Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Good and bad protests

By Amit Roy

WESTERN gov­ernments and the media have backed protests in the Belarus capital, Minsk, against president Alex­ander Lu­kashenko, who is widely accused of rig­ging his election victory in early August.


But this moral sup­port might prove point­less unless the west is able to match president Vladimir Putin’s threat to send in military help from Russia.

It is worth remember­ing the lessons from the Arab Spring of the early 2010s when the demo­cratic process went into reverse in Egypt, Syria, Iraq and elsewhere, de­spite western support for the protestors’ cause.

Meanwhile, Black Lives Matter marches in Portland, Oregon, are being judged by differ­ent standards, with the protestors denounced as “agitators and thugs” by US president Trump. Joe Biden, the Demo­cratic presidential can­didate who fears the law and order issue is being used against him, has also condemned the vi­olence, though he accused Trump of “fanning the flames of hate and division in our society” and “recklessly encour­aging violence”.

Ironically, Putin said of the Belarus protests: “If this fight for natural rights, legal rights, turns into mayhem and riot­ing, I see nothing good for the country. We have never supported this.”

In other words, one man’s good protest is another man’s thuggery.

More For You

Comment: Horror in Manchester and a glimmer of hope as communities respond together

Mourners gather for the funeral of Adrian Daulby, who was shot when police responded to an attack on Yom Kippur outside Heaton Park Hebrew Congregation, in what police have declared a terrorist incident, at the Agecroft Jewish Cemetery in Pendlebury, Salford, Britain, October 6, 2025.

Reuters

Comment: Horror in Manchester and a glimmer of hope as communities respond together

MURDER at the synagogue made last Thursday (2) a dark day in British history. Yom Kippur, the holy day of atonement, sees soul-searching Jews cut themselves off from electronic communication for many hours. Some, guarding other synagogues, heard of the Manchester attack from police officers rushing to check on their safety. Others from whispers reverberating around the congregation. Some only found out in the evening, turning on mobile phones or car radios after the ceremonies were over.

“There was an air of inevitability about it,” Rabbi David Mason told me. He was among many Jewish voices to describe this trauma as shocking, yet not surprising. No Jewish person has been killed for being Jewish in this country for over half a century. That victims Melvin Cravitz and Adrian Dauby died seeking to protect others exemplifies the enormous everyday efforts on community security in recent decades. There had been a grim, rising expectation, over the last two years of simmering antisemitism, that such a day might come. David Mason told me he fears a ‘double tragedy’ if the response was to disrupt efforts to build cohesion across communities, rather than galvanising them.

Keep ReadingShow less