Roti Kapada Aur Makaan: Making of a film masterpiece
The all-time classic, written, produced, directed, and headlined by movie star Manoj Kumar, transcended conventional storytelling, delivering powerful social commentary.
Stills from Roti Kapada Aur Makaan
By Asjad NazirOct 12, 2024
WHEN Roti Kapada Aur Makaan was released in cinemas on October 18, 1974, it strongly resonated with audiences and became the highest-grossing film of the year.
This all-time classic, written, produced, directed, and headlined by movie star Manoj Kumar, transcended conventional storytelling, delivering powerful social commentary on the struggles of the common man. Powered by a strong cast, this social drama about essential human needs explored themes of dignity, survival, economic disparity, and life in a turbulent era.
Eastern Eye decided to celebrate the drama’s golden anniversary by sharing fascinating facts connected to it:
Manoj Kumar visited several unemployment offices and interacted with job seekers to authentically portray his role. He also drew on his early job-hunting struggles for inspiration, with scenes where his character searches for a job reflecting these real-life observations.
Rajesh Khanna was initially considered for the role of Mohan Babu but had to decline due to other commitments. Navin Nischol, approached next, opted out, not wanting to act in a multistarrer. Although Rajendra Kumar was offered the role, he requested improvements that Manoj Kumar declined to make. Shashi Kapoor was ultimately cast, earning great acclaim.
Sharmila Tagore was first offered the role of Sheetal, but she preferred the character played by Moushumi Chatterjee. Kumar, however, ultimately cast Zeenat Aman as Sheetal.
Zeenat Aman initially hesitated to play the morally ambiguous role of a woman leaving her struggling partner for a wealthier man but was eventually persuaded, solidifying her status as a leading lady willing to break norms.
Amitabh Bachchan was relatively unknown when he was cast in the film but had become a star by its release. His presence helped it become a blockbuster. Despite a suddenly packed schedule, Bachchan made special efforts to accommodate the film, shooting some of his most intense scenes between other projects.
Manoj Kumar had offered Smita Patil a role when she was still an unknown, which she declined. Patil would later become one of India’s greatest film actresses.
It was widely reported that Mehmood had been promised a role that did not materialise, leading to public expressions of displeasure by the legendary actor.
Legendary playback singer Mukesh, despite being unwell, completed the popular song Main Na Bhoolunga with Lata Mangeshkar.
Bachchan sustained an injury during an action sequence but continued shooting to avoid disrupting the schedule.
Chatterjee, pregnant during filming, could not shoot for the song Haye Haye Yeh Majboori. The song was shot with Zeenat Aman, though it didn’t suit her character’s story arc. Chatterjee later revealed that Kumar never fully forgave her for her inability to perform in that song.
During the filming of a rape scene, a significant amount of cooking flour fell on Chatterjee. A lot of it went into her mouth, leading to her vomiting the entire night. It also took hours to remove the flour from her hair.
In keeping with his patriotic Bharat persona, Manoj Kumar included no physical romantic scenes with Zeenat Aman in their roles.
This was the first film for which actor Ajay Devgn’s father, legendary stunt director Veeru Devgan, took full charge of the action scenes.
The project was Manoj Kumar’s most ambitious to date, leading him to mortgage his house to fund the film, which became that year’s biggest Bollywood success.
The film employed a lot of symbolism to reflect the socio-political climate of India at the time. Lead characters Bharat (Manoj Kumar) and Vijay (Amitabh Bachchan) symbolised India and victory, respectively, representing hope for a better future amidst struggles.
Indian cultural references were deliberately included in the dialogues to enhance resonance with the audience.
Kumar had filmed an alternate ending in which his character, Bharat, succumbs to life’s pressures and dies. He eventually chose a positive ending to convey a message of resilience and hope.
The initial cut of Roti Kapada Aur Makaan was much longer than the final 160-minute version, with Kumar editing out scenes to keep the narrative focused and concise.
Unused sub-plots that were excluded from the final edit involved a more in-depth exploration of the relationship between Bharat and his younger brother Vijay.
Kumar organised screenings for workers and lower-income groups to gauge the film’s impact on its target audience.
The film’s distributors and many Bollywood insiders initially disliked the title Roti Kapada Aur Makaan, but Kumar maintained it to encapsulate the film’s social message.
Following the film’s success, Kumar organised special screenings for the impoverished in various rural areas and held charity screenings, with proceeds donated to local initiatives aimed at alleviating poverty. This ultimately reflected the film’s core message.
Some sets used in Roti Kapada Aur Makaan were repurposed for other films of the time.
The song Hai Hai Yeh Majboori was later sampled by hip-hop artist Bubba Sparxxx in the song Ugly and remixed by Bally Sagoo on his album Bollywood Flashback 2.
Roti Kapada Aur Makaan was later remade in Telugu as Jeevana Poratam (1986) and continues to inspire Bollywood movies with its themes.
The timeless classic remains relevant today, highlighting the struggles of the poor and working class to secure basic necessities such as food, clothing, and shelter, as the title suggests. Many filmmakers have been inspired by its themes to create movies about the common man’s struggles, using it as a reference point for addressing similar social issues in subsequent decades.
Lauren Sánchez didn’t need a red carpet to mark her pre-wedding celebration, just a close circle of friends and the charm of Paris. Days before tying the knot with Jeff Bezos, the former TV anchor turned aviation entrepreneur spent a laid-back but lavish weekend in the French capital with a dozen women she calls her pillars of strength.
The guest list was anything but ordinary. Kim Kardashian, Kris Jenner, Katy Perry, Eva Longoria, and a few other familiar faces from business, entertainment, and media joined Sánchez for what looked like a celebration of sisterhood rather than a spectacle. Over the course of two days, the group dined at chic spots like Lafayette’s and cruised through the city on a private boat, all while keeping things relatively low-key by celebrity standards.
From clinking espresso martinis to dancing to Earth, Wind & Fire, the vibe was expensive, chill, and relaxed. The celebration wrapped with a surprise vanilla meringue cake and laughter under the Paris sky.
Sánchez shared heartfelt moments on Instagram, calling her friends “the women who’ve lifted me up and shaped my heart.” The photos, mostly in black and white, showed candid rooftop laughs and cosy robe moments, far from the polished party shots one might expect.
Inside Lauren Sánchez’s Paris bachelorette Instagram/laurenwsanchez
Her outfit choices, too, while expensive, leaned into romantic minimalism. A short white Oscar de la Renta dress with 3D florals and a vintage pink Chanel bag added soft glamour to the weekend.
Heartfelt moments and low-key glam defined Sánchez’s pre-wedding celebration in Paris Instagram/laurenwsanchez
Sánchez and Bezos, who went public in 2019, got engaged in 2023 on board his yacht Koru, where he proposed with a rare 20-carat pink diamond worth approximately £15 million (₹160 crore). Their wedding is expected in June on the coast of Venice, Italy, although they’ve been tight-lipped about the specifics. Italian officials have already reassured locals that the ceremony will not disrupt the city.
A candid moment with Sánchez and her closest friendsInstagram/laurenwsanchez
Beyond the headlines and designer outfits, Sánchez’s celebration in Paris was about a woman pausing to honour the relationships that helped her grow, before stepping into a new chapter as Mrs. Bezos.
Ever walked into a cinema, popcorn in hand, all hyped for a big new Hindi release – only to realise, halfway through, that you have seen the exact same story before, just in another language? That weird sense of déjà vu has become all too familiar for Bollywood audiences in recent years, with one remake after another. Many are based on South Indian hits.
From Vikram Vedha to Shehzada, Bholaa to Selfiee, Bollywood seems to be treating South Indian blockbusters like a catalogue to borrow from. But here is the problem – most of them did not work. Not just with critics, but at the box office too. Which raises the obvious question: if the originals were such big hits, why can’t the Hindi versions strike gold?
The numbers do not lie Let us look at the figures.
The Tamil film Vikram Vedha (2017) was made on a budget of £103,695 (₹11 million) and earned £5.66 million (₹600 million). It had strong writing, originality, and standout performances. The 2022 Hindi remake starring Hrithik Roshan and Saif Ali Khan, despite slick production, was a costly misfire.
Bholaa, a remake of Kaithi, leaned too heavily on visual effects and forgot the raw, gritty storytelling that made the original shine. Made for £8.8 million (₹1 billion), it only grossed £9.7 million (₹1.1 billion) worldwide. Compare that with Kaithi, made for £2.2 million (₹250 million), which earned over £9.3 million (₹1.05 billion) – without big stars or CGI. This pattern keeps repeating itself.
Selfiee, based on Malayalam hit Driving Licence, flopped. Shehzada tried to replicate the success of Ala Vaikunthapurramuloo and failed miserably. Sarfira, based on Soorarai Pottru, came and went without impact. Even Baby John (a version of Theri) and Deva (inspired by Mumbai Police) could not turn strong originals into Hindi box office hits.
Ajay Devgn in Bholaa
Star power is not enough These numbers paint a clear picture: the remakes are not connecting. But what about star power? Salman Khan, Akshay Kumar, Shahid Kapoor, Hrithik Roshan, Kartik Aaryan – surely such big names should guarantee success? Unfortunately, it is not that simple anymore.
Audiences are smarter now. Thanks to streaming platforms, dubbed versions and social media buzz, many have already seen the originals – or at least know the storyline. So when the Hindi version arrives, it often feels stale.
Hrithik Roshan in Vikram Vedha
What is missing from the remakes? Successful films rely on many elements – chemistry between the leads, emotional tone, pacing – things you cannot script or transplant.
Take Vinnaithaandi Varuvaayaa. The chemistry between Silambarasan TR and Trisha felt electric, rooted in the film’s deeply emotional story of unrequited love. The Hindi remake Ekk Deewana Tha, with Prateik Babbar and Amy Jackson, lacked that connection.
Okkadu had raw energy, with Mahesh Babu anchoring the emotional weight. Ghilli, its Tamil counterpart, had similar intensity with Vijay’s charismatic presence and high-octane action. But the Hindi version Tevar lacked the same punch and raw emotion.
Similarly, Theri worked because of Vijay’s stardom, Atlee’s direction, and its emotionally driven story. Baby John has not captured that same feeling.
Mahesh Babu in Okkadu
Audiences want originality Here is the real kicker – audiences are not rejecting South Indian cinema. In fact, they are embracing it. Baahubali 2, the Pushpa and KGF franchises, RRR, Kantara – all became massive pan-India hits. The appetite for regional content is real.
What people are rejecting is lazy filmmaking – the idea that simply changing the language, inflating the budget, and casting a big Bollywood name is enough.
What works today is originality. Films like 12th Fail and Article 15 resonated because they told new stories. Even blockbusters like Pathaan and Jawan succeeded by playing to their own strengths – not copying someone else’s.
RRR
A call for change So what should Bollywood do? The answer is simple: focus on originality.
Stop leaning on South Indian remakes. Start backing fresh, innovative stories that speak to today’s diverse audience. The success of South Indian films lies in their ability to connect emotionally, to create real characters and tell untold stories. Bollywood needs to find that magic again.
In the end, remakes may seem like a safe bet – but they are not always the solution. Why settle for déjà vu when you can create something unforgettable?
The audience has evolved. Maybe now, it is time the industry asked itself: has it?X: @GeorgeViews
Keep ReadingShow less
Ananya Panday gets candid about body shaming on Lilly Singh’s podcast
Ananya Panday is no stranger to the spotlight, but she’s also tired of being stuck under a microscope. In a recent chat with Lilly Singh on her podcast Shame Less, the actor spoke honestly about the constant criticism of her body and the double standards women face in the film industry.
Ananya recalled the early days of her career when, at 18, she was mocked for being too thin. Terms like “chicken legs” and “matchstick” were thrown at her regularly. “They said I had no boobs, no butt, like a flat-screen,” she shared. Fast forward a few years, and as her body naturally changed, new rumours popped up, but this time accusing her of undergoing cosmetic surgery. “Now they say I’ve had my butt done. You can never win,” she said.
What hits harder for Ananya is that this scrutiny often comes from other women. “The harshest comments I get are from women. I rarely see this happening to male actors,” she said, pointing out the gender gap in how public figures are judged.
But Ananya doesn’t shy away from taking responsibility either. She admitted that Bollywood films, including some of her own, have pushed unrealistic beauty ideals. “We’ve shown women waking up with perfect hair and makeup. That’s not real life. I’ve been part of that narrative, and I’m trying to be more aware of it now,” she said. Off camera, she tries to keep things real, reminding her followers that what they see on screen isn’t always the truth.
This honesty is, in fact, a shift in Ananya’s journey, from someone who once felt pressured to fit in, to an actor willing to question the norms she’s grown up with. Her recent work also reflects that change. From light-hearted romances to more grounded roles like her turn as a lawyer in Kesari: Chapter 2, Ananya is clearly making deliberate choices.
Women in the public eye are constantly judged, but it’s time to break that cycle. “If I talk about it, maybe one other girl will feel less alone,” she said. That, perhaps, is the quiet power behind her loudest statement yet.
Keep ReadingShow less
Angelina Jolie stuns in a strapless nude gown on the Cannes 2025 red carpet
After a long break from the Cannes spotlight, Angelina Jolie stepped back onto the red carpet, quietly commanding attention without theatrics. It’s been nearly 14 years since she last appeared at the French film festival, but her recent appearance shows she never really left the scene, she just chose when to re-enter it.
At the premiere of Ari Aster’s Eddington during the 78th Cannes Film Festival, Jolie arrived in a strapless white and silver gown designed by Brunello Cucinelli, a label she often turns to for its classy, minimalist elegance. The look was elevated with diamond accessories from Chopard, adding just enough sparkle without overwhelming her understated style.
Jolie keeps it classic in Brunello Cucinelli with Chopard diamonds for Eddington premiereGetty Images
The nude-toned dress was detailed with subtle embroidery and featured a structured A-line silhouette. Its fitted bustier, square neckline, and flowing hem were all about clean lines and classic femininity: nothing flashy, just well-crafted. Her choice of accessories followed the same theme: a pear-shaped diamond pendant, teardrop earrings, and a striking ring.
Her hair was styled in soft waves, parted to the side, and her makeup was balanced with wine-toned nails, muted smoky eyes, a soft pink lip, and feathered brows that framed her face.
The actress makes a graceful return to Cannes after 14 years awayGetty Images
Jolie took on the role of Trophée Chopard godmother this year, an honour that involves presenting an award to two emerging talents in cinema: Marie Colomb and Finn Bennett. The award celebrates the future of film, and Jolie’s presence felt fitting. Over the years, stars like Julia Roberts, Cate Blanchett, and Charlize Theron have taken on this role, and Jolie now joins that distinguished list.
For the Trophée Chopard dinner, Jolie wore a simple one-sleeved gown with a slit, paired with ankle-strap heels and silver earrings. She kept her makeup light and her hair down, opting for ease over excess.
Angelina Jolie interacting with fans Getty Images
Though she’s been away from the Cannes red carpet, Jolie hasn’t been out of sight. Her recent film Maria, based on opera legend Maria Callas, kept her on the awards circuit earlier this year. She also made headlines as a producer of the Broadway musical The Outsiders, which went on to win big at the 2024 Tony Awards.
Jolie keeps her style effortless for Cannes 2025Getty Images
Angelina Jolie’s Cannes appearance was a glorious comeback. But more than that, it was a quiet reminder of who she is: a woman of style, substance, and selective presence.
The buzz around King, Shah Rukh Khan’s upcoming action-thriller, just got bigger. Rani Mukerji is officially part of the film, stepping in for a role that’s brief but deeply important. Shooting begins on 20 May in Mumbai, with an international schedule to follow.
King is being helmed by Siddharth Anand, the director behind Pathaan and War. This film will not only mark SRK’s return to a high-action role, where he plays an assassin, but also introduces his daughter, Suhana Khan, to the big screen. The cast includes Deepika Padukone, Abhishek Bachchan, Anil Kapoor, Jackie Shroff, Arshad Warsi, Jaideep Ahlawat, and Abhay Verma, making it one of the biggest star-studded projects in recent memory.
The iconic duo returns to the screen after more than a decadeGetty Images
Rani Mukerji joins the cast in a special cameo as Suhana Khan’s mother. While she’s expected to shoot for just five days, her role is far from minor. Insiders say her character is central to the story’s emotional arc and serves as a turning point in the larger action narrative.
This is also Rani and Shah Rukh’s reunion after more than a decade. The two have a long list of hits together, from the iconic Kuch Kuch Hota Hai to Kabhi Khushi Kabhie Gham, and their on-screen chemistry is considered the gold standard. Their scenes in King are expected to tap into that nostalgia while adding a fresh layer to the story.
Sources say it didn’t take long for Rani to say yes. The part, though short, left a strong impression on her. “She heard the story and agreed instantly. It’s a powerful role that holds the emotional thread of the film,” one source shared.
Rani Mukerji will join Shah Rukh Khan for the much-awaited KingGetty Images
Interestingly, earlier buzz suggested that Deepika Padukone might play Suhana’s mother in the film, but the final decision went to Rani. This change seems to have added an extra edge to the film’s casting.
Currently in pre-production, King is aiming for a release sometime between October and December 2026. With a cast this strong and a fresh mix of family, action, and suspense, the film is shaping up to be a major event not just for Shah Rukh fans, but for Bollywood itself.