Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

India's new tax legislation may end disputes with more than 15 foreign companies

India's new tax legislation may end disputes with more than 15 foreign companies

INDIA's disputes with more than 15 foreign companies may end with the new tax legislation unveiled by the country on Thursday (5).

Some of these firms have threatened to seize Indian assets abroad including jets and property.


The legislation would allow for refunds to be made to companies including Vodafone and Cairn Energy of Britain if they end the battle dragging on for the past decade.

International arbitration panels have ruled against India, and a French court last month put a freeze order on 20 Indian government-owned properties in Paris following a move by Cairn.

Cairn, which is seeking $1.2bn awarded by an independent panel last year, has also targeted Air India assets abroad.

More than 15 foreign companies have been in dispute with India for several years over a 2012 tax law that allowed the government to claim retroactive tax from enterprises that acquired assets of Indian companies.

Analysts say the disputes in total are worth more than $6bn and have become a diplomatic issue with some countries.

The government said its new legislation would allow for taxes on the transfer of Indian assets before May 2012 to be "nullified" if certain conditions are met, including the withdrawal of legal claims and a promise that no damages claims would be filed.

The government would not pay interest on any sums owed, officials added.

"This is indeed a very pragmatic step by the government and should help it contain the widespread litigation in cases similar to Vodafone and Cairn. A worthy battle to lose," said Kumarmanglam Vijay, a partner with leading Indian law firm J Sagar Associates

An international tribunal in The Hague last year ruled that the tax and penalties ordered against mobile phone giant Vodafone breached an investment treaty between India and the Netherlands.

The Permanent Court of Arbitration at The Hague in December ordered the Indian government to pay Cairn, which has operations in India, more than $1.2bn, plus interest.

The legislation received a cautious reaction.

Cairn said it had "noted" the proposed bill and was "monitoring the situation". India had said that it did not recognise the tribunal decisions and would fight them.

Indian government revenue secretary Tarun Bajaj has said that it was "unfair criticism to say that we have done this under pressure because of Air India assets being claimed."

But he acknowledged that India faced a "long battle". Bajaj estimated, however, that only $1bn dollars would have to be refunded under the proposal. This is less than the award made to Cairn.

Vodafone faced demands for nearly $3bn from India over its $11bn acquisition of Indian mobile assets from Hutchison Whampoa in 2007. It is not known how much they had paid.

More For You

homelessness

2.7 per cent of private rented properties in England are affordable for people receiving housing benefit.

Getty Images

Nearly 300,000 families face worst forms of homelessness in England, research shows

Highlights

  • 299,100 households experienced acute homelessness in 2024, up 21 per cent since 2022.
  • Rough sleeping and unsuitable temporary accommodation cases increased by 150 per cent since 2020.
  • Councils spent £732 m on unsuitable emergency accommodation in 2023/24.


Almost 300,000 families and individuals across England are now experiencing the worst forms of homelessness, including rough sleeping, unsuitable temporary accommodation and living in tents, according to new research from Crisis.

The landmark study, led by Heriot-Watt University, shows that 299,100 households in England experienced acute homelessness in 2024. This represents a 21 per cent increase since 2022, when there were 246,900 households, and a 45 per cent increase since 2012.

More than 15,000 people slept rough last year, while the number of households in unsuitable temporary accommodation rose from 19,200 in 2020 to 46,700 in 2024. An additional 18,600 households are living in unconventional accommodation such as cars, sheds and tents.

A national survey found 70 per cent of councils have seen increased numbers approaching them for homelessness assistance in the last year. Local authorities in London and Northern England reported the biggest increase.

Keep ReadingShow less