Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Submit Guest Post

Caste in US politics

By Amit Roy

IT IS easy to sympathise with the Pulitzer prize­winning American jour­nalist, Isabel Wilkinson, who has drawn lessons for the US from her per­sonal experiences out­lined in her book, Caste: The Lies That Divide Us (Allen Lane, £20).


On one occasion, when she went to interview a shop owner in Chicago’s Magnificent Mile, the city’s premier commer­cial district, she was told to leave because he was “preparing for an impor­tant appointment with The New York Times”.

This anecdote reminds me of a black colleague whom I won’t name but we sat opposite each oth­er for a number of years. On one occasion he, too, went to interview some­one who rang the office after waiting for a while to complain: “There’s no one here.” All the while, the reporter was standing next to him.

After the Black Lives Matter movement be­came active again in America following the killing of George Floyd, I did wonder whether the race divisions in the country were so deep that the only solution was a partition of the US to create a separate land for African Americans.

Although this is a little far-fetched, Wilkinson has likened the cracks in American society to the caste divisions in India: “Caste is more than rank, it is a state of mind that holds everyone captive, the dominant imprisoned in an illusion of their own entitlement, the subordi­nate trapped in the pur­gatory of someone else’s definition of who they should be.”

Add EasternEye As Your Trusted Source
preferred source on google news

More For You

English identity

MADRID, SPAIN - NOVEMBER 15: Jude Bellingham of England celebrates after the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match between Spain and England at Riyadh Air Metropolitano on November 15, 2026 in Madrid, Spain.

(Photo by Carl Recine/Getty Images)

English identity must be defined by belonging, not race

DO YOU have to be white to be English? Few people watching England’s footballers last Sunday (15) night would doubt that the obvious answer is no. Jude Bellingham was man of the match in this famous English victory over world champions Spain. The iconic back-page sporting image was of goalscorer Ezri Konsa congratulating goalkeeper James Trafford for his match-winning saves in a nail-biting finale. Trafford, of Leeds United, was raised on his family's farm in Cumbria while Konsa, of Arsenal, was born in London to parents from Angola and the Congo. That they represent England together has little novelty value today since the reality of our multi-ethnic England has been a settled fact on the pitch for several decades.

Sporting symbolism helped to entrench a common-sense consensus: research shows the white English reject defining English as just for white people by a thumping eight-to-one margin. Ethnic minorities agree, but a bit less emphatically – by closer to three-to-one. That difference is partly because migrants coming to England have mostly identified as British, not English too, before English-born children and grandchildren more often adopt both. It reflects the damage a vocal toxic minority can do to this work-in-progress of an inclusive England.

Keep ReadingShow less