Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

EXCLUSIVE: ‘Stop weaponising race’

EXCLUSIVE: ‘Stop weaponising race’

By Barnie Choudhury

THE UK government must stop “weap­onising race” and using it as a political tool to further its political agenda, a panel of experts has told Eastern Eye.


The experts, who were taking part in a virtual debate, unanimously concluded that Britain today was more divided about race and racism than during in the high-water mark of 2012, the year of the London Olympics.

“When you look at Nigel Farage, some of the utterances of (home secretary) Priti Patel and (prime minister) Boris Johnson, about making immigration the funda­mental centre point for Brexit, that has given a lot of people who ordinarily would not mouth racist things, a passport to say these things,” said Sailesh Mehta, a barrister and part-time judge.

“I’ve noticed in my profession, as well as in general in society, that in the last two or three years there has been a hard­ening of racism and racist opinion that we didn’t see a few years ago.”

The panel was responding to the gov­ernment’s latest race repot which concluded that Britain was no longer institutionally, structurally or systemically racist.

Report condemned

The report’s conclusions were roundly condemned by the panellists.

Nero Ughwujabo, a former special ad­viser to former prime minister Theresa May, said she set up the Race Disparity Unit to tackle the “burning injustices” felt by Britain’s non-white communities.

“When that report [under May] was published, it was very clear there were persistent inequalities,” said Ughwujabo.

“If this was to make a different claim to what was already made by the disparity audit, it should have given the explana­tion as to exactly how we have arrived at that position, and I don’t think it does.

“That’s where the challenges are, and that’s where I think people are question­ing whether this report was intended to be a truthful, accurate representation of what’s actually happening on the ground.”

Like many, the journalist, writer and professor, Yasmin Alibhai-Brown, felt Downing Street had already made up its mind about what it wanted the report to say, and brought in people who would deliver its views to head the group.

“This report has given the prime minis­ter exactly that,” Alibhai-Brown said.

“If you started saying there is no sexism in this country, if girls and women only took care of themselves a bit better and stop the sense of victimisation, there would be outrage.

“So, there is a political agenda, which maybe some of the panel members didn’t know, and that was to deny not just insti­tutional racism, but all kinds of racism.”

Sanjay Bhandari, the chair of Kick It Out, football’s anti-racism group, be­lieved that the debate needed to focus on the recommendations.

“When you actually look at the recom­mendations, quite a lot of them mirror other reports,” he said. “Why don’t we implement the recommendation from the eight other reports?

“What it brings to mind for me is The Smiths [Manchester rock band] song, What Difference Does It Make? And, actu­ally, what difference is this gonna make? And what difference do all the other eight reports make?”

What the panel unanimously agreed was that Britain remained institutionally systemically and structurally racist.

“Normalised nepotism”

Alibhai-Brown was Britain’s first non-white national newspaper columnist. She contended that her profession needed to wipe out systemic inequalities.

“There’s a kind of normalised nepotism [in newspapers],” she said. “The reason we are in the state we are in is there have been no systems in place to create equal chances for those outside those circles.”

It is not just black and south Asians who are excluded, but white working-class people as well, she added.

“You have to have gone to private school, you have to have gone to Oxford or Cambridge, you have to have been in those circles. So that is what systemic, institutional racism is.

“You look at the way people enter the profession and then rise in it, and you re­alise it is wrong, unfair, and immoral. And you make it a much fairer, neutral system. That’s beginning to happen now.

“It’s very simple to me. If there was no systemic racism, we would have more people in the top hierarchies of every profession. We exist at the bottom. We’re not moving up. Why is that?”

In 1999, Sir William Macpherson con­cluded that the Metropolitan Police was institutionally racist when it investigated the stabbing murder of the black teenag­er, Stephen Lawrence.

GettyImages 950357970 scaled The investigation into the murder of Stephen Lawrence found the Met Police to be institutionally racist (Photo by Victoria Jones WPA Pool/Getty Images)

More that 20 years later, his definition that institutions could be “unwittingly” racist remains a bone of contention.

