Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

‘Make reciprocity the law’

by Nadeem Badshah

LEADING legal figures have backed calls for British lawyers to be allowed to work in India


after Brexit.

Foreign solicitors and barristers are not allowed to practise in India, which is expected to become a key market after Britain leaves the European Union.

Lord Karan Bilimoria highlighted the issue in the House of Lords in March. He argued that the situation “makes it very difficult for our lawyers to provide advice not just to British companies in India, but also to Indian companies, and that is a huge loss for India and our

British legal services”.

The independent crossbench peer, chair of the UK-India Business Council, said, “from my experience, the UK has arguably the finest legal services in the world. The ability of our lawyers to practise abroad is crucial.”

Bilimoria has been supported in his call for a review of current rules in order to allow two-way arrangements, so Indian and British lawyers have access to each other’s jurisdiction.

Jo Sidhu QC, former president of the Society of Asian Lawyers, told Eastern Eye: “It is no coincidence that international businesses prefer to settle their disputes in London, where they can be guaranteed a fair hearing from independent and impartial judges.

“But global integration and the huge growth of India as a world economic power means

English commercial lawyers need to be able to provide services there too.

“However, every nation operates a closed shop for their legal profession, not just India. Therefore, what we need are reciprocal arrangements to let Indian and English lawyers have access to each other’s jurisdiction.

“It can’t just be one way – as president of the Society of Asian Lawyers, I tried to encourage mutual access whenever and wherever it was possible.

“At the moment, professional regulations prevent this from happening. If we can overcome that hurdle, I can see huge benefits for both countries in a post-Brexit world. It’s now urgent that the leaders of the English and Indian Bars pursue serious negotiations to break

the impasse.”

In England and Wales, similar rules apply as foreign lawyers are not allowed to practise. To attend court, they must be either a solicitor or a barrister qualified to practise in this country.

Tamana Aziz is a business immigration director at Duncan Lewis Solicitors. She told Eastern

Eye: “As we are heading towards Brexit, it is vital for the UK to have a stabilised economy.

“With a number of UK companies operating in India, it is important that UK lawyers are given permission to practise in India so they can advise their clients on foreign law on a temporary and casual basis.

“It is also vital for international commercial arbitration, which involves a party which is not Indian and law that may be foreign.

“If someone wants to practise Indian law in the UK, they can do so by setting up an office here. We are open to Indian lawyers practising in the UK, therefore our lawyers should be given similar opportunities in India.”

Radha Stirling, founder of civil and criminal justice organisation Detained in Dubai, believes a change in the rules could benefit crime victims if they are represented by the same legal team throughout a case.

She said: “I agree with Lord Bilimoria’s sentiments regarding the usefulness of foreign lawyers being allowed to practise in India.

“It is obviously beneficial to victims of abuse if they can be represented by the same legal team throughout their pursuit of justice.

“Handing off a case to a local advocate midstream can be problematic, as well as a cause for delay. Trust and understanding are built between a client and attorney over the course of time.

“Indeed, if a client has been traumatised, it will be very difficult to begin establishing a relationship with a new lawyer who takes the case on weeks or perhaps months into the process.

“I would welcome a relaxing of India’s ban on foreign lawyers practising in the country, both in human rights matters and commercial cases. This serves the interests of justice and best practice, and it is something India’s legal system could be proud of facilitating.”

Meanwhile, Lord Goldsmith QC called on the Indian government to delay amendments to the arbitration law, warning they could “set back the cause of Indian arbitration” by a generation.

In a speech in Delhi in February, he expressed concern about proposals that would require an arbitrator to be qualified as an Indian advocate with 10 years of practice experience.

Such provisions “would appear at a stroke to prohibit the appointment of foreign lawyers as arbitrators in Indian seated arbitrations,” he said.

While some changes in the new bill are “welcome”, Goldsmith said there was international concern over provisions for a new body, the Indian Council of Arbitration, which will not merely promote arbitration but also “regulate it”.

A Ministry of Justice spokesman said: “We are already in discussions with the Indian government to improve mutual market access for legal services.”

More For You

Air India

The Amritsar-Birmingham and Amritsar-London Gatwick routes will each increase from three to four weekly flights, while Ahmedabad-London Gatwick will go from three to five weekly flights.

Air India to increase flights between UK and India from March 30

AIR INDIA will increase flight frequencies on key routes as part of its Northern Summer schedule, effective 30 March 2025.

In the UK, the airline will add three more flights on the Delhi-London Heathrow route, increasing from 21 to 24 weekly flights using a mix of A350-900 and upgraded B787-9 aircraft.

Keep ReadingShow less
Pablo-Escobar-merchandise-Getty

Escobar, killed by security forces in 1993, remains a figure of global interest, with his image appearing on souvenirs like T-shirts, mugs, and keychains. (Photo: Getty Images)

Colombia considers ban on Pablo Escobar merchandise

COLOMBIA’s Congress is considering a bill that would ban the sale of merchandise featuring drug lord Pablo Escobar and other convicted criminals.

The proposed law aims to curb the glorification of Escobar, who was responsible for thousands of deaths during his time leading the Medellín cartel, reported BBC.

Keep ReadingShow less
Assisted dying bill: Judge approval scrapped for expert panel safeguard

Polls show most Britons back assisted dying, with supporters calling for the law to reflect public opinion.

Assisted dying bill: Judge approval scrapped for expert panel safeguard

Eastern Eye

THE proposed new assisted dying law for terminally ill people will be amended to remove the requirement that a high court judge sign off on each case, Labour MP Kim Leadbeater said on Tuesday (11).

Opponents of assisted dying said the change would weaken the safeguards around protecting vulnerable people from being coerced or pressured into taking their own lives.

Keep ReadingShow less
Andrew Malkinson

Malkinson, 59, has been struggling financially since his release and has been on universal credit for 19 months. (Photo: X/@NotThatBigIan)

Wrongful rape conviction: Andrew Malkinson to get 'significant' compensation

ANDREW MALKINSON, who spent 17 years in prison for a rape he did not commit, will receive a six-figure interim compensation payment from the Ministry of Justice.

The payment comes more than a year after his conviction was overturned by the Court of Appeal in July 2023.

Keep ReadingShow less
IMF team visits Pakistan to assess governance and corruption reforms

The assessment will shape structural reforms and examine protections for property rights and foreign investments

IMF team visits Pakistan to assess governance and corruption reforms

Eastern Eye

A TECHNICAL team from the International Monetary Fund met Pakistan’s chief justice Yahya Afridi on Tuesday (11) to conduct a Governance and Corruption Diagnostic Assessment under the 2024 Extended Fund Facility programme.

The IMF team is in the country for a week-long trip to scrutinise the judicial and regulatory framework tackling governance and corruption as part of a £5.6 billion loan agreed last year.

Keep ReadingShow less