Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

India's top court fines celebrated rights lawyer token one rupee

India's top court imposed a symbolic one rupee fine (one US cent) Monday on a celebrated public service lawyer for contempt in a case that raised concern about free speech in the world's largest democracy.

Prashant Bhushan said after the decision that he would pay the fine, but did not apologise for two tweets he wrote in June that were deemed critical of the judiciary -- including one showing a picture of the chief justice astride a Harley-Davidson motorbike.


The 63-year-old was found guilty of contempt by the court in August.

Following Monday's sentencing, Bhushan tweeted a photo of him holding a one rupee coin -- saying his lawyer and senior colleague Rajiv Dhavan had given him the money.

Bhushan was ordered to pay the fine by mid-September or face three months in jail and a suspension from the bar.

The case raised concerns about freedom of speech, but also was seen as a battle of wills in India's legal ether.

Bhushan is a vocal critic of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Hindu-nationalist government and over the years has filed a number of public interest cases and served pro bono in the trials of rights activists.

Hailing from legal blue blood, he studied at top Indian universities -- and Princeton in the US -- before embarking on a celebrated career at home.

Following the imposition of a coronavirus lockdown in March, Bhushan filed petitions concerning the plight of millions of migrant workers who were left without jobs.

In June he tweeted a picture of chief justice Sharad Arvind Bobde on a motorbike -- without a face mask and surrounded by people despite the coronavirus pandemic.

He accused him of hypocrisy at a time when the court was in lockdown, "denying citizens their fundamental right to access justice".

Bhushan was charged with contempt, but -- apparently keen to avoid a fuss -- the court offered him the chance to apologise and avoid punishment.

He refused, however, saying that would amount to "contempt of my conscience".

Bhushan was more contrite Monday, saying in a statement he never intended to disrespect the judiciary, but "merely meant to express my anguish, at what I felt, was a deviation from its sterling past record".

"Every Indian wants a strong and independent judiciary,", he said. "Obviously if the courts get weakened, it weakens the republic and harms every citizen."

Monday's sentence ended what some in the legal community increasingly saw as a circus, although the three-judge panel defended their decision.

"Freedom of expression is there, but rights of others should also be respected," said the bench, sitting without chief justice Bobde.

After last month's verdict, several lawyers and retired judges said it went against freedom of expression and called the contempt laws a colonial legacy.

Bhushan still faces a separate contempt charge over a 2009 media interview he gave in which accused judges of corruption.

That case will be heard on September 10.

More For You

ai-blackmail-students

'Blackmailers are taking images from school websites, using AI tools to manipulate them into illegal material'

Photo for representation: iStock

Schools warned to take down pupils' photos over 'AI blackmail threat'

  • Sextortion reports from under-18s rose 34 per cent last year
  • Schools are being advised to use blurred, distant or rear-facing photos — or none at all
  • One private school group has already redesigned its website to remove recognisable pupil images

SCHOOLS across the UK are being urged to remove pictures of pupils from their websites and social media pages after criminals used artificial intelligence to turn children's photos into sexually explicit images and demand money.

Child safety experts and the National Crime Agency have warned that blackmailers are taking images from school websites, using AI tools to manipulate them into illegal material, and then threatening to release them unless they receive a payment, reported the Guardian.

Keep ReadingShow less