rancher Recalled in UK Over Cancer-Linked Chemical Fears

Jolly Rancher sweet products were recalled due to the presence of banned ingredients

Amazon.UK

Jolly Rancher candy recalled in UK over cancer-linked chemicals

An urgent warning has been issued in the UK after several popular Jolly Rancher sweet products were recalled due to the presence of banned ingredients linked to cancer. The Food Standards Agency (FSA) has confirmed that certain products, including Jolly Rancher Hard Candy, ‘Misfits’ Gummies, Hard Candy Fruity 2 in 1, and Berry Gummies, are affected.

These sweets, produced by American confectionery giant Hershey, were found to contain Mineral Oil Aromatic Hydrocarbons (MOAH) and Mineral Oil Saturated Hydrocarbon (MOSH), both of which are derived from crude oil and have been associated with serious health risks, including cancer.

Keep ReadingShow less
British national survives Ahmedabad Air India crash

Rescue and relief work underway following the Air India plane crash, in Ahmedabad. (PTI Photo)

British national survives Ahmedabad Air India crash

ONE survivor walked away from the Air India aircraft that crashed at Ahmedabad airport earlier this morning (12), according to the latest reports from India.

Vishwash Kumar Ramesh, 40, a UK national, was in seat 11A of the Air India Flight 171 bound for London Gatwick when it crashed shortly after take off from Ahmedabad with 242 people on board.

Keep ReadingShow less
Air India crash: Former Gujarat chief minister Rupani was on aircraft

FILE PHOTO: Former Gujarat chief minister Vijay Rupani. (PTI Photo)

Air India crash: Former Gujarat chief minister Rupani was on aircraft

FORMER Gujarat chief minister Vijay Rupani was believed to be on board the London-bound Air India plane that crashed near the Ahmedabad airport soon after take-off on Thursday (12), a Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader said.

"Vijay Rupani was going to London by the Air India flight," senior BJP leader Bhupendrasinh Chudasama told reporters in Ahmedabad. "I am going to the city civil hospital to inquire about him," he added.

Keep ReadingShow less
Air India crash: Police collect 204 dead bodies

Police said they had collected 204 dead bodies (PTI photo)

Air India crash: Police collect 204 dead bodies

  • All 242 passengers on board believed to have been killed in the Air India crash AI-171 in Ahmedabad
  • Air India passenger hotline numbers - 1800 5691 444 and for foreign nationals +91 8062779200
  • There were 169 Indian passengers, 53 British, seven Portuguese, and a Canadian on board the flight bound for London Gatwick
  • Contact @HCI_London on the emergency number 07768765035 with regard to emergency visa assistance to travel to India if needed

POLICE in Ahmedabad said they had collected 204 dead bodies after the London-bound Air India aircraft with 242 people on board crashed into residential buildings after takeoff on Thursday (12).

“We have found 204 bodies,” city police commissioner GS Malik said, adding that 41 injured people were “under treatment”.

Keep ReadingShow less
Starmer says scenes of Air India plane crash 'devastating'

Keir Starmer. (Photo by JORDAN PETTITT/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)

Starmer says scenes of Air India plane crash 'devastating'

PRIME MINISTER Keir Starmer on Thursday (12) expressed his anguish following a plane crash involving a London-bound Air India flight with 53 British nationals among 242 on board, shortly after takeoff from Ahmedabad airport.

"The scenes emerging of a London-bound plane carrying many British nationals crashing in the Indian city of Ahmedabad are devastating,” Starmer said in a statement.

Keep ReadingShow less