Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Crime victims fear police ‘informers’

by NADEEM BADSHAH

MIGRANTS who have been victims of serious crimes are not reporting their experiences to the police because of fears of that data being shared with immigration officials.


Campaigners have warned that some men and women who have suffered attacks – including domestic violence, robbery, sex attacks or assaults – or those who have been a witness are not coming forward due to fears of ending up in a detention centre or being deported.

It comes as watchdogs are set to probe the police in England and Wales over the sharing of data on victims and witnesses of crime with immigration enforcement authorities.

Human rights groups Liberty and Southall Black Sisters (SBS) lodged the first super­complaint against the police over the “draconian” practice which sparked the investigation by the Inspectorate of Constabulary, the College of Policing and the Independent Office for Police Conduct.

Pragna Patel, director of SBS, told Eastern Eye: “The practice instils fear in the group of vulnerable migrant women that we work with and deters those women from reporting abuse.

“It is part of the government’s inhumane and hostile approach to immigration, but it directly contravenes the government’s obligations to protect women subject to domestic violence or other forms of harm.”

Patel added: “We would like to see an open and transparent investigation into how and why the police and immigration officials decided to adopt the policy and practice, allowing the sharing of information about immigration involving vulnerable people and abused women.

“This is, by all accounts, a draconian policy that has civil liberties and human rights implications, making it unlawful.”

The investigation may result in inspections or recommendations, which may include a public body that is better placed to deal with the issue.

Harjap Singh Bhangal, a leading immigration solicitor, told Eastern Eye: “I’m often called out to police stations where the person who has been a victim of crime or wrongly arrested, but who has been found to have no leave to remain is held in detention for immigration reasons.

“The police checks the status of the person and then holds them, pending the arrival of the UK Border Force.

“People stopped for minor traffic offences have ended up in immigration detention for months due to this process.

“As a result, many migrants are not reporting crimes when they are victims, because they fear ending up in a detention centre despite having been victims of domestic violence, robbery, sexual offences and assault.

“A police station should be seen a safe haven for victims of crimes. However, for many migrants who don’t have valid visas, it is often associated with being referred onto the UK Border Force and hence a lot of crime against migrants now goes unreported”.

After discovering that forces were likely to face a challenge over their tactics, the National Police Chiefs Council issued guidance in December, including a ban on officers checking the police national computer solely to determine if someone had leave to remain in the UK.

Officers will also be barred from passing on information about people suspected of being in the country illegally to authorities if they come forward as victims of crime.

Debaleena Dasgupta, a lawyer for Liberty, said: “Not only are those victims prevented from accessing justice, but others with insecure status feel too afraid to come forward for fear of similar treatment. There is a real concern that witnesses may also not feel able to report what they have seen, preventing investigation of other crimes.

“As a result, perpetrators are not investigated and are left free to commit further crimes, both against the same victims and potentially other people. This is an urgent issue of public safety. Some police officers are acting as de facto immigration officers, instead of public protectors.”

She added: “The new guidance doesn’t stop officers passing details of victims to the Home Office. It merely delays that data sharing.

“So, victims with insecure immigration status have every reason to continue fearing to report crimes or come forward as witnesses, because immigration enforcement will follow later rather than at the start.”

Chief constable Shaun Sawyer, the National Police Chiefs Council’s lead officer on modern slavery and organised immigration crime, said it was “imperative that we were clear that the role of the police and immigration enforcement are different”.

He added: “We had an inappropriate relationship with immigration enforcement whereby, by proxy, we were helping to kick people out of the country.

“There were a handful of cases that showed the relationship was too close and could not be tolerated. We are not a branch of immigration enforcement, we deal with crime and vulnerability.”

More For You

Streeting hails India’s global role as Labour backs bilateral relations

Wes Streeting addresses the Republic Day reception at the Guildhall in London last Tuesday (28),joined by Sir Lindsay Hoyle and Vikram Doraiswami

Streeting hails India’s global role as Labour backs bilateral relations

WES STREETING spoke of the priority prime minister Sir Keir Starmer and the Labour government attach to relations with India when he addressed a Republic Day reception at the Guildhall in London last Tuesday (28).

But the secretary of state for health and social care won over the large Indian crowd by paying an unexpected tribute to Rishi Sunak.

Keep ReadingShow less
Sri Lanka seeks to negotiate with Adani over renewable energy plants

Gautam Adani

Sri Lanka seeks to negotiate with Adani over renewable energy plants

SRI LANKA’S government started talks with India’s Adani Group to lower the cost of power from two wind power projects the group will build in the island nation’s northern province, the cabinet spokesman said last Tuesday (28).

Sri Lanka has been reviewing the group’s local projects after US authorities in November accused billionaire founder Gautam Adani and other executives of being part of a scheme to pay bribes to secure Indian power supply contracts. Adani has denied the allegations.

Keep ReadingShow less
Badenoch proposes stricter citizenship rules for all migrants

Kemi Badenoch delivers speech on January 16, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

Badenoch proposes stricter citizenship rules for all migrants

CONSERVATIVE PARTY on Thursday (6) proposed a clampdown on all migrants by tightening citizenship rules and barring social benefit claimants from residency rights.

Kemi Badenoch, who took over from Rishi Sunak in November last year, outlined her first major policy agenda as Tory leader in a move seen as an attempt to win back the support of Conservative voters drawn to the far-right anti-immigrant Reform party.

Keep ReadingShow less
Pakistan court gives unusual punishment to Youtuber Rajab Butt for owning lion cub

Pakistani zookeeper Mohammad Amir holds the confiscated lion cub at Lahore’s safari zoo last Tuesday (28)

Pakistan court gives unusual punishment to Youtuber Rajab Butt for owning lion cub

A PAKISTANI YouTube star who was gifted a lion cub on his wedding day avoided jail after promising a judge to upload animal rights videos for a year.

Rajab Butt has one of the largest online followings in south Asia, and his week-long nuptials in December were plastered over celebrity gossip websites.

Keep ReadingShow less
Theft and violence in retail shops hit record high in 2024

The Labour government has pledged to address the rise in retail crime through stronger measures to tackle shoplifting and anti-social behaviour

iStock

Theft and violence in retail shops hit record high in 2024

THEFT and violence against retail workers in Britain soared to record levels last year, driven partly by criminal gangs, and are “out of control”, according to a report last Thursday (30).

The British Retail Consortium's annual crime survey found that more than 20 million thefts occurred in the year to August 31, 2024 – an average of 55,000 a day – costing retailers £2.2 billion.

Keep ReadingShow less