Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Football commentary box lacks diversity, only two are BAME in Premier League

Football commentary box lacks diversity, only two are BAME in Premier League

There has been a conscious attempt in the recent years to make football diverse in every aspect, and it gathered steam during last season in the sport's fight against racism.

But curiously, the commentary box lacks diversity and according to a report by Sportsmail, which has found out that of 37 commentators employed by the four Premier League rights holders this season - only two are from BAME communities.


Mark Scott and Seb Hutchinson are the two freelancers working across multiple channels.

Mark Scott made history as the first BAME commentator on Match of the Day when covering a goalless draw between Bournemouth and Crystal Palace in 2015. Earlier this month he achieved another career first by commentating a live game for the BBC.

Scott, who has a Trinidadian mother and English father says visibility can play a huge role like it did in the case of female commentators such as Vicki Sparks and Robyn Cowen since Jacqui Oatley made her Match of the Day debut in 2007.

"It's become a cliche that 'You can't be what you can't see' but it applies in this case. Jacqui really inspired girls and young women to get into commentary, but we're rarely on screen and not noticed. When you see the names Mark Scott and Seb Hutchinson appear on the TV they don't scream out that we're from ethnic minority backgrounds," Scott said.

Hutchinson, who was the first black commentator to work for BT Sport and ITV, says there are other structural problems in the industry.

"There's an anomaly in football, which is a meritocracy on the pitch but not off it," he said.

"Outside of ex-players there are hardly any black people working in TV at all. I've been at outside broadcasts with hundreds of people as the only black face.

"At the bottom it's not very well paid so it's more difficult for those from working-class backgrounds to take the risk. And those who do tend to have contacts within the industry, which increases the likelihood of favouritism," he added.

More For You

Instagram removes DM encryption from today: What users should do to stay safe

Meta can’t read WhatsApp messages, but it can see who you talk to, when, and how often and use that data for ads and recommendations

iStock

Instagram removes DM encryption from today: What users should do to stay safe

Highlights

  • Instagram switches off end-to-end encryption just before federal deepfake law enforcement begins.
  • Meta can now read private messages it previously could not access.
  • Privacy experts warn against storing downloaded chats in Google Drive or iCloud.
Instagram is removing a privacy feature from May 8 that previously stopped the company from accessing the content of users’ direct messages.
The change comes just days before a new US federal law requires platforms to scan and remove harmful content.
The change affects users who turned on Instagram's end-to-end encryption option for direct messages.
Most Instagram users never switched on this feature, according to digital privacy expert Harry Maugans. For the small number who did, the protection ends on May 8.

End-to-end encryption works like a sealed envelope. The platform can see who sent a message and who received it, but cannot open it to read what is inside.

When Instagram removes this feature, it effectively removes the privacy layer that kept messages hidden. As a result, Meta would be able to access the content of those messages.

Keep ReadingShow less