• Saturday, September 30, 2023


US should deny assistance to Pakistan, says Trump’s former advisor

Former American national security adviser HR McMaster (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)

By: Chandrashekar Bhat

A FORMER US national security advisor has said America should not provide any fresh aid to Pakistan as it has “had it both ways” for too long. 

General (retired) HR McMaster, who advised former US president Donald Trump, said America should hold Pakistan prime minister Imran Khan accountable for his comments apparently hailing the Taliban.

When the insurgents were taking over Afghanistan in August, Khan is reported to have said the Taliban were “breaking the chains of slavery”.

Testifying before a Congressional committee on Afghanistan, McMaster said, “Why should we send a dime to Pakistan under any conditions?

“I think that they should be confronted with international isolation because of their support for jihadist terrorists, who are threats to humanity, including the Haqqani network, the Taliban, and groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba”

It is also delusional, he claimed, to think that any of the money that would go to the Taliban or through the Taliban for humanitarian purposes would immediately be used by the Taliban to solidify their power and to become an even greater threat.

“So, we’re in a situation where we’re facing a really extraordinary dilemma that it’s going to be tough for us to mitigate the humanitarian crisis without empowering the Taliban,” he said in response to a question.

“I don’t think we should give any assistance to Pakistan at all. Pakistan has had it both ways for way too long; it should be confronted with its behaviour over the years that has actually resulted, I think, in large measure in this outcome,” McMaster said.

When Trump was president, the US blocked security assistance to Pakistan. Current president Joe Biden has not yet resumed the security aid to Islamabad. Biden is also yet to speak to Khan.

“I think we ought to hold Imran Khan responsible for his comments when Kabul fell. He said the Afghan people have been unshackled. Why should we send a dime to Pakistan under any conditions? I think that they should be confronted with international isolation because of their support for jihadist terrorists, who are threats to humanity, including the Haqqani network, the Taliban, and groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba,” McMaster said.

To a question from Congressman Scott Perry during the hearing convened by the House Foreign Affairs Committee, McMaster also said “it is a good idea” to remove Pakistan’s status as a major non-NATO ally.

“The only time we have ever laid out a very clear and realistic assessment of south Asia and prioritised the strategy was president Trump’s speech in August of 2017.

“Now, he abandoned it and he doubled down on the flaws of the Obama administration. I don’t know how that happened. But if you go back to that August 2017 speech, that was the proper approach to Pakistan as well, which called for a suspension of all assistance to Pakistan until Pakistan fundamentally changed its behaviour,” McMaster said.

Congressman Bill Keating said Pakistan remains a problem and the US needs to assess it.

“Its long-standing activities, by many accounts, have been negative. I think that’s putting it mildly. For decades, though, for decades, whether you go back to ’96 when the Taliban took control, Pakistan was one of the first to recognise them,” he said.

“When you go through the change in 2001 in Afghanistan and then the reconstruction of the Taliban starting around 2005, they were there giving assistance, by all accounts, and I believe those accounts are accurate. And indeed, right up into this current change in the government, Pakistan, there were many people that suggested their intelligence was embedded with them,” Keating said.

Pakistan’s relationship with the Haqqani network is one of concern.

“That may indeed affect our relations with India in that respect. But can you comment on that? I think they have been duplicitous, not just recently, not just in the few months of this administration, but for decades in this with many administrations, Republican and Democratic alike,” he said.

Former US Ambassador to Pakistan Ryan Croker acknowledged that Pakistan worked against the US “in some very fundamental aspects” with their support for the Taliban.

“Earlier, I tried to present their narrative as to why. We were going to walk out, and they did not want to be left with the Taliban as a mortal enemy. They may get that anyway. And as satisfying as it would be to a lot of us, myself included, to do something to punish Pakistan for this, I don’t think we have the luxury. They are already worried over the repercussions inside their own country of the Taliban’s so-called victory in Afghanistan,” he said.

“Now, we can say, ‘Yeah. Well, they deserve whatever they get’. But again, a blow-up in Kashmir is going to bring a regional war. So, I think reassessment is always good, but let’s reassess with a clear eye on the dangers now that the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan has created throughout the region. We do not need a completely destabilised Pakistani state with nuclear weapons,” Croker said.

McMaster also told the lawmakers the Taliban was backed by Pakistan’s ISI (Inter Services Intelligence) and that’s why they recaptured Afghanistan.


Eastern Eye

Related Stories

Eastern Eye


Mrunal Thakur on Dhamaka, experience of working with Kartik Aaryan,…
Nushrratt Bharuccha on Chhorii, pressure of comparison with Lapachhapi, upcoming…
Abhimanyu Dassani on Meenakshi Sundareshwar, how his mom Bhagyashree reacted…