Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

US elections: Work in progress

By Amit Roy

THE United States of America may be the most powerful country in the world but compared to India, its system of democra­cy does seem to be a work in progress.


American and British correspondents gushed that turnout in the 2020 US presi­dential election was the highest for over a century. In a country with 239.2 million people eligible to vote, the turnout was 66.9 per cent, the highest since 1900 when it was 73.7 per cent.

I looked up the figures for India and discovered that in the 2019 general elec­tion, with 911 million Indians eligible to vote, the turnout was 67.36, one per cent more than in 2014. This is remarkable giv­en the level of poverty, illiteracy and a large rural population in India.

What is also remarkable is the speed with which the votes are counted in India, where losers accept the result without go­ing through the “I was robbed” routine.

Americans also have this baffling elec­toral college which interposes an unneces­sary barrier between the voter and their choice of president.

This is only partly a joke, but perhaps the Americans should hand over the run­ning of their elections to India because they seem unable to do it themselves.

More For You

Shabana Mahmood

Home secretary Shabana Mahmood was born in Britain of parents who came from Mirpur. (Photo: Getty Images)

Politics of grooming gangs

Sir Keir Starmer was never keen on an inquiry specifically on Pakistani grooming gangs. The prime minister wants to be protective of the wider Pakistani community in the UK. The last thing he wants is an Islamophobic report which states that for cultural and religious reasons, Muslim Pakistan men have been targeting vulnerable white children and young women. But this is precisely the conclusion that some of the survivors and other groups want.

The Labour leadership was already in trouble with some Pakistani voters who felt it was not sufficiently critical of Israel’s military approach in the Gaza war. Starmer would not want to alienate them further with a report that picks out only Pakistanis when it comes to sexual abuse. It would be preferable to have a report that acknowledges that while there has been an historic problem with Pakistani grooming gangs in places such as Rotherham and Rochdale, white men are involved, too, in bigger numbers across the UK as a whole.

Keep ReadingShow less