Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

The 'Chhaava' controversy: A Bollywood film's portrayal of Aurangzeb and Sambhaji sparks communal tensions

Historical inaccuracies and political polarisation fuel heated debates across India.

Actor Vicky Kaushal

Actor Vicky Kaushal plays Sambhaji in Chhaava

There have been calls for Indians to learn their history from books rather than ill-informed WhatsApp messages, after a Bollywood film featuring the Mughal emperor Aurangzeb triggered communal tensions in parts of the country. The film is called Chhaava – meaning "lion cub" – in which 40 minutes out of 136 are dedicated to depicting how Aurangzeb tortures and finally executes Sambhaji Maharaj, a valiant Hindu ruler.

Sambhaji is the lion cub in question because he is the son of the great Maratha leader, Shivaji, who has a devoted following in the state of Maharashtra. After watching Chhaava, a Hindu viewer in Gujarat tore down the cinema screen. Multiple videos circulating on social media show viewers, including children, crying and shouting anti-Aurangzeb (and anti-Muslim) slogans. Subtlety is not the film’s main strength.


The real Aurangzeb, the sixth Mughal emperor



Sambhaji, taken captive, rejects Aurangzeb’s offer to spare his life if he converts to Islam. Salt is rubbed into his wounds, his fingernails are pulled out, his eyes pierced with hot iron rods, and body parts cut off one by one. An epilogue tells viewers that the Mughal empire eventually collapses and India finally gains freedom. The filmmakers, who are no doubt delighted that Chhaava has been doing well at the box office, do not see it as their duty to paint the shades and nuances of Indian history. Since its release on February 14, Chhaava has received mixed reviews from critics but drawn criticism for historical inaccuracies.


It is a fact that Aurangzeb, had he been alive today, would probably have considered Reform leader Nigel Farage, for example, as hopelessly liberal. During his long reign, Aurangzeb practiced an assertive and frequently violent brand of Islam. Inevitably, there have been demands for the destruction of his tomb, though by Mughal standards, it is a simple one. The process of renaming roads and places that honour Aurangzeb has already begun and will continue.

Protesters burn a poster of Aurangzeb demanding the removal of his tomb in Nagpur in March


Two Hindu groups, the Bajrang Dal and Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), have engaged in anti-Aurangzeb demonstrations in Pune, Kolhapur, Nashik, Malegaon, Nagpur, Ahilyanagar, and other parts of Maharashtra. During the protest in Kolhapur, the VHP destroyed a mock tomb, while the Bajrang Dal demonstrated in Pune with a hammer and (Hindu) slogans of “Jai Shri Ram”. Nagpur, the third-largest city in Maharashtra, has witnessed violent communal clashes, leaving more than 30 people injured, hours after Hindu outfits held a protest demanding the removal of Aurangzeb’s tomb.


Indians are an emotional people whose passions are easily aroused, especially by politicians who rely on communal vote banks. How to tackle difficult periods of Indian history in films, books, and works of art is a tricky business. One newspaper, The Hindu (despite its name, it has nothing to do with religion), commented: “When history in cinema becomes merely a tool to evoke anger, disgust, and hatred, it robs us of understanding history in all its complexity. Chhaava’s world of Hindus versus Muslims/Indian versus foreigner is far from the real 17th century.

Akshaye Khanna as Aurangzeb


Chhaava
does have the laudable goal of setting the historical record straight about Sambhaji as a great warrior and administrator against biased accounts. But it becomes harmful national-level propaganda when it is fixated on the good Hindu versus the bad Muslim binary, skips some incontrovertible facts, and is in complete sync with the ruling (Bharatiya Janata Party) party’s ideology.
“Thus, it joins the cohort of over 20 blatant propaganda films made recently, such as The Kashmir Files, The Kerala Story, The Vaccine War, Article 370, Bastar – The Naxal Story, Swatantrya Veer Savarkar, JNU: Jahangir National University, The Sabarmati Report, and Samrat Prithviraj.“And Chhaava, like some others, was endorsed by the prime minister (Narendra Modi) and other ministers, and made tax-free in certain BJP-ruled states.”

Raj Thackeray

So who was Aurangzeb, and why is he such a divisive figure in Indian history?
There could not be a greater contrast between him and Akbar, the third of the Mughal emperors who took a number of Hindu wives and went out of his way to ensure his brand of Islam and his reign were inclusive. Muhi al-Din Muhammad (November 3, 1618 – March 3, 1707), commonly known by the title Aurangzeb and also as Alamgir I, was the sixth Mughal emperor, reigning from 1658 until his death at the age of 88.

His father, Shah Jahan, best known for building the Taj Mahal, wanted his more progressive eldest son, Dara Shikoh, to succeed him. But there was no Mughal tradition of primogeniture, the systematic passing of rule, upon an emperor’s death, to his eldest son. Instead, it was customary for sons to overthrow their father and for brothers to murder each other to get the throne. Which is what happened.

On August 10, 1659, Dara was executed on grounds of apostasy and his head was sent to Shah Jahan. Aurangzeb had another brother, Prince Murad Baksh, apparently an ally, held for murder, judged, and then executed. Having secured his position, Aurangzeb confined his frail father at Agra Fort, where he was cared for by his daughter Jahanara, and died in 1666.
Under Aurangzeb’s reign, the Mughal empire spanned nearly the entirety of the Indian subcontinent. His tomb is located in Khuldabad, Aurangabad district, in Maharashtra. At his own direction, he was buried in an unmarked grave at the complex of the dargah or shrine of Sheikh Zainuddin, a Sufi who was his “spiritual and religious teacher.”

Chhaava is a Bollywood interpretation of Aurangzeb’s conflict with Sambhaji, who was born on May 14, 1657, at Purandar fort. He became the second Chhatrapati (ruler) of the Maratha Empire after his father, Shivaji, the great warrior, died in 1680.
Sambhaji Maharaj ruled from 1681 to 1689, continuing the Maratha struggle against the Mughals. After initial successes, he was captured by Aurangzeb in 1689, and brutally executed. He is remembered for his courage and resilience, refusing to convert to Islam even under torture.

In Chhaava, Aurangzeb is played by the actor Akshaye Khanna, and Sambhaji by Vicky Kaushal. One critic said Khanna had “a chilling, restrained portrayal of Aurangzeb and that his silent menace is a contrast to Kaushal’s fiery energy.”
“Aurangzeb has been a deeply polarizing figure in Maharashtra, and controversies surrounding the Mughal ruler keep cropping up in the state’s political discourse frequently,” was the restrained comment from India Today magazine. In the Maharashtra state assembly, one member provoked outrage by delivering a positive judgment on Aurangzeb.

Abu Azmi was suspended from the assembly after claiming that certain aspects of the movie Chhaava were historically inaccurate and that Aurangzeb was a “good administrator.” “I don’t consider Aurangzeb a cruel ruler – wrong history is being shown (in Chhaava),” he said. “Aurangzeb built several temples.” A Muslim cleric, Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi, the national president of the All India Muslim Jammat Dargah Aala Hazrat, has written to India’s home minister, Amit Shah, urging him to take legal action against the filmmakers.

His arguments were not unreasonable: “The atmosphere of the country is deteriorating since the release of Chhaava. Hindu youth have been incited and provoked by showing Aurangzeb as anti-Hindu. This is the reason why leaders of Hindu organizations are giving hate speeches against Aurangzeb.” Although he has been a nationalist leader in the past, Raj Thackeray, leader of the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena, told people caught up in the Aurangzeb controversy: “Hindus who feel awakened after a movie are of no use.

“Did you learn about Sambhaji Maharaj’s sacrifice because of Vicky Kaushal and about Aurangzeb because of Akshaye Khanna? Stop reading history on WhatsApp and delve into history books. People are made to fight in the name of history.”
He added: “History should not be viewed through the prism of caste and religion. We have forgotten the real issues of the present time.”

More For You

Glowborne

Each character in the set has been carefully designed to reflect cultural narratives

Glowborne

Anika Chowdhury reimagines chess with Glowborne, reviving its South Asian and East African origins

Highlights:

  • British-Bangladeshi prop maker Anika Chowdhury has designed a handcrafted glow-in-the-dark chess set celebrating heritage and identity.
  • The limited-edition set, called Glowborne, launches on Kickstarter in October.
  • Each piece draws from South Asian, Middle Eastern, and African cultural references, re-rooting chess in its origins.
  • The project blends art, storytelling, and representation, aiming to spark conversations about identity in play.

Reimagining chess through heritage

When Anika Chowdhury sat down to sculpt her first chess piece, she had a bigger vision than simply redesigning a classic game. A British-Bangladeshi prop maker working in the film industry, she grew up loving fantasy and games but rarely saw faces like hers in Western storytelling.

“Chess originated in India, travelled through Arabia and North Africa, and was later Westernised,” she explains. “I wanted to bring those forgotten origins back to the board.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Piranhas’ police box

The piece was originally one of nine works that appeared across London in August 2024

Getty Images

Banksy’s ‘Piranhas’ police box heads to London Museum

Highlights:

  • Banksy’s ‘Piranhas’ artwork, painted on a police sentry box, is being stored ahead of display at London Museum.
  • The piece was originally one of nine works that appeared across London in August 2024.
  • It will form part of the museum’s new Smithfield site, opening in 2026.
  • The City of London Corporation donated the artwork as part of its £222m museum relocation project.

Banksy’s police box artwork in storage

A Banksy artwork known as Piranhas has been placed in storage ahead of its future display at the London Museum’s new Smithfield site, scheduled to open in 2026. The piece features spray-painted piranha fish covering the windows of a police sentry box, giving the illusion of an aquarium.

From Ludgate Hill to Guildhall Yard

The police box, which had stood at Ludgate Hill since the 1990s, was swiftly removed by the City of London Corporation after Banksy confirmed authorship. It was initially displayed at Guildhall Yard, where visitors could view it from behind safety barriers. The Corporation has since voted to donate the piece to the London Museum.

Keep ReadingShow less
viral qawwali group UK tour

The group have introduced fresh orchestral elements and added instruments to expand their live sound

Qawwal Group

Shahbaz Fayyaz Qawwal Group brings viral energy and rich heritage to UK tour

Highlights:

  • The Shahbaz Fayyaz Qawwal Group return to the UK with a nationwide tour after viral success online.
  • The ensemble of brothers blend centuries-old qawwali traditions with fresh improvisations that connect with young audiences.
  • From Pakistan to the USA and UK, their performances have won acclaim for their electrifying energy and spiritual depth.
  • Fans can expect new instruments, reimagined classics, and the same message of love and harmony at this year’s shows.

From viral sensation to global stages

When a performance goes viral, it can change an artist’s career overnight. For the Shahbaz Fayyaz Qawwal Group, their stirring renditions of Bhar Do Jholi and B Kafara propelled them from local fame in Pakistan to global recognition, amassing millions of views across platforms. What set them apart was not just the power of their voices, but the way their music resonated with younger listeners who were hearing qawwali with fresh ears.

That viral momentum soon carried them beyond borders, leading to major performances in the United States and the UK. “It wasn’t just one track,” the group explained. “We revived older gems like Kali Kali Zulfon and Dil Pukare Aaja in our own style, and those went viral again, showing that qawwali still speaks across generations.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Navratri gets a global tune with Gujarati–British folk fusion

Navratri gets a global tune with Gujarati–British folk fusion

Mahesh Liloriya

This Navratri, the traditional rhythms of Garba are being paired with the timeless melodies of British folk in a new musical fusion that promises to bring fresh energy to the festival.

The piece blends the iconic Gujarati folk song Kon Halave Limdi Ne Kon Halave Pipdi with the classic English–Celtic ballad Scarborough Fair. It is performed as a duet by Gujarati folk singer Kashyap Dave and Western classical vocalist Vanya Bhatt, a graduate of Christ University, Bengaluru.

Keep ReadingShow less
Tarek Amin

A visual dialogue between flesh and spirit

Manzu Islam

Tarek Amin's 'Echoes of Existence' showcases bodies caught in time and reaching for escape

Manzu Islam

Highlights:

  • Woodcut prints that explore the fragile threshold between body, time, and transcendence
  • Inspired by Baul mystics like Lalon Shai and Shah Abdul Karim, as well as sculptural forms from Michelangelo to Rodin
  • Figures emerge from black holes and womb-like voids — trapped in time yet reaching for freedom
  • A visual dialogue between flesh and spirit, rootedness and flight
  • A bold continuation of South Asian metaphysical traditions in contemporary form
  • Paradox becomes the path: muscular bodies dream of escape through light, memory, and love
  • Expressionist in tone, haunting in imagery — a theatre of becoming


I imagine Tarek Amin (Ruhul Amin Tarek) has a singular vision as his hands work on his craft, his measuring eyes, the membranes of his fingers. They are mostly woodcut prints on the threshold of becoming, from darkened holes. A human figure dangling in space, yet not without gravitational pull, the backwards tilt of the head is like a modern-day high jumper in the fall position, the muscles and ribcage straining to keep the body's mass afloat. A clock is ticking away in the background of a darkened rectangle. Is it the black hole, the womb, or the nothingness from which the first murmurings of being, its tentative emergence into light, can be heard?

Keep ReadingShow less