Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Why politicians and academics should choose their words wisely

By Amit Roy

COMPLETE freedom of expression is fine in theory, but free speech sometimes has to be combined with restraint, especially when you are in a position of responsibility.


This is something that appears to have escaped Imran Khan. A week ago, Pakistan’s prime minister said: “I will never forget how we Pakistanis were embarrassed when the Americans came into Abbottabad and killed Osama bin Laden, martyred him.”

And last week, he told his country’s National Assembly that India was responsible for the terrorist attack on the Karachi Stock Exchange, in which two guards and a policeman were killed, along with the four assailants.

“There is no doubt that India is behind the attack,” he said, without providing any evidence.

“For the last two months my cabinet knew (that there would be an attack). I had informed my minister. All our agencies were on high alert.”

He read out the names of the victims and added: “I’m paying tribute to them because our security forces made a huge sacrifice and fought (the terrorists) and a major tragedy planned by our neighbouring country, India, to destabilize our country was thwarted.”

And then, without thinking about what he was saying, he said the four heavily-armed gunmen had aimed to stage a hostage situation similar to the one in Mumbai, when terrorists had attacked the Bombay Stock Exchange in 2008.

“They had planned to do exactly the same in the (Pakistan) Stock Exchange and murder innocent people to create an atmosphere of unstability (sic) and uncertainty. We have no doubts that this plan was made by India.”

One must wonder whether he thinks of these ideas all by himself or if they are fed to him.

Later, the Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA) linked Majeed Brigade who are supposed to do India’s bidding, claimed responsibility for the Karachi attack.

It is such a pity that the prime minister has become insanely bellicose and not worked to improve relations with India, where he has enjoyed such hospitality and goodwill.

In Britain, one man who has paid the price for not appreciating the fact that free speech does have its limits is the eminent historian David Starkey, 75, who invariably draws attention to himself by being as provocative as possible. But he crossed a line when he said last week:

“Slavery was not genocide, otherwise there wouldn’t be so many damn blacks in Africa or in Britain, would there? An awful lot of them survived.”

Starkey was made to resign as an honorary fellow by Fitzwilliam College, Cambridge, and was also dropped by his publishers.

Meanwhile, Priyamvada Gopal, an Indianorigin don at Cambridge and a fellow at Churchill College, had to explain herself after she tweeted: “White lives don’t matter. As white lives. Abolish whiteness.”

Her tweet came after a banner flown over a Premier League football stadium read “White lives matter Burnley”, which was itself a response to the Black Lives Matter movement.

Gopal later insisted she was not getting at white people personally but at the notion of white supremacy.

The sophistry of her arguments was lost as she was deluged with abusive and threatening comments. Twitter temporarily deleted what Gopal had said initially, as a campaign was started to get her fired from her post.

A tweet from mikhailhakeem told her: “How low caste must your whole bloodline be ……”

Gopal replied: “Here come the casteists, close brothers to white supremacists. Abolish Brahminism now!”

She set out her position: “I’m from a Brahmin family. That makes me a Brahmin. I will say this too then, since Brahmins are the whites of India. Brahmin lives don’t matter – not as ‘Brahmin’ lives. Abolish Brahmins and the upper castes.”

Cambridge University backed Gopal and, as she pointed out, announced her promotion to a full professorship. But perhaps her first tweet was not exactly wise. Dons are better at writing long dissertations laced with qualifications. Twitter just gets them into trouble.

More For You

Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment

Shraddha Jain

Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment

FUNNY UK TOUR

The tidal wave of top Indian stand-up stars touring the UK continues with upcoming shows by Shraddha Jain this July. The hugely popular comedian – who has over a million Instagram followers – will perform her family-friendly show Aiyyo So Mini Things at The Pavilion, Reading (4), the Ondaatje Theatre, London (5), and The Old Rep Theatre, Birmingham (6). The 90-minute set promises an entertaining take on the mundane and uproarious aspects of everyday life.

Keep ReadingShow less
Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment
Doctor Who
Doctor Who

Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment

RANI MAKES RETURNDoctor Who acclaimed actress Archie Panjabi added to her diverse body of work by playing the iconic villain Rani in the recently concluded series of Doctor Who. She reprised the role originally portrayed by Kate O’Mara decades ago. Unfortunately, the series – available on BBC iPlayer – has been plagued by problems and suffered plummeting ratings, largely due to poor storylines. As a result, Archie and fellow cast member Varada Sethu are unlikely to return in future episodes.

Doctor Who


Keep ReadingShow less
Priya Mulji with participants

Priya Mulji with participants at a Thailand retreat

X/ Priya Mulji

Finding my tribe in an unexpected place

Priya Mulji

I turned 43 recently, and it was the best birthday of my life. Special for so many reasons. For the first time since my twenties, I spent my birthday abroad. (In case you were wondering – Phuket, Thailand.)

Last year, I impulsively booked myself onto my friend Urvashi’s mind, body and soul expansion experience. Since then, life has taken some unexpected turns – including being made redundant from my day job – so this trip could not have come at a better time.

Keep ReadingShow less
Comment: Slow progress on inclusion despite anti-racism rallies

Britain faces challenges in changing attitudes around diversity

Comment: Slow progress on inclusion despite anti-racism rallies

IT HAS been five years since the biggest anti-racism protests in a generation – but how far did they have a lasting legacy?

The protests across America after the murder of George Floyd spread to Britain too. There was no central organisation, nor a manifesto of demands, as students and sixth formers took to the streets.

Keep ReadingShow less
Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment
Kumail Nanjiani
Kumail Nanjiani

Eye Spy: Top stories from the world of entertainment

KUMAIL STAND UP

Hollywood actor Kumail Nanjiani has returned to his stand-up comedy roots with a major tour of his show Doing This Again. He is set to perform at Union Chapel in London on September 20. Once the tour concludes, the stand-up special will stream on a major platform. The multi-talented star also has several upcoming projects, including roles in the high-profile films Ella McCay, The Wrong Girls and Driver’s Ed.

Keep ReadingShow less