“I suspect that my colleagues or judges, if they ask themselves, ‘am I racist’, that the answer will be ‘no, I don’t think I am’,” argued Mehta.

“But if they then ask themselves, why is it that our profession in the last 20 years has been almost entirely made of white, upper middle-class men, and the further up the judicial structure you go, the num­bers from public schools these individu­als come from, then you get an idea that this must be structural. It cannot be the case that the top judges in the Supreme Court and the court of appeal can only be created by three or four of the country’s top public schools.

“It must be, therefore, a structural problem. I’m willing to concede that it may be unwitting, although I suspect that there may be a ‘witting’ element to it, a knowing element to it as well.”

Tick box exercise

Bhandari, who was part of the Parker Review into the ethnic make-up of board­rooms, said the danger with all investiga­tions is that they would lead to a tick-box exercise when it came to tackling the lack of racial diversity and inclusion.

“The principal beneficiaries of that are Asian women, because you tick two boxes to get in as a non-executive director,” he said. “That’s the place where people go to fill their criteria and say, ‘actually, yeah, I’ve kind of done diversity, because we’ve got this person that fulfils some criteria.’”

He argued that racial imbalance was caused by what he called “majoritorial bias”, where the system favoured those who were the majority in an organisation.

What institutions needed to do was the examine what he called the “egregious statistical anomalies in the system” and to conclude something was going wrong.

“The biggest statistical anomaly in football is that 10 out of 4,000 profession­al footballers are Asian,” said Bhandari.

“You have to unpack that as to why aren’t kids getting into academies? What are the stereotypes that are applying, what are you recruiting for? Who’s doing the recruiting? What are they thinking?”

His conclusion was that children as young as eight were chosen to join an academy based on the stereotype of how they would develop when it comes to pace, strength and power. Scouts be­lieved these traits cannot be taught, while technique could, he said.

“That explains two things. It explains a positive stereotype that black people ex­perience, which is why they are dispro­portionately positively impacted in that they are over-represented in academies.

“It also explains why Asian kids are disproportionately impacted in that they are perceived as not being strong. What it means is if Xavi [Simons], [Andrés] Ini­esta or [Lionel] Messi were born Asian in the UK, they would never have been professional players because they would not have made it through the academy. Because they are small, they would have been perceived as weak..., as their diet not being helpful.

“Someone would have said their par­ents wanted them to be a doctor or a lawyer, all of those stereotypes would have been applied to them because they are being applied today. So, you have to get into the weeds of understanding where the blockages are.”

Lack of political will

The biggest hurdle, said the panel, was that the recommendations from all the race reports commissioned by various govern­ments have not been implemented.

Ughwujabo believed implementation came down to political will.

“There are specific areas which I think were low-hanging fruits for this particular commission,” he said. “One of them would be the ethnicity pay gap. We’ve seen pro­gress in terms of gender with the gender pay gap, not least because it started a na­tional conversation about gender.

“Also, companies responding to ques­tion their existing systems and structures that disadvantage women in the work­place and do something about it.

“So, the expectation for the ethnicity pay gap is that it would have done some­thing similar, and I think that’s one missed opportunity.”

Cosmetic change

The Eastern Eye panel called for parlia­mentary scrutiny to audit the latest report to make sure the country knew which recommendations had or had not been implemented and the differences they had made.

“Whether intended or unintended,” said Alibhai-Brown. “You have to con­clude that all these things are cosmetic. What we’re missing is an alliance of peo­ple of different backgrounds coming to­gether and saying, not good enough.”

For Bhandari the answer to tackling racism in institutions came down to those willing to hold their staff to account.

“I think it’s going back to who matters more, Larry Fink [boss of investment company BlackRock] or Boris Johnson?

“It’s because the CEO of BlackRock sends a note out to all these investment companies saying, ‘I’m going to be meas­uring you not just on quarterly returns or quarterly income, but also on your social and economic impact.’

“So, the best thing that governments can do is get out of the way and let them get on with doing what they’re doing, be­cause that’s where change is going to be driven from. It’s about getting away from the rhetoric and into [asking], what are the solutions that actually work, and fo­cusing on those actions.”

More For You

Police officers

Police officers stand guard between an anti fascist group and Tommy Robinson supporters during an anti-immigration rally organised by British anti-immigration activist Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, also known as Tommy Robinson, in London, Britain, September 13, 2025.

REUTERS/Jaimi Joy

UK defends France migrant returns deal after court blocks first removal

THE British government has defended its new migrant returns deal with France after a High Court ruling temporarily blocked the deportation of an Eritrean asylum seeker, marking an early legal setback to the scheme.

The 25-year-old man, who arrived in Britain on a small boat from France on August 12, was due to be placed on an Air France flight from Heathrow to Paris on Wednesday (17) morning. But on Tuesday (16), Judge Clive Sheldon granted an interim injunction, saying there was a “serious issue to be tried” over his claim to be a victim of trafficking.

Keep ReadingShow less
Asian surgeon sentenced to six years for sexual assault

Dr Amal Bose. (Photo: Lancashire Police)

Asian surgeon sentenced to six years for sexual assault

AN ASIAN senior heart surgeon, who abused his position to sexually assault female members of staff, has been jailed for six years.

Dr Amal Bose, from Lancaster, was convicted of 12 counts of sexual assault against five colleagues at Blackpool Victoria Hospital between 2017 and 2022. He was cleared of two other charges.

Keep ReadingShow less
Modi & Trump

Donald Trump and Narendra Modi shake hands as they attend a joint press conference at the White House on February 13, 2025.

Reuters

Trump greets Modi on 75th birthday, trade talks continue in Delhi

Highlights:

  • Both leaders reaffirm commitment to India-US partnership
  • Trade talks resume in New Delhi amid tariff tensions
  • India defends purchase of discounted Russian oil

US PRESIDENT Donald Trump on Tuesday called Indian prime minister Narendra Modi and greeted him ahead of his 75th birthday. The phone call sparked hopes of a reset in India-US ties, which had been under strain after Washington doubled tariffs on Indian goods to 50 per cent.

Keep ReadingShow less
​Donald Trump and Melania Trump

Donald Trump and Melania Trump exit Air Force One after arriving at London Stansted Airport for a state visit on September 16, 2025 in Stansted, Essex.

Getty Images

UK rolls out royal welcome as Trump begins second state visit

Highlights:

  • Trump begins his second state visit to the UK with a royal welcome at Windsor Castle
  • Prince William, Catherine, King Charles and Queen Camilla take part in ceremony
  • State banquet and trade talks with prime minister Keir Starmer scheduled
  • Protests and security operation mark visit amid political challenges

US PRESIDENT Donald Trump began his unprecedented second state visit to Britain on Wednesday with a lavish welcome from King Charles and the royal family at Windsor Castle.

Keep ReadingShow less
11th UK Gatka Championship

All winners received medals and trophies

UK Parliament

11th UK Gatka Championship ends with Welsh debut and £1,000 support for Gatka Akharas

Highlights:

  • The 11th UK National Gatka Championship was hosted near Cardiff, marking the first time in Wales.
  • Winners included Roop Kaur (girls), Navjot Singh (boys), and Gurdeep Singh (men’s).
  • Gatka Federation UK awarded £1,000 to each participating Akhara to support martial arts promotion.
  • Chief guests included MP Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi and Harjeet Singh Grewal, President of the World Gatka Federation.

Gatka Championship marks Welsh debut

The 11th UK National Gatka Championship concluded on a high note near Cardiff, Wales, showcasing the traditional Sikh martial art with flair. Seven leading Gatka Akharas participated, thrilling spectators with their lightning-fast strikes, precision moves and elegant techniques.

Inauguration by global leaders

The tournament was inaugurated by Harjeet Singh Grewal, President of the World Gatka Federation (WGF) and the National Gatka Association of India (NGAI). He was joined by Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi MP, President of Gatka Federation UK, alongside other dignitaries including Jagbir Singh Jagga Chakar, President of Wales Kabaddi Club, and community leaders from the Haveli Hotel Pontyclun.

Keep ReadingShow less