'Trap' embraces the power of bizarre and unconventional storytelling
The film, starring Josh Hartnett and Ariel Donaghue, doubles down on its unique storytelling approach.
By Eastern EyeAug 06, 2024
INDIAN-American filmmaker M Night Shyamalan believes that audiences crave new ideas, and his approach to capturing their attention is to embrace the "bizarreness" of the stories he tells.
Known for his mastery of suspense and unexpected twists, Shyamalan has now introduced Trap, starring Josh Hartnett, Ariel Donaghue, and his daughter Saleka, which was released in India last week by Warner Bros.
Shyamalan expressed that he holds onto the belief, perhaps naively, that people are eager to experience something new, if only they can be reached.
"I tell my partners at Warner Bros that the unique aspects of the movie are what should be celebrated. We need to double down on how strange and different it is," Shyamalan shared in an interview with PTI.
Trap sees Hartnett playing Cooper Adams, a regular father who is a dreaded serial killer known as 'The Butcher', with Donaughue essaying his teenage daughter Riley.
Asked how difficult it is as a filmmaker to make original movies when most of the Hollywood films are franchises or superhero projects with strong IP (Intellectual Property), the 54-year-old said in such an ecosystem there is no point in making something "usual".
"The other aspect is that you need to sell the bizarreness of the new idea and really tell them why this is a new tone. I have an accent in the way I tell stories. Make sure I have that accent. I used to have conversations with the trailer makers. And I would say 'Don't cut it like it's everyone's movie'. You're stealing the thing that's unique about it. And that's our weapon," he added.
The Puducherry-born filmmaker, who grew up in Pennsylvania, made his breakthrough in Hollywood with The Sixth Sense in 1999, which earned him Oscar nominations for best director and screenplay. He followed it up with hits such as Unbreakable, Signs and The Village.
Then followed a string of poorly reviewed big-budget flops such as Lady in the Water, The Happening, The Last Airbender and After Earth.
Recalling that lean period in his career, Shyamalan said it made him realise the futility of trying to do it "the way the system wanted".
What he did next was something he doesn't recommend to others, but luckily, it worked for him and resurrected his career with "The Visit" (2015).
"I wasn't succeeding, I wasn't happy... I was so unhappy that I went like, 'I'm just going to make a movie. I'm not going to ask anybody. I'm just going to go shoot a movie and mortgage the house. Let's see what happens'.
"And that started this run, through Trap and Servant (series) and all of it. I do not recommend what I did, by the way. But it gave me a fire and an autonomy, which kind of leads to this hyper original (storytelling) that the audience can feel."
In his second innings, the filmmaker has directed Split, Glass, Old, Knock at the Cabin.
In Trap, he has collaborated with musician-daughter Saleka. She plays Lady Raven, a Taylor Swift-like persona, whose concert Cooper is attending with his teenage daughter when he comes to know about the trap set up for him.
Is the movie, with its elaborate musical set-up, the closest he has come to directing a Bollywood-like musical?
"Saleka would say, it's kind of in our genetics. So, doing an entirely music-based movie feels not as strange as you would think. She talks about that a lot and maybe it's there in my head. It's fascinating.
"If I was more fluent in the languages of India, to work from the South... My parents speak Tamil, but if I was more fluent, I would consider doing some version of something. I love it," he said.
Asked about his love for strange ideas, Shyamalan said as a storyteller, he just wants "to know what happens" next.
"On a gut level, the tone and the angle of the story is exciting to me. When I was younger, I probably couldn't have articulated it the way I just did, which is, there's an idea and then an angle to it. I've come to realise you need both before the ignition goes off."
Mostly, the director said, he begins with an idea, and in the case of Trap, it was about a guy trapped at a concert.
"But the angle is you're with him. You're the dad, you love him and you have to figure a way out. That's what made me want to make the movie."
His original name, as per internet, is Mec Nelliyattu Shyamalan. How and when Night became a part of it?
Shyamalan said he chose his middle name when he was 17 or 18, and got the National Merit Scholarship, a government-funded scholarship given to a few students.
"To accept it, I had to be a citizen but I had no middle name. In some ways, I felt like I was inventing myself. I was very much at that time interested in Lakota Indian (a Native American tribe) culture. I read this name (Night). It was actually a woman's name. At the time, it was more about connection to things we don't know and nature, which felt right to me.
"Later, when I ended up living in the thriller genre, it felt, coincidentally, tonally right for what I do for a living. But that wasn't the intention. It felt like a moment of 'Hey, this is your second version of yourself'," he said. (PTI)
Forum brings UK and Chinese film professionals together to explore collaborations.
Emerging British-Asian talent gain mentorship and international exposure.
Small-scale dramas, kids’ shows, and adapting popular formats were the projects everyone was talking about.
Telling stories that feel real to their culture, yet can connect with anyone, is what makes them work worldwide.
Meeting three times a year keeps the UK and China talking, creating opportunities that last beyond one event.
The theatre was packed for the Third Shanghai–London Screen Industry Forum. Between panels and workshops, filmmakers, producers and executives discussed ideas and business cards and it felt more than just a summit. British-Asian filmmakers were meeting and greeting the Chinese industry in an attempt to explore genuine possibilities of working in China’s film market.
UK China film collaborations take off as Third Shanghai London Forum connects British Asian filmmakers with Chinese studios Instagram/ukchinafilm
What makes the forum important for British-Asian filmmakers?
For filmmakers whose films explore identity and belonging, this is a chance to show their work on an international stage, meet Chinese directors, talk co-productions and break cultural walls that normally feel unscalable. “It’s invaluable,” Abid Khan said after a panel, “because you can’t create globally if you don’t talk globally.”
And it’s not just established names. Young filmmakers were all around, pitching ideas and learning on the go. The forum gave them a chance to get noticed with mentoring, workshops, and live pitch sessions.
Which projects are catching international attention?
Micro-dramas are trending. Roy Lu of Linmon International says vertical content for apps is “where it’s at.” They’ve done US, Canada, Australia and next stop, Europe. YouTube is back in focus too, thanks to Rosemary Reed of POW TV Studios. Short attention spans and three-minute hits, she’s ready.
Children’s and sports shows are another hotspot. Jiella Esmat of 8Lions is developing Touch Grass, a football-themed children’s show. The logic is simple: sports and kids content unite families, like global glue.
Then there’s format adaptation. Lu also talked about Nothing But 30, a Chinese series with 7 billion streams. The plan is for an english version in London. Not a straight translation, but a cultural transformation. “‘30’ in London isn’t just words,” Lu says. “It’s a new story.”
Jason Zhang of Stellar Pictures says international audiences respond when culture isn’t just a background prop. Lanterns, flowers, rituals, they’re part of the plot. Cedric Behrel from Trinity CineAsia adds: you need context. Western audiences don’t know Journey to the West, so co-production helps them understand without diluting the story.
Economic sense matters too. Roy Lu stresses: pick your market, make it financially viable. Esmat likens ideal co-productions to a marriage: “Multicultural teams naturally think about what works globally and what doesn’t.”
The UK-China Film Collab’s Future Talent Programme is taking on eight students or recent grads this year. They’re getting the backstage access to international filmmaking that few ever see, including mentorship, festival organising and hands-on experience. Alumni are landing real jobs: accredited festival journalists, Beijing producers, curators at The National Gallery.
Adrian Wootton OBE reminded everyone: “We exist through partnerships, networks, and collaboration.” Yin Xin from Shanghai Media Group noted that tri-annual gathering: London, Shanghai, Hong Kong create an “intensive concentration” of ideas.
Actor-director Zhang Luyi said it best: cultural exchange isn’t telling your story to someone, it’s creating stories together.
The Shanghai-London Screen Industry Forum is no longer just a talking shop. It’s a launchpad, a bridge. And for British-Asian filmmakers and emerging talent, it’s a chance to turn ideas into reality.
By clicking the 'Subscribe’, you agree to receive our newsletter, marketing communications and industry
partners/sponsors sharing promotional product information via email and print communication from Garavi Gujarat
Publications Ltd and subsidiaries. You have the right to withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the
unsubscribe link in our emails. We will use your email address to personalize our communications and send you
relevant offers. Your data will be stored up to 30 days after unsubscribing.
Contact us at data@amg.biz to see how we manage and store your data.