Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Art of retrieving treasures

by NADEEM BADSHAH

BRITAIN’S museums have been urged by a campaign group to return “colonial” treasures to countries including India, instead of just relabelling them.


Leading institutions in the UK are hiring staff to revisit their colonial- era collections.

The Victoria and Albert Museum (V&A) in London recently employed a ‘provenance and spoliation research curator”, while the British Museum is adding new research into its audio guides and striving for “very honest” labels on items such as the Hindu statues it houses.

The Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford is advertising for a research assistant on a salary of £32,236- £39,609 to manage a labelling project to “identify and find ways to redress a range of ethical issues in the current displays”.

However, the India Pride Project, a group set up by art enthusiasts to identify artefacts that were taken, said the move does not go far enough, and wants treasures from the Empire era to be returned.

Anuraag Saxena, a founder of the project, told Eastern Eye: “We shouldn’t have to prove what was ours for centuries. Museums need to prove their right to own our heritage.

“Lip service about ‘transparency’ is pointless, unless museums are ready to acknowledge the violent circumstances under which each piece of heritage was extracted from India.

“Faith objects were not meant to be show pieces.

“The key word is consent. Heritage acquired under duress is as illegitimate as the act of duress itself.”

He added: “You haven’t really decolonised a nation unless you’ve given back what was theirs.

“We’re not asking for much. Just to do what’s morally right.”

“We need a ‘coalition of the colonised’ – ordinary citizens demanding back what was always theirs.

“Academics categorise this issue under archaeology or faith or artcrimes. It really is

not that trivial. It’s about repairing a squalid, oppressive and bloodied past.”

The Indian government has long demanded that the British hand over the 105.6 carat Kohinoor diamond it took after the Anglo-Sikh wars in the 1840s. Britain has insisted

that the diamond was a “gift.”

Rajinder Dudrah, professor of cultural studies and creative industries at Birmingham City University, said the campaign from India to have historical pieces returned is due to “cultural identity, but in the current moment, [it is also] heritage and tourism”.

He told Eastern Eye: “It has benefitted countries in western centres, fuelling tourism in London and the US for example.

“India would like a bit of their history back and enhance their world-level resources.

“[Relabelling artefacts] a good first step but a lot needs to be done. They will claim it was cultural circumstances in the colonial era, but who owns it in principle?

“They are treading very carefully but the compensation needs to go much further due to legal ramifications and international relations.

“It could have a domino effect and be a test case for other nations around the world like Pakistan, Bangladesh and Latin America.”

Last year, academics hit back at V&A museum director Tristram Hunt who claimed returning treasures to countries would be “historically wrong and inaccurate”.

He said giving back colonial artefacts would be a denial of history as he discussed items from the East India Company which form part of the museum’s collections.

On the relabelling, Hunt said: “Through exhibitions, conservation work, provenance research, talks, and events, the V&A is committed to exploring our own colonial history

with rigour and transparency – and to building platforms for collaboration around the world.”

The British Museum said it has “not received any official requests about returning objects to India”.

It added: “The museum has gained these objects in many ways – as gifts, through collectors, excavations or sold with conscious intent.”

More For You

Modi meets Vance, family in Paris

Narendra Modi in a group picture with US vice president JD Vance and his wife Usha Vance and their children Ewan and Vivek, at Elysee Palace in Paris. (ANI Photo)

Modi meets Vance, family in Paris

US vice president JD Vance and Indian prime minister Narendra Modi spoke on Tuesday (11) about how the US can assist India in diversifying its energy sourcing through investments in US nuclear technology, the White House said.

The meeting between Vance and Modi in Paris, where they were both attending an artificial intelligence summit, came ahead of the prime minister's US visit later this week in which topics like trade, investment, technology and immigration are expected to be discussed.

Keep ReadingShow less
Heathrow to submit third runway proposal by summer

A British Airways passenger plane takes off behind houses next to land earmarked for a third runway at Longford near Heathrow Airport. REUTERS/Toby Melville

Heathrow to submit third runway proposal by summer

LONDON's Heathrow Airport, one of the world's busiest hubs, will submit its proposal for a third runway to the British government by summer, its chief executive Thomas Woldbye will say in a speech on Wednesday (12).

The move comes after chancellor Rachel Reeves said last month the government would back the construction of a new runway at Heathrow to boost trade and economic growth.

Keep ReadingShow less
trump-musk-

Musk, standing alongside Trump in the Oval Office with his 4-year-old son, said he was leading the effort to cut government waste. (Photo: Getty Images)

Trump, Musk move to cut federal workforce under new order

US PRESIDENT Donald Trump has directed federal agencies to work with Elon Musk to identify government jobs that can be cut and functions that can be eliminated.

The move is part of an effort to reduce the federal workforce and align it with Trump’s policy priorities.

Keep ReadingShow less
Ed-Miliband-India

Miliband said his meetings with Indian officials reinforced the commitment to work together in key areas, including grid modernisation, offshore wind, and industrial decarbonisation.

Exclusive: UK-India energy partnership strengthens as Miliband backs clean transition

BRITAIN sees India as a “crucial partner” as both countries aim to deepen their cooperation on clean energy, with a focus on renewables and climate action, UK secretary of state for energy security and net zero, Ed Miliband, said.

On a visit to India this week, Miliband highlighted India’s ambitious renewable energy targets and its commitment to achieving net zero by 2070.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bangladesh's former government accused of 'crimes against humanity'

Sheikh Hasina (Photo credit: Getty Images)

Bangladesh's former government accused of 'crimes against humanity'

BANGLADESH's former government was behind systematic attacks and killings of protesters as it strived to hold onto power last year, the UN said Wednesday (12), warning the abuses could amount to "crimes against humanity".

Before premier Sheikh Hasina was toppled in a student-led revolution last August, her government oversaw a systematic crackdown on protesters and others, including "hundreds of extrajudicial killings", the UN said.

Keep ReadingShow less