UK got richer at India's expense, Russia says, rubbishes British colonial rule's 'positive impact' on Asia
Citing a study published by economic anthropologists Jason Hickel and Dylan Sullivan, Russia accused the UK and its former prime minister Sir Winston Churchill of starving Indians to death.
Amid its growing confrontation with the West, particularly in the wake of the intervention in Ukraine, Russia has slammed the UK saying the latter caused "real damage to the people of India" with its colonial policies and caused millions of deaths.
Russia's foreign ministry said this on Saturday (14) while weighing in on Britain's colonial past.
Moscow noted that more than 100 million people in India "fell victim" to London's draconian policies as it ruled the country between 1880-1920, the period it said was the "peak of the British colonial rule in India" that brought misery and suffering to the people of the south Asian nation.
India became independent on August 15, 1947, after the British ruled the country for nearly two centuries.
Sir Winston Churchill in 1950 (Photo by OFF/AFP via Getty Images)
The Russian ministry was referring to the statistics cited in a scholarly study which has been published by economic anthropologists Jason Hickel and Dylan Sullivan.
It accused its adversary Britain of looting and plundering India during its rule and berated then British prime minister Sir Winston Churchill's colonial policies related to India.
In a statement published on Telegram and the Kremlin's official site, the foreign ministry said nearly 165 million deaths took place in India between 1880 and 1920 and the British stole trillions of dollars of wealth from that country. It also rubbished the alleged "positive impact" of the British colonial rule in Asia as promoted by pro-western analysts on social media platforms.
During British colonial rule in India, the country's death rate increased from 37.2 per 1,000 in the 1880s to 44.2 per 1,000 in the 1910s and the life expectancy of Indians went down from 26.7 years to 21.9 years, Russia said citing the study by Hickel and Sullivan.
This, according to Russia, was because millions of Indians died because of the anthropogenic famine "engineered by the British" in the then Bengal of 1943.
"That humanitarian catastrophe was a direct result of the decisions by the colonial administration and personally British prime minister Winston Churchill, who ordered for grain to be shipped out of India to cover the needs of the home country," said the foreign ministry.
Russia accused the UK of "starving Indians to death".
Moscow, which is one of India's time-tested allies in the world, also took on Churchill for his views of the Indians.
"Winston Churchill’s statements about the horrifying developments in Bengal look openly racist," the Russian foreign ministry said.
Quoting Churchill's wordings, it said, "I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion."
Also accusing the UK of looting Indian wealth during colonial rule, Russia supported the analysis of the Indian economist Utsa Patnaik.
The British empire siphoned out £9.2 trillion ($45 trillion) of wealth from India, the Russian ministry said.
The evidence listed in academic journals clearly shows how the UK "got wealthier at the expense of India, and how they exploited and caused the deaths of [Indians] whom they deeply despised," Russia said.
Dr Malhotra, an advisor to US health secretary Robert F Kennedy's Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) Action, also serves as Chief Medical Advisor to Make Europe Healthy Again, where he campaigns for wider access to vaccine information.
Dr Aseem Malhotra, a British Asian cardiologist, and research psychologist Dr Andrea Lamont Nazarenko have called on medical bodies to issue public apologies over Covid vaccine mandates, saying they have contributed to public distrust and conspiracy theories.
In a commentary published in the peer-reviewed journal Science, Public Health Policy and the Law, the two argue that public health authorities must address the shortcomings of Covid-era policies and acknowledge mistakes.
They note that while early pandemic decisions were based on the best available evidence, that justification cannot continue indefinitely.
“Until the most urgent questions are answered, nothing less than a global moratorium on Covid-19 mRNA vaccines — coupled with formal, unequivocal apologies from governments and medical bodies for mandates and for silencing truth seekers — will suffice,” they write.
Dr Malhotra, an advisor to US health secretary Robert F Kennedy's Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) Action, also serves as Chief Medical Advisor to Make Europe Healthy Again, where he campaigns for wider access to vaccine information.
In the article titled Mandates and Lack of Transparency on COVID-19 Vaccine Safety has Fuelled Distrust – An Apology to Patients is Long Overdue, the authors write that science must remain central to public health.
“The pandemic demonstrated that when scientific integrity is lacking and dissent is suppressed, unethical decision-making can become legitimised. When this happens, public confidence in health authorities erodes,” they write.
They add: “The role of public health is not to override individual clinical judgment or the ethics that govern medical decision-making. This is essential because what once appeared self-evident can, on further testing, prove false – and what may appear to be ‘safe and effective’ for one individual may be harmful to another.”
The article has been welcomed by international medical experts who say rebuilding trust in public health institutions is essential.
“It might be impossible to go back in time and correct these major public health failings, which included support of futile and damaging vaccine mandates and lockdowns and provision of unsupported false and misleading claims regarding knowledge of vaccine efficacy and safety, but to start rebuilding public confidence in health authorities (is) the starting point,” said Dr Nikolai Petrovsky, Professor of Immunology and Infectious Disease, Australian Respiratory and Sleep Medicine Institute, Adelaide.
“This article is a scholarly and timely review of the public health principles that have been so clearly ignored and traduced. Without a complete apology and explanation we are doomed to pay the price for failure to take up the few vaccines that make a highly significant contribution to public health,” added Angus Dalgleish, Emeritus Professor of Oncology, St George’s University Hospital, UK.
By clicking the 'Subscribe’, you agree to receive our newsletter, marketing communications and industry
partners/sponsors sharing promotional product information via email and print communication from Garavi Gujarat
Publications Ltd and subsidiaries. You have the right to withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the
unsubscribe link in our emails. We will use your email address to personalize our communications and send you
relevant offers. Your data will be stored up to 30 days after unsubscribing.
Contact us at data@amg.biz to see how we manage and store your data.