Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Imran disappoints at Davos  

By Amit Roy


LAURENCE FOX is not the only one whose history needs a little brushing up. Pakistan prime minister Imran Khan’s grasp of the history of Kashmir appears to be one fed to him by the Pakistani military.

Imran was interviewed for Radio 4’s Today programme by Mishal Husain in Davos. He wanted to only talk Kashmir, but she asked about the incarceration of thousands of Chinese Muslims in Xinjiang.

“At the moment, I did not know enough about it,” he replied. “If I have, we will speak to the Chinese privately because that’s how the Chinese are.”

This is not a defence of Indian prime minister Narendra Modi’s Kashmir policy or his Citizenship (Amendment) Act or the National Register of Citizens, which have been met with protests across India.

But negotiations between Pakistan and India are not going to be helped by Imran comparing the Modi government to the Nazis. On nearly the eve of Holocaust Day, his comments were unworthy of a head of government.

Imran launched into a familiar rant on Kashmir, accompanied with the implied threat of nuclear war.

Unfortunately for him, he is seen more as a mouthpiece for the generals and not taken too seriously. If he were, the US, which has not forgotten where Osama bin Laden found shelter, would wonder about Pakistan’s possession of nuclear weapons.

India and Pakistan should talk about trade and peopleto-people contact, not Kashmir, which will remain divided along the Line of Control.

More For You

Shabana Mahmood’s hard line on asylum risks repeating Tory failures

Mahmood's plans are uncannily similar to Priti Patel’s new asylum law in 2022

Getty Images

Shabana Mahmood’s hard line on asylum risks repeating Tory failures

Shabana Mahmood is already the third British Asian woman to be a home secretary talking tough on asylum. That shows how much ethnic diversity in high office has accelerated. No Asian woman had ever been an MP before Mahmood and Priti Patel were elected in May 2010. But that Mahmood is so closely following Patel’s agenda now casts doubt on how far the Labour government’s new asylum proposals can deliver control in the Channel or rebuild public confidence in the system.

Mahmood’s core mission is to grip the asylum issue: she declares her reforms to be the most significant since the 1950s. Yet, they are uncannily similar to Priti Patel’s new asylum law in 2022 – which also proposed asylum seekers getting only 30 months of temporary protection. Suella Braverman then went even further – pledging that no asylum claims would get heard at all. By memory-holing these efforts, Mahmood misses crucial lessons of why they failed. If “pull factors” of the UK asylum design were the key to small boat arrivals, Patel and Braverman would have stopped the boats before the election.

Keep ReadingShow less