Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Did minister ‘mislead’ House about PHE review?

By Barnie Choudhury

QUESTIONS are being asked about whether a minister misled parliament during a debate on Public Health England’s (PHE) review into the disproportionately high number of Asian and black people who died from Covid-19, Eastern Eye has learnt.


It follows last Thursday’s (4) urgent question to the equalities minister, Kemi Badenoch, in the Commons.

Eastern Eye understands that there are three main areas of concern – who led the review, why there were no recommendations, and why material from experts and groups was left out of the final report.

Badenoch told MPs that a BAME PHE director had led the review. “We do want to see diversity in leadership across institutions in this country, which is one reason why we asked Professor Kevin Fenton, who is a black surgeon, to lead on this review,” she said.

But the terms of reference (TOR), published on May 5, contradicts this. It said, “This work will be led jointly by Professors Yvonne Doyle and John Newton, and initial findings should be available by the end of May.”

Eastern Eye understands neither Doyle nor Newton is black or Asian. Badenoch also told the Commons that “PHE did not make recommendations, because it was not able to do so. Some of the data needed is not routinely collected but acquiring it would be extremely beneficial.” That was despite assurances in the TOR that it would “suggest recommendations for further action that should be taken to reduce disparities in risk and outcomes from Covid-19 on the population”.

The TOR document also stated: “PHE will work with external experts, independent advisors and stakeholders to consider the results of the review and any suggested recommendations.”

But the experience of the chair of the British Medical Association (BMA), Dr Chaand Nagpaul, suggests this was not the case. “We hadn’t been formally asked for any input. We pro- actively then wrote, and I wrote to Kevin Fenton saying, look, we are the doctors’ union,” he recounted during Eastern Eye’s virtual round-table of medics.

“There’s a serious issue in terms of over 90 per cent of doctors who have died being BAME. We have something to say, that’s why we called for the review. We did give some very, very specific proposals. But it appears that our proposals and those from other organisations did not make it in the final version,” he added.

Eastern Eye has now learnt that the former shadow equalities secretary and Brent Central Labour MP, Dawn Butler, has tabled four written questions for the health and social care secretary, Matt Hancock. Among them is one which suggests the equalities minister may have made errors in her answers.

“To ask the secretary of state for health if they will a) return to the House of Commons to correct their statement that the Public Health England report Covid-19: Review of Disparities and Risks in Outcomes was led by black doctor, Professor Kevin Fenton, when it was in fact led by Professor John Newton? and b) will they place a copy of the corrected statement in the Library?”

The MP also raised the matter in parliament. Using a point of order, Butler said, "On 4 June, the Minister for Equalities, the hon. Member for Saffron Walden misled the House when she made a statement with regard to a Public Health England report. She said that the report was led by the black doctor, Professor Kevin Fenton.

"This was not in fact the case. The minister also misled the House when she said that third-party submissions were not part of the report. I have written to the minister, but I wonder if there is a way that we can compel her to return to the House to correct the record."

Eastern Eye can also reveal that last Friday (5) the MP wrote to the PHE chief executive, Duncan Selbie, asking for a copy of the “third party submissions not included within the final published report”. We understand that she is still waiting for these.

Butler said, “I don’t think the full details of the review have come out yet. We don’t know who actually led the review. We know there were recommendations. Where are they? The equalities minister told the House it was Professor Fenton and made great play she was proud it was someone who was black. Yet the terms of reference makes clear that he did not lead it.

“Who is right? The minister or the press notice? I am concerned MPs, and importantly my concerned constituents, haven’t been given the right or most accurate information. That’s why I’m asking a series of written questions to the health secretary to find out who did what.”

There are also discrepancies in the government’s own website. On May 5, an announcement stated that: “Professor Kevin Fenton, Public Health Director for London will lead the review, supported by a wide group including Trevor Phillips, OBE.”

Eastern Eye asked Public Health England whether the statement in the TOR refers to those who led the PHE review, which was published last Tuesday (2). A spokesman said, “If it is in the press notice, then you can take it as being accurate.”

In a separate move, the former shadow international trade secretary and Brent North Labour MP, Barry Gardiner, has written to the health secretary seeking clarification on the entire review process. In the letter seen by Eastern Eye, Gardiner forensically picks apart what the government said and appears to have done. He believes the government should have done more to make recom- mendations and collect data for the review using the work being carried out by the Race Disparity Audit set up by former prime minister, Theresa May.

“But surely this was precisely what the Race Disparity Audit was set up to do by the then prime minister in 2016? If such action was taken, why does the government now claim that the data required to make recommendations to reduce disparities in risk and outcomes ‘is not routinely collected’?” the MP asks Hancock.

Gardiner told Eastern Eye, “This review was supposed to make recommendations about how to address health inequalities. Instead it regurgitates data to prove what we already know, that such inequalities exist. It is four years since the government set up the Race Disparity Audit. When will they ever get round to doing something about the problem instead of analysing it to death?”

Eastern Eye approached the Department for Health and Social Care and the Government Equalities office for comment, but they declined.

More For You

Parliament backs assisted dying in historic law shift

Supporters of the assisted dying law for terminally ill people hold a banner, on the day British lawmakers are preparing to vote on the bill, in London, Britain, June 20, 2025. REUTERS/Isabel Infantes

Parliament backs assisted dying in historic law shift

PARLIAMENT voted on Friday (20) in favour of a bill to legalise assisted dying, paving the way for the country's biggest social change in a generation.

314 lawmakers voted in favour with 291 against the bill, clearing its biggest parliamentary hurdle.

Keep ReadingShow less
Air India

An Air India Airbus A320-200 aircraft takes off from the Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport in Ahmedabad, India, July 7, 2017. Picture taken July 7, 2017.

Regulator warns Air India over delayed emergency equipment checks: Report

INDIA’s aviation regulator has warned Air India for violating safety rules after three of its Airbus aircraft operated flights without undergoing mandatory checks on emergency escape slides, according to official documents reviewed by Reuters.

The Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) issued warning notices and a detailed investigation report highlighting the breach. These documents were sent days before the recent crash of an Air India Boeing 787-8, in which all but one of the 242 people onboard were killed. The Airbus incidents are unrelated to that crash.

Keep ReadingShow less
assisted dying bill

Pro and anti-assisted dying campaigners protest ahead of a parliamentary decision later today, on June 20, 2025 in London.

Getty Images

MPs to vote on assisted dying bill amid divided views

UK MPs are set to hold a key vote on assisted dying on Friday, which could either advance or halt a proposed law that would allow terminally ill adults to end their lives under strict conditions.

The vote follows several hours of debate in the House of Commons and will decide whether the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill moves to the House of Lords for further scrutiny or is dropped altogether.

Keep ReadingShow less
Zhenhao Zou

Zhenhao Zou, 28, was jailed on Thursday after being found guilty of multiple offences. (Photo: Reuters)

Reuters

Chinese student jailed for life for raping women in UK and China

A CHINESE postgraduate student convicted of drugging and raping 10 women in the UK and China has been sentenced to life imprisonment by a London court.

Zhenhao Zou, 28, was jailed on Thursday after being found guilty of multiple offences. Police say there is evidence he may have targeted more than 50 other women.

Keep ReadingShow less
Air India cuts international flights after deadly crash

Mother (C) of First Officer Clive Kunder, co-pilot of the Air India plane that crashed in Ahmedabad last week, mourns after his mortal remains were brought to his residence, in Mumbai. (PTI Photo)

Air India cuts international flights after deadly crash

AIR INDIA said on Wednesday (18) it will cut international operations on its widebody aircraft by 15 per cent for the next few weeks, citing ongoing safety inspections and operational disruptions following last week's deadly crash of one of its Boeing 787 Dreamliners.

Authorities continue to investigate the crash of flight AI171, which killed 241 people and marked the world's deadliest aviation disaster in a decade.

Keep ReadingShow less