Skip to content 
Search

Latest Stories

Profit and loss: Is photocopying chapters of educational books legal?

Students will celebrate if a court in India rules that a shop can continue to sell photocopied chapters of books, according to an expert.

Publishing giants including Oxford University Press will have an appeal hearing on Tuesday (November 29) in Delhi over the four-year battle involving a bookshop.


A court ruled in September that Rameshwari Photocopier, based at Delhi University’s School of Economics, can make copies of pages from textbooks and sell them to students as “course packs”.

The publishers argue the store was violating their copyright and exploiting their work, which is affecting their profits. But teachers, authors and undergraduates have thrown their support behind the bookshop.

Shamnad Basheer, a professor of intellectual property law at Nirma University in Ahmedabad, told Eastern Eye if the appeal is dismissed, it will help students who are paying too much for books.

“A number of authors were against this lawsuit filed because they knew it was important for students to access their works.

“It was not realistic to expect students to buy these books. Rather through course packs, students would at least get exposed to these authors.

“The lawsuit therefore is primarily brought to further the private profits of publishers. And more importantly to bolster the fortunes of the newly set up Indian Reprographic Rights Organisation (IRRO).”

He added: “Many academic authors are being paid for by universities and in publicly funded universities; they are effectively paid for by tax payers. This, coupled with the government doling out significant moneys to universities for library purchases, essentially means we have a highly subsidised academic publishing ecosystem.

“To now charge excessively high prices for these books is mercenary mercantilism by publishers. I’m glad this lawsuit will open up a can of worms, and also force us to interrogate as to how much authors are being paid as royalties and who really benefits from all of this.”

The publishers, including Cambridge University Press and Taylor & Francis Books approached the Delhi high court in 2012 to get a permanent injunction to bar Rameshwari Photocopier from making copies of its books.

They asked the judge to ensure the university obtains a licence and gets its permission. But Delhi University said no license was granted to the shop and it was allowed to run, “keeping the interest of the students in mind”.

The publishers said it has brought out low-cost editions, course-packs, adaptations and reprint titles to help undergraduates.

In a statement to Eastern Eye, the Association of Publishers in India, the Federation of Indian Publishers and the IRRO said: “We have decided to support the publishers’ appeal with the Delhi high court bench, filed against the dismissal of their suit.

“We fully support the principle of equitable access to knowledge. But such access would not exist without the efforts of content creators, authors, illustrators, designers, publishers and everyone involved in the creation and dissemination of original content. Their rights must be respected.

“We have full faith the court will balance the interests of those creating learning materials with those requiring access to them in a fair and sustainable manner.”

The book shop could be forced to pay compensation to the companies if they lose next week’s appeal hearing.

More For You

Court to review teen's sentence in Bhim Kohli case
Bhim Kohli

Court to review teen's sentence in Bhim Kohli case

THE seven-year prison sentence handed to a 15-year-old boy convicted of the manslaughter of 80-year-old Bhim Sen Kohli is to be reviewed under the UK’s Unduly Lenient Sentence (ULS) scheme.

The Attorney General’s Office confirmed on Friday (5) that the teenager’s sentence will now be considered by the Court of Appeal.

Keep ReadingShow less
Dalai Lama hopes to live 'beyond 130 years'

Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama attends a prayer meet held for his long life at the Dalai Lama temple in the northern hill town of Dharamshala, India, July 5, 2025. REUTERS/Anushree Fadnavis

Dalai Lama hopes to live 'beyond 130 years'

THE Dalai Lama said on Saturday (5) he hopes to live until he is more than 130 years old, two decades longer than his previous prediction, following his assurance to followers that he would reincarnate as the spiritual head of the faith upon his death.

The Nobel Peace Prize winner was speaking during a ceremony organised by his followers to offer prayers for his long life, ahead of his 90th birthday on Sunday (6), and as China insists it will choose his successor. The Dalai Lama told Reuters in December he might live to 110.

Keep ReadingShow less
UK heatwave by mid-July

Daytime temperatures meeting or exceeding set thresholds of 25°C

iStock

Met Office warns of potential third UK heatwave by mid-July

Key points

  • Met Office forecasts rising temperatures by mid-July
  • Possible third heatwave after record-breaking June
  • High pressure system likely to bring hot air from the Atlantic
  • Yellow rain warning and flood alerts issued in parts of Scotland and Cumbria

Possible heatwave to return by mid-July

The UK could experience its third heatwave in a month by mid-July, the Met Office has said. Forecasters expect rising heat and humidity during the second weekend of July, following two weekends of unusually warm weather in late June.

June was officially the hottest on record in England, and the return of high temperatures could mean another heatwave for parts of the country. However, the Met Office cautioned that it is too early to confirm how hot conditions will get.

Keep ReadingShow less
crypto

Two men have been jailed for defrauding investors of £1.5 million through a fake crypto investment scheme. (Representational image: iStock)

iStock

Two jailed over £1.5m crypto investment scam

TWO people who duped investors of £1.5 million by selling fake investments in crypto have been jailed for 12 years, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said.

Raymondip Bedi, of Bromley, and Patrick Mavanga, of Peckham, conned at least 65 people by cold-calling them between February 2017 and June 2019. They operated companies including CCX Capital and Astaria Group LLP.

Keep ReadingShow less
Manchester Police probes over 1,000 child sexual abuse suspects

Photo for representation. (iStock)

Getty Images/iStockphoto

Manchester Police probes over 1,000 child sexual abuse suspects

GREATER MANCHESTER POLICE is now investigating more than 1,000 child sexual abuse suspects, following years of public criticism and institutional failings in tackling child sexual exploitation.

A new report by His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS) has revealed the force has made “significant improvements” in dealing with group-based sexual abuse and related crimes.

Keep ReadingShow